The Devil Wears Church's?

Polly white.JPGGood finance fiction is apparently very difficult to produce. Otherwise there’d be more of it. We’ve got a couple of books by Tom Wolfe, some of Scott Fitzgerald’s stuff and, well, that’s about it. So we were thrilled when we caught wind of Golden Handcuffs, a new novel due out in a couple of months from a twenty-something refugee from an investment bank in London.

But there was something odd about the story. To begin with, we’d never heard of Polly Courtney until earlier today when DealBook took notice of an item on HereIsTheCity, which was itself pointing to an article published in the English newspaper The Observer. Any trail that leads through two blogs and an English newspaper deserves at least a bit of skepticism.

What’s more, none of the folks involved mentioned a publisher. If you are an author for a major publishing house, one of the things you learn rather quickly is that it is a good idea to mention your publisher when discussing your book. You know, because it’s a good idea to tell booksellers where to order your book. And, well, the publishers like it and they’re the ones paying you to write.

So we did some digging. WallStFolly had discovered Miss Polly’s website—where, by the way, she castigates Helen Green’s £800,000 win against Deutsche Bank—and so we looked for information on the publisher there. It seems her book is being published by Troubador, which describes itself as “the leading Italian Studies publisher in the UK and publish an expanding academic research journals programme.” That’s odd. Why would they publish a roman a clef about working in finance?

The answer may be contained in the next sentence of Troubador self-description: “We also run a self-publishing programme for authors of any subject under our Matador imprint.” So is Miss Polly’s book being self-published? There’s nothing wrong with self-publishing but we find it extraordinary that a roman a clef about a young girl in finance couldn’t find a mainstream publisher. A young girl lost amidst the sharks of The City? We cannot imagine publishers wouldn't be climbing over each other for it.

But they aren't. This suggests three possibilities. One, Miss Polly’s book is very, very bad indeed. Two, there is some grand conspiracy in London with publishers suppressing possibly embarrassing books about their financial institutions. Or, three, Miss Polly is just an enthusiast for self-publishing and wanted to go it alone.

Comments

Posted by Now it makes sense, Aug 30, 2006 9:43AM

I was wondering why nothing appeared when I searched the book on Amazon.com (not even Amazon.co.uk)

Posted by London Bunny, Aug 30, 2006 10:02AM

Er, it's not out until November so maybe that's why Amazon isn't selling it yet...

Surely a self-published book on the City is more likely to tell it as it is, without being dumbed down by some publically-owned publishing company thinking only of its shareholders and its bottom line??

I'm looking forward to reading the book!

Posted by Elizabeth Spiers, Aug 30, 2006 11:40AM

Books are always on Amazon well before they're out, and never *after* they're out (which hers is; she says it won't be listed till January). For example: Ex-banker Dana Vachon's novel, Mergers & Acquisitions is already available on Amazon:
http://www.amazon.com/Mergers-Acquisitions/dp/1594489343/sr=8-2/qid=1156952286/ref=sr_1_2/002-4464820-8874439?ie=UTF8
It's not out until April. Publishers want people to pre-order.

Also - publishers want stuff that will sell, not stuff that won't offend people. Scandal is much better for the bottom line than fluff.

Posted by john taylor, Sep 08, 2006 9:12PM

Seems strange to castigate an author for trying to generate some publicity for a new book? If the observer are interviewing her, ther must be something to it. Nice of you to guess that it's "very, very bad indeed" without reading it yet...

Posted by john taylor, Sep 08, 2006 9:13PM

Seems strange to castigate an author for trying to generate some publicity for a new book? If the observer are interviewing her, there must be something to it. Nice of you to guess that it's "very, very bad indeed" without reading it yet...

Posted by Steve Bank, Sep 13, 2006 6:18AM

"A young girl lost amidst the sharks of The City? We cannot imagine publishers wouldn't be climbing over each other for it."

Really? Maybe thats why there is not more of it. Maybe it's not that "Good finance fiction is apparently very difficult to produce." but maybe it's due to the fact that publishers don't see a huge market for people reliving semi-factual events.

We all know that our business is run a certain way, and we all accept it. But how many people out there would buy a book where we show what really goes on in "the city" especially if it doesn't end in the 20 something girl cracking the deal of the century?

The realism is, that a story can only go one of threee ways. "Wall Street", "Secret of my success", or true to life in teh city. The realism is that the first two are 80s movies and the later is a genre that so far has about 4 books.

I have to whole heartedly stand behind the author here, and say that it's probably a publisher issue. But I for one will be buying the book on Amazon, especially as it's self published, and not inspite of it.

Steve Bank

Footnote: And as for Miss Courtney's stance on Helen Green, the point she made is perfectly valid. She suggested that the working enviroment in the city brings with it some pluses and minuses. Both are well documented and known by most before going in (they may even be known by more if there were more books). It's not that Miss Courtney suggests that bullying or harrasment is ok, it's just that she feels that what transpired did not fall into that category, and it was only persieved to be that way because the person complaining was a woman. This is a view shared by almost every lady working in the city that I have spoken to.

Posted by Anon, Sep 20, 2006 9:14AM

It's now available on amazon to pre-order

Posted by Michael Johnson, Sep 07, 2007 9:05AM

Great article, it has been a good read.

Mike
www.regentstreetpress.com

Post Your Comment