It’s nice to see that HBS draws the line somewhere. It absolutely will NOT admit people who succumb to the temptation of finding out if they get accepted early (119 people were denied admission as a result of that fracas). It will admit people, however, who have a record of potential human rights abuses. A number of human rights activists are complaining about Harvard’s admission of Gabriel Ashkenazi, a 2004 graduate of HBS. Ashkenazi was recently appointed the chief of staff of the Israeli Defense Forces. Before his stint in the states he had a major role in the construction of the barrier separating Israeli settlements from the rest of the West Bank and also in Israel’s 22 year occupation of Southern Lebanon.
The individuals from the activist groups are alleging that Ashkenazi’s supervisory role in Israel’s South Lebanon Army gives him de facto responsibility for the maintenance of the Khiam Detention Center, which is alleged to be Israel’s very own version of Abu Ghraib. I’m not one to judge, and I’m sure Ashkenazi didn’t write his essay on beating prisoners held without trail (as much of a unique journey of self-discovery that that entails). Harvard, of course, is remaining mum. Getting the school to actually issue a statement is about as likely as getting it to disclose dubious off the books partnerships with energy companies and to admit that Jeff Skilling was a huge toolbox, even before his days of white collar crime.
Criticism Flies Over HBS Alum – [Harvard Crimson]






Posted by Shalom , Feb 06, 2007 12:20PM
Keith,
You are indeed not one to judge.
Apparently you are one to compare a military leader with a convicted felon.
Let us recall the reasons for the invasion of Lebanon and the construction of the barrier. Were the 40 people blown up as they sat down to Passover not enough?
"A record of potential human rights abuses?" Please consider the source.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/alan-dershowitz/the-human-rights-watch-_b_27701.html
http://www.nysun.com/article/37473
Posted by Jay , Feb 06, 2007 1:10PM
Seriously. I don't read dealbreaker for political commentary. Human rights abuses? How is constructing a wall to keep out suicide bombers somehow a human rights abuse. You're an idiot. And whats more is, you're an idiot.
Posted by Keith Hahn , Feb 06, 2007 1:24PM
I was expecting the backlash from people not reading carefully - it's not commentary on my part. Just pointing out the current complaint by the organizations and individuals. Again, I am not judging on what constitutes human rights abuses, and am careful to point out the "alleged" nature of the protest's claims. The barrier is considered by some organizations to be not exactly kosher. I didn't make that up, nor am I throwing in my two cents as to whether I agree with it or not. Write to those actually making that commentary.
Posted by R. Welch , Feb 06, 2007 1:38PM
I think KH is being fair, for once, and it's the "activist groups" that we should confront. Anyway, the barrier is a great idea. Come to think of it, we could use a barrier on our very own US-Mexico border.
Posted by , Feb 06, 2007 2:00PM
Keith,
I think we both were disappointed in our expectations.
The barrier is indeed considered by some organizations not to be kosher. Then again, there are many who consider it to be completely kosher.
That part is missing from your unbiased / non-judgemental commentary. Why?
Since when is being on military assignment for a democratic country considered a possible human rights violation ("22 year occupation")? He has been accused of funding militias in Lebanon? To fight who, Hezbollah, funded by. . . ?
You imply that Harvard should issue a statement - about both the "allegation" in the media against Ashkenazi and the "conviction" in a court of law Skilling.
That the school should be responsible for the actions of it's alumni is questionable at best. Your assertion that the two stories warrant comparison is downright biased.
Posted by blah , Feb 06, 2007 2:02PM
Hopefully when he is successful at destroying the enemies (that is if they don't finish destroying themselves (e.g. Gaza)), he can say "I was able to succeed because I used at HBS."
Then the lefty-activist-wackos will boycott Harvard (including the tenured idiots in the other schools) thus turning Harvard back into the great school it once was :)
Posted by Bulging Bracket , Feb 06, 2007 3:46PM
I dearly hope that anti-semites and lefties will boycott HBS. Too many idiots at Moscow on the Charles, even at the B-school.
It's wonderful that the IDF is getting advanced training for its senior leadership. Anyone that is upset, in an auproar, or thinks that this is controversial can FOAD. A wall that has been effective at nearly eliminating suicide bombings is a war crime? That tells you all you need to know about the complainers - they are Jihadists just like Jimmuh "I'm afraid of rabbits" Al-Carter.