While there are many sectors of the financial services industry that likely feel they were on the losing end of yesterday’s 80+ page regulatory reform proposal, there was one true winner- the rating agencies. In fact, the proposal has arguably strengthened their position. The proposal does not address the misalignment of interests between the agencies and issuers, but does recommend less reliance on ratings alone when making investment/credit decisions while remaining silent on encouraging new firms to enter the market.
So, in effect, the proposal recognizes the ratings are worthless and shouldn’t be relied on but doesn’t want any new competitors who might be slightly more competent to add a shred of legitimacy to the process and capitalize on the quid-pro-quo fee arrangement which will remain intact. It looks like the proposal’s subtitle, A New Foundation: Rebuilding Financial Supervision and Regulation, needs an overhaul of its own.
Overhaul Leaves Rating Agencies Largely Untouched [NYT]
— Advertisement —
2467Comments (15)http%3A%2F%2Fdealbreaker.com%2F2009%2F06%2Frating-agencies-emerge-victorious-from-regulatory-overhaul%2FRating+Agencies+Emerge+Victorious+From+Regulatory+Overhaul2009-06-18+15%3A12%3A17Greg+Michaelshttp%3A%2F%2Fwp.dealbreaker.com%2F2009%2F06%2Frating-agencies-emerge-victorious-from-regulatory-overhaul%2F
Leave a comment
You can log in with your account or comment as a guest below.
- Use the Bloomberg command
NH BLG_DEALBREAKER <GO>
to access Dealbreaker Contact Us
Editorial Staff
- Executive Editor
- Bess Levin
- Editor
- Matt Levine
How Can We Help You?
- Send tips to:
tips@dealbreaker.com - For tech issues email:
web@dealbreaker.com - For advertising or events email:
advertising@breakingmedia.com - For research or custom solutions email:
services@breakingmedia.com
- Dealbreaker is published by Breaking Media.
For a full list of our sites, services and staff visit breakingmedia.com
Markets

Coked up Laser shark misses the muffster.
That is one douchy piece of clipart.
Coked up Laser shark misses the muffster.
BLANUS!
My laser cat double posted.
- Laser Shark
Come on Greggers, don’t you know how to use the transparency tool in Powerpoint when copying a picture? For the love, get it together, rook. This is bush league!
6 I don’t know how to use it either. Thank god.
Does Powerpoint have an anal bleaching feature as well?
Greg,
You should have used a dash, not a hyphen.
Regards,
AIG
It ain’t the Government’s fault investors are lazy.
Greg, how exactly would competition between rating agencies make them any more legitimate or reliable?
Also, the picture for this post confirms what I’ve always suspected: Greg is an art school drop-out.
Shit. Macke’s car people argument is becoming more sane by the day. Nod your head if you understand.
The rating agencies do a decent job at the stuff they understand such as sovereign debt, municipal and corporate credit; but they should be banished from profiting in the structured finance market because they simply have no idea what they’re doing.
@13. If 2007-2009 are indicative, Wall Street has no idea what it is doing in the structured finance market either.
Glad I have been some help