Who Killed Bear Stearns And Then Laughed About It At Denny's? We're Gonna Go With NO ONE

Bryan Burrough's Vanity Fair article on the downfall of Bear Stearns took nearly 16 pages to get to what most would regard as the mother of all ledes, wherein he casually mentions it is believed that a bunch of hedge fund managers "wanted [Bear] to go down, and go down hard," naming Citadel and SAC Capital as suspects. Burrough's then goes on to add that after said managers supposedly spread the rumor that ultimately killed BSC, they "celebrated Bear's collapse at a breakfast that following Sunday and planned a similar assault on Lehman the next week." He leaves it that, presumably because a. he's writing a book that will include actual IM conversations between the interested parties, and will place Griffin, Cohen, et al at the scene of the crime, b. he doesn't have any other details because the breakfast, and the events leading up to it, never actually took place. or c. he's a man after our own heart, and likes to pepper his prose with fanciful fabrications, in which case he should've noted "Stevie-boy was distracted from the meaty conversation by the sheer pleasure of his 3-cheese Denver omelette." In any event, with all deference to Burrough, I call bull shit.

Let's just say they did spread the rumors, which I don't believe they did (and, as an aside: if a company can be brought down by the corporate equivalent of 7th grade girls passing notes in class, perhaps it doesn't deserve to be in existence anyway). There is no way in hell this meal took place. Ken Griffin and Steve Cohen are not stupid enough to go chest bump over egg McMuffins with the rotting corpse of Bear Stearns at their table (that kind of genius is-- or was-- reserved for the upper echelons of BSC management).

When you off someone, you go to a safe house, lay low and count your money. You don't run into the nearest bar with blood on your hands, wave the murder weapon around and go, hey everyone, look what I just did! Drinks for the house, put it on Bear Stearns! (Of course, on the very off-chance that this thing did go down, we want the dirt and we want it now. Waiters, sous chefs, people sitting at neighboring tables-- give us a call.) And confidential to Ken and Steve: unlike a shithouse mouse like Vanity Fair, you will get a fair hearing from the reasoned and conscientious phoney reporters at DealBreaker. If you want to get your side of the story out there, do not hesitate to get in touch. 203-890-2000. I'm a good listener.

Bringing Down Bear [Vanity Fair]

Comments

Posted by Lowly Assistant, Jul 01, 2008 11:40AM

In my humble opinion, I can't see Stevie letting guilt or blood take precedent over a dish of "Moons-over-MyHammy" (sans hammy, of course). A grand slam breakfast maybe, but not moons.

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 11:45AM

Anyone hear anything about fixed income layoffs yesterday at CS? Hear after it was completed they called everyone into a conf. room and swore people to secrecy.

Posted by big r, Jul 01, 2008 11:47AM

in season 2 of The Wire, ziggy sobotka would wave around his new money and not take the advice of his wise cousin nicky. at the end of the day, we all know how that turned out for young zig.

youre welcome bess

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 11:50AM

I heard RenTech has a time machine that Jim shares with SAC and Citadel. Who needs rumors! Get in the Delorean!

Posted by Clown Capital , Jul 01, 2008 11:58AM

Bessie! Are you kdding me?! Of course Cohen's involved! Didn't the town of Greenwich reject his property proposal of double-digit toilets in his McMansion?! Some of us celebrate with a cigar and a nice Moscato wine; Others(namely Cohen) want to build porcelain thrones and attempt to defacate in each one while reading about their conquered foe...

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 12:11PM

Who cares about the chest butting. I am really concerned about this phenomenon:

Have you noticed in all these stories that when the sh*t is hitting the fan, the powers that be all happen to be in some exotic location on vacation with their families? Fuld was in Europe, that JPM guy was in Antigua, Cayne was in Detroit(PSD holiday). Maybe... maybe that's why these firms are out of control. None of the CEOs are ever at the mahogany desk at 11pm on Friday night, picking up the phone!

Posted by Old Sneep, Jul 01, 2008 12:22PM

I heard in a bar in Queens that, years ago, some concrete laborer buried a JPMorgan Corporate Challenge T-shirt below the sub floor in the Bear Stearns HQ building!!! I swear it's true!!!

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 12:38PM

There's a one-legged hedge fund CEO who wants to buy Denny's and re-name it IHOP.

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 12:41PM

Um, Bess, hello? Those hedge funds are huge, with a ton of employees. It was a lot more likely that, if the victory breakfast really happened, it was among traders of the firms, who are hardly people that anyone would recognize. I think it's entirely credible. I also think that their bosses probably didn't know that they were the --> originators <-- of the rumors, rather than that they just hopped on the bandwagon.

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 1:04PM

BURN

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 1:04PM

BURN

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 1:04PM

BURN

Posted by AJ, Jul 01, 2008 1:05PM

I love Bess Levin

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 1:06PM

lol ... Bess, try the decaf! But even if they were hedge fund managers (read PMs), there's dozens of those! Traders and funds that are enthusiastically going short making trading bets on financials haven't had to exactly be the biggest cowboys in the past 9 months. Where's the fine line between hoping your big short position pans out, and hoping/trying/rumoring that the target of your short is in trouble? I guess that's why it's so hard to prove that aggressive trading can rise to the level of being "a concerted and colluded effort".

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 1:12PM

i heard that the celebrations weren't over a breakfast table but at a strip club in new york where these baller hedge-funders didn't stick $ bills into the panties strippers, but stuck shares of bear stearns and showered it on the strippers. it took a while for them to realize that it was worth a mere $2.

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 1:21PM

I'm not your friend, buddy!

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 1:24PM

I'm not your buddy, guy!

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 1:28PM

I'm not your guy, fwiend!

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 1:29PM

Ken Griffin's brother was with Bear Stearns for a long time and up to the end.

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 1:40PM

Hell hath no fury...

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 1:43PM

@ 1:29,

what about stevie cohen's brother?

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 1:46PM

where is alan schwartz, jimmy cayne and the ace greenberg these days? smoking up in Cayne's bathroom?

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 1:48PM

1:43 - Cohen's brother became his sister after he accidentally injected himself with too much estrogen to enhance his trading performance.

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 1:55PM

1.46 very clever and original

Posted by onetwo , Jul 01, 2008 1:55PM

As David Einhorn said (and BL beautifully alluded to) "If your company's balance sheet can't stand the scrutiny of people asking questions it probably is too highly leveraged to continue as an ongoing concern."

Someone please explain to me why any negative rumors are derided as illegal profiteering (ie, "Bear Stearns is too highly leveraged to continue doing business; if any of their major PB counterparties left they are fucked"), yet if i were to post "apple is coming out with a 600 jiggawaz time machine with 100% gross margins in the next six months...stock should hit 8,000 by 2H09" It's ok?

Posted by FUNdamental, Jul 01, 2008 2:04PM

@1-2 - because everyone is entitled to have their stocks go up. The market doesn't have downside risk, and if you lose money it is someone else's fault!

Blame the shorts, or speculators....orrrrr those DAMNED brown people in other countries!!!
Investments here only go down for one of those three reasons.

Posted by miami, Jul 01, 2008 2:13PM

I love the arrogance of the BSC execs continually:

1) telling the rest of the Street to go cuff themselves,

2) smoking pot, playing bridge, and sunning in Florida while Rome burns,

3) Not having anyone in Risk Mgmt know what the positions were

4) Having the guy supposedly in charge of knowing the positions not know them

5) Keeping their entire capital base in the hands of fast-money hedgies and overnite loans that can be pulled at any time,

6) Being shocked that firms may stop loaning you overnite money even though that's what killed Drexel, et al,

7) Shouting it... is... a... conspiracy! if anyone mentions that BSC is [was clearly] over-levered, or if they stop trading with them, or if they decide to stop lending them money, or if management is clueless, or if anyone notes you are lying to the press and your clients and employees, or if GS/CS/DB decide they are maxed out on BSC novation requests, or if they decide to ask any 'probing' questions like - do your counterparties think you will be in business next week?

8) Pretending that anyone needed to kill Bear Stearns, while BSC execs were busy getting shooting dope, borrowing from the mob, going on vacation with the proceeds, and committing suicide by not knowing what positions they had on or how risky they were or how much they were losing every day, as the smarter employees who could leave while the getting was good, left, while running a leverage ratio of THIRTY-FIVE TO ONE in less liquid assets than GS, JPM, MS, ML.

Nobody on WallSt interferes with a man who's busy killing himself. There's simply no need.

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 2:25PM

@fundamental....spot on.

and @onetwo....you just reminded how much I hate apple fanboys.

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 2:45PM

who's the hot new chick on cnbc? is this an attempt to cheer us all up?

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 3:02PM

cops come and try to snatch my crops

Posted by mrpink, Jul 01, 2008 3:08PM

JCay is coming over later on, we have to hotbox the new car.

I'll ask him what he thinks through the clouds.

-mrp

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 3:12PM

these pigs wanna blow my house down

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 3:19PM

@2:25 pip pip, cheerio.

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 3:46PM

While I do empathize for employees who lost most of their savings in this - Bear and the rest of the Street should be focused on one thing...how did this happen and how can they position so it doesn't happen again. If paper rumors can take you down, you weren't so solid in the first place. How about some real disclosure about what's on the books and where exactly the marks are set.

Rather than being greedy and leveraging to the hilt, how about building a sustainable business model that can handle some magnitude of risk? This was certainly the case, or at least far more so than today, when these firms existed as private partnerships - what's different now? Oh yes, accountability. Management - you are employees. Board - you are the owner's trusted steward and oversight. Both of you - corporate governance doesn't have autopilot. Do your job, use your brain, if you can't understand what's going on, get out.

Posted by Anal_yst, Jul 01, 2008 4:33PM

@ 3:46

While you're 100% correct, that'll never happen, no matter how much sense it makes.

Posted by Finnegan, Jul 01, 2008 5:41PM

"Insane in the membrane" said Cayne coming home on the plane.

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 7:01PM

The dumbest mother fucker on the tube is Chuck Gasbagarumor the Wind Man - named so for the wind he breaks instead of news. "Alls he says is we brook dat story, we brook dat story" Hey asshole, you beat a press release by 10 seconds. You couldn't break a fucking window with a bulldozer.

And,despite your supposed inside scoop from croney Dick Grasso (who uses you like the insecure fool that you are), you missed the real story this afternoon. There was no mention of his suit against the NYSE. That doesn't go away (like we wish you would). What a fucking dope you are to miss such an obvious pending matter. Come on up to our trading room and we will "breaka u face".

And, for your reading pleasure, check out the posting that Spitzer put out on this moron last night at 2am from another article. ROFL. You fucking dope.

The unfortunate reality of the CNBC impact on Bear is simple- Gasbagarumor. The guy milked Jimmy Cayne for years and then turned on him like he does all of his sources. They name Russell Sherman in the Vanity Fair article. Just ask Russell or his boss Elizabeth Ventura what they think of Gasbagarumor - the dumbest human being on television. The nicest thing they will call him is snake, scumbag, liar, moron and so on. They also make a very good point. Gasbag makes stories up for his own self promotion and frequently leaves out both sides of the story for his own personal benefit. He is as stupid as he is inarticulate and every pr person in the industry refuses to deal with the thug. Ditto for their bosses. In fact, Cayne, Thain, Mack, Diamon.....Blankfein, Niederauer,Dougan,.....think he is the scum of the earth and will fire any of their people who have anything to do with him. In fact, a number of industry folks have learned that lesson the hard way. You're FIRED! Are you listening Mike Mayo????

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 11:24PM

For what it's worth. There was not only that breakfast, but several face-to-face meetings of the three in the immediate period prior the take-down. If these people weren't planning and working in tandem, why the need for these in-person meetings?
None of these facts really matter anyway because the parameters are such, that it would take all three to voluntarily write confessions written in their own blood and take them by hand to the nearest SEC office and only then, might there be any hope of a hand-slap. This has been going on for years, only on a much smaller scale. Anyone familiar with the situation knows
what happened here.

Posted by guest, Jul 01, 2008 11:38PM

Correction, the meetings took place between two of the three mentioned.

Posted by merkin capital partners, Jul 01, 2008 11:46PM

I'm just glad someone focused on the plausibility of the group being recognized at Denny's.

Though unable to recognize sarcasm and dangerous behind the wheel, you guests still can serve a purpose. Don't go dying on me!

Post Your Comment