Goldman Loses Charity Trading Event Due To Lack Of Frontrunning Opportunities

Non-profit organization Junior Achievement of New York, which places volunteers in NYC and Long Island class rooms to “teach students about their role in society and how to successfully navigate their futures,” held its annual Stock Market Challenge last night. The fundraiser, sponsored this year by Merrill Lynch, simulates 60 days of trading, with teams (from banks and other businesses) being issued $500,000 in mock dollars that they use to purchase fake stocks before the “opening bell.” They then buy and sell through a “floor trader,” several of which roam the room taking orders. All proceeds go to funding JANY’s programs. Unfortunately, we weren’t invited. Luckily, one participant took copious notes. Normally we’d make you wait for the results (as you would expect, ranking from first to last place is determined by how much "money" each team has at the end), but they’re too hilarious—and telling—not to put out there up front. (You’ll note that Citi did not place in the Top Ten, which had less to with lacking skills and more to with neither participating nor donating to the event, because it was awake at the office doing work.)


1. Best Buy (1)
2. WaMu
3. Merrill
4. Deloitte
5. Keyspan (1)
6. Goldman (2)
7. KPMG
8. Best Buy (2)
9. Keyspan (2)
10. (I forget, but not a big-dog)
11. Pitney Bowes
.......
19. Goldman (2)

Some additional points of interest:

- Last night’s win by Best Buy’s A-Team (B-Team came in 8th, still beating Goldman by a long shot) represented its third straight 1st place finish in as many years.

- Both Best Buy teams were wearing their trademark blue shirts; the Goldmans wore suits, in addition to their cloaks of failure.

- Man from MetLife yelling at the bartender, “Just give me a fucking Amstel if you don’t have fucking Budweiser! I got 30 seconds before opening bell!”

- Deloitte employees stealing intel from a team that didn’t show up. (Each team was given a package that included “paperwork,” two "Press Release" tags (providing news on the mock stocks through the weeks) and five "Portfolio Summary" tags.))

- One of the volunteer traders telling a Merrill guy to "fuck off" for getting spit in his ear while shouting trades.

- The fact that Merrill’s third place finish represented a tremendous improvement from last year, when it came in 21st place (out of 24 teams).

- Everyone putting down their heads and walking out of the room in (near) tears, while the Best Buy Geek Squad guys showered each other with praises, while high-fiving and chest bumping.

Comments

Posted by golden girl, May 13, 2008 1:08PM

Huh?

Posted by guest, May 13, 2008 1:16PM

floor brokers? What? No algos?

Posted by guest, May 13, 2008 1:19PM

Best Buy, nice double entendre.

Sidenote, the #19 GS team must have been the Global Alpha PMs.

Posted by lift all the offers, May 13, 2008 1:20PM

Hope the talented Best Buy team enjoy their pretend money as much as they enjoy pretending they are going to their pretend home in Greenwich or their pretend home in the Hamptons, driving their pretend high-end luxury car.

Posted by guest, May 13, 2008 1:20PM

What's this list? Is #1 the winner?

Posted by girl, May 13, 2008 1:27PM

@ 1:20

Please, they take their pretend helicoptor out to the hamptons- weeee!

Posted by guest, May 13, 2008 1:32PM

@1:20 - you can't tell whether the team ranked #1 on a list of results is the winner? With such math and comprehension skills, you'd be a shoo-in to work at Goldman.

Posted by guest, May 13, 2008 1:34PM

Now the liitle financiers will want to do 130/30 homework and port alpha to school.

Posted by guest, May 13, 2008 1:40PM

Wait..it wouldn't be a real contest unless the little junior deskheads called each other the night before and discussed the "time and signal" before running a stock the way they wanted it to go.

Posted by big r, May 13, 2008 1:43PM

@ girl - continued from the morning bell. how far downtown do you want round II to be?

@ golden girl - did you have an enjoyable 8-9pm last night?

Posted by girl, May 13, 2008 1:56PM

@ big r - anal_yst and i were just discussing- pretty far downtown & as long as its outdoors.

Posted by Anal_yst, May 13, 2008 2:05PM

Just pick east-side (Seaport area?) or West side (Pj clarks?), unless you all wanna do it up straight alky style @ Kalarney (sp?) Rose.

Posted by HAM05, May 13, 2008 2:11PM

http://www.alllooksame.com/register.php

user name: stromblarney
pw: dungeons

the hardest exam ive ever taken.

Posted by guest, May 13, 2008 2:13PM

bess, i'll be honest, you explained this process pretty shittily. were there actual midgets trading or just fake ones with dehabilitating meth dependencies?

-chad

Posted by guest, May 13, 2008 2:17PM

@chad-- can you read? "Unfortunately, we weren’t invited."

Posted by girl, May 13, 2008 2:21PM

straight up alkifarianism regardless-
westside.

Posted by american bandersnatch, May 13, 2008 2:59PM

ham 'o5 - it is difficult, but what's the point?

Posted by golden girl, May 13, 2008 3:01PM

@big r: I have to say, I was a little let down. I was hoping for a more creative reveal. That being said, the fact that Chuck lost his v-card to Georgie was gold. And the I-bankers at PJ Clarkes line was a good one.

I was just hoping for more of, you know, an actual murder.

Or at least for Chuck and Blair to totally team up on Georgarah.

Posted by HAM05, May 13, 2008 3:30PM

@ab - the point is to highlight and reaffirm the fact that all asians do, in fact, look the same

no point - just a distraction from the day...

Posted by american bandersnatch, May 13, 2008 3:37PM

ah ok. But would you be able to distinguish between a selection of Limeys, Krauts and Frogs? I would imagine they would all look the same as well.

Posted by guest, May 13, 2008 4:03PM

Limeys are the drunks,
Krauts are the master race (standind like they have a pole up the ass) and the frogs look like euro trash and gesture a great deal. The whites and jews both look very similiar (and very different from The Poors).

Posted by big r, May 13, 2008 4:19PM

@ girl & anal_yst - i'll make the trip just let me know where.

@ golden - ive been asked to not make bess' posts a gg discussion board and to "take that shit to the community section". so i'll just say that b, n, and c's "non-juding breakfast club" scene was great.

Post Your Comment