News

If We’re Not Supposed To Care About What S&P Says, Why Do We Care When They Said It?

The FT today reports that the SEC is looking into whether there was insider trading based on leaks of S&P’s downgrade on Friday. Which is puzzling – who made S&P insiders?

There’s something going on here that is not quite an insider trading investigation. For one thing, there probably wasn’t insider trading. The SEC helpfully tells you that “Illegal insider trading refers generally to buying or selling a security, in breach of a fiduciary duty or other relationship of trust and confidence, while in possession of material, nonpublic information about the security.”

Let’s take a look at that, starting with “buying or selling a security.” What security? Normally, you’d think that advance notice of a downgrade would let you short the subject bonds and make money. Here, not so much. Treasury yields were up on Friday but spiked lower on Monday after the downgrade and closed well below where they started on Friday. So if you naïvely shorted Treasuries when you heard the rumor Friday morning, and closed out Friday afternoon, you could have done okay – but if you waited until the information became public to close the trade, which is the normal way to insider trade, you’d have lost money.*

The next requirement is that the trade come from a “breach of a fiduciary duty or other relationship of trust and confidence.” That is, it’s got to be inside information. Here there are no insiders – S&P had no relationship of trust with the U.S. government, and it knows nothing more about the creditworthiness of the U.S. government than anyone else. Probably less!.

The FT says “If the investigation results in a case, it would not be the first time government-related information leaked or a rating firm employee was charged with insider trading.” But we can’t find cases where a rater was charged for leaking ratings information. Previous ratings-agency charges seem to have been based on more traditional corporate information: an analyst was rating a company and leaked information about an upcoming merger – same as a banker or lawyer or Nasdaq markets intelligence officer who misuses client information.

That said, there is a famous precedent for non-insider trading being treated as insider trading – Wall Street Journal columnist R. Foster Winans leaked the contents of his upcoming columns, which were market-moving, and was arrested and convicted of insider trading. The Supreme Court ultimately upheld his conviction that this could be insider trading because he “misappropriated” information from the Journal, even though he had no inside information about any of the companies that his cronies traded on.

Note what the Supreme Court said about Winans’s column by the way:

Petitioner Winans was coauthor of a Wall Street Journal investment advice column which, because of its perceived quality and integrity, had an impact on the market prices of the stocks it discussed.

So … this would be different then? For this to be illegal insider trading, the downgrade would have to be “material,” and “perceived quality and integrity” is a good starting point for that. Why would you care what the S&P thinks? The agencies’ track record of predicting defaults is quite bad, to the point that an S&P rating creates anti-information by predicting default worse than debt-to-GDP ratios. And again, since Treasuries went up after the downgrade was released, one might reasonably conclude that investors are not all that moved by S&P’s sovereign rating prowess.

Oh, one more thing – the downgrade wasn’t all that nonpublic either. An S&P spokesman pointed out that they were pretty much jumping up and down to tell anyone who would listen about the impending downgrade:

“In our July 14, Credit Watch Negative announcement, we indicated that there was an at least 50% chance of a potential of downgrade if an agreement regarding the debt ceiling is reached, but does not change the trajectory of U.S. debt growth in the medium term. In addition, we published several reports and broadly communicated our views regarding the potential impact on other fixed income securities.”

So no clear trade, no insider information, nothing material or nonpublic – why is there an insider trading investigation again?

There isn’t. MarketWatch points us in what looks like the right direction:

At issue, in part, is a 2006 statute — the Credit Rating Agency Reform Act — that says a credit rating agency could have its licence registration revoked if it leaked information about its pending downgrade decision before making that information publicly available.

In other words, the SEC isn’t looking to catch insider traders – it’s looking for leverage to delegitimize S&P if it violated the rules that let it give “official” credit ratings. A telling fact is this, again from the FT:

The inquiry was made by the SEC’s examination staff, which has oversight of credit rating firms, one person familiar with the matter said. The exam staff can make referrals to the SEC’s enforcement division if it believes any laws have been violated, but the inquiry might not result in a referral.

But that’s not how actual insider trading investigations work. Market moving events – above all, corporate mergers – are announced all the time, and when they do the SEC regularly does a routine insider-trading check whether or not there’s any suspicious activity. They’ll ask everyone at the companies, and their banks and law firms, who knew about the deal, and then they’ll cross-check those people against the people and firms who traded ahead of the announcement. But as we recall even these routine checks are done by the enforcement division, not (say) the SEC’s corporate finance or M&A offices.

If the SEC were looking for insider trading, enforcement would be doing it. The fact that the credit-ratings overseers are doing the investigation suggests that … they’re looking for credit-ratings shenanigans. Meaning that hedge funds who bought or sold Treasuries or stocks or did whatever else on Friday – even if they had an inkling of the downgrade – shouldn’t be too worried. But Michael Moore should be pleased.

* Or you could have say shorted equities figuring that the downgrade would hurt investor confidence – but an enforcement action on that seems pretty tough since you could literally trade any stock on the leak, and you surely don’t have material nonpublic information about every stock. We’re sort of intrigued by this – has anyone ever been prosecuted for insider trading in equities based on leaked macro data?

119 comments
(hidden for your protection)
Show all comments

119 Responses to “If We’re Not Supposed To Care About What S&P Says, Why Do We Care When They Said It?”

  1. GUESST says:

    ML;DR

  2. guest says:

    Bring back Greg

    – Guy that tooled on Greggums mercilessly about his mom's easy virtue and meatloaf

  3. florida says:

    S&P will learn — small people in government with authority that far exceeds their ability (think TSA, SEC, any congressman) are not to be trifled with.

  4. suckmesideways says:

    stopped reading, too long, didn't laugh…

  5. why still here says:

    Matt….go to the fucking hamptons already

  6. Peter says:

    "Leak" is the first word that came to mind on friday evening when I saw the US downgrade news. The big market swing on thursday, 4th was way out of proportion to the alleged Italy and Spain concerns.
    The leak here could have happened at Geithner's office who had been going back and forth with S&P all of wednesday.
    But of course, crooks don't investigate themselves.

  7. Friday Night Blues says:

    Moo L; DR

  8. Guest says:

    Marcel Proust called, he wants his rights to the lengthiest prose back…

  9. BigjohnTparty says:

    GOD BLESS AMERICA!

  10. Guest says:

    There is a correlation between ratings and sovereign defaults. See the study below. Get the facts first.
    http://www.standardandpoors.com/ratings/articles/

  11. root of all evil says:

    FYI

    3 people will be investigated and likely charged by midweek.

    – MHP put holder and purveyor of likely useless info.

  12. 100wattWarlock says:

    Matt, the article makes for an interesting read. Please learn to use the word count function in your editor of choice or I'm going to have to start checking DB for the amusing pictures

    – guy who reads playboy for the articles

  13. Chancellor Kent says:

    Good article, but a bit slanted to say the least. Yes, we know where you stand. "It's not insider trading but, oh, by the way, the Supreme Court says stealing market moving information from a non-issuer is insider trading!" Let's be clear – it is certainly insider trading and it happened with certainty. We are not talking about a gradual decline since April. This was a 500 point drop on a "no market moving news" day that just so happened to be 24 hours before a major event. Please. The smart money knew exactly what was coming. The rest of us took a major hit unaware of what was to come. Integrity is everything in markets. We aren't Russia. The SEC is on exactly the right trail.

  14. Minty Dingleberry says:

    Only read the headline but yeah I think the S&P and all of their indices are hogwash.

    – Value manager trailing the benchmark by 300bps YTD

  15. fetQBI I appreciate you sharing this blog post.Really thank you! Really Cool.

  16. I truly appreciate this article.Thanks Again. Really Cool.

  17. Very neat blog.Thanks Again. Great.

  18. alcohol says:

    I think this is a real great blog article.Really looking forward to read more. Cool.

  19. Muchos Gracias for your blog.Much thanks again. Fantastic.

  20. steroids says:

    Really enjoyed this post.Much thanks again.

  21. I cannot thank you enough for the article. Really Cool.

  22. group on says:

    I loved your article post.Really looking forward to read more. Keep writing.

  23. This is one awesome post.Really looking forward to read more. Want more.

  24. I really like and appreciate your blog article.Really thank you! Really Great.

  25. Really informative article.Really thank you! Really Cool.

  26. I think this is a real great blog post.Really thank you! Fantastic.

  27. Muchos Gracias for your article post.Really looking forward to read more. Fantastic.

  28. I am so grateful for your blog.Much thanks again. Really Great.

  29. wow, awesome blog post.Really thank you! Really Cool.

  30. Major thankies for the article post.Thanks Again. Great.

  31. I truly appreciate this blog article.Really thank you! Great.

  32. I am so grateful for your article post. Great.

  33. Fantastic blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Cool.

  34. Thanks a lot for the article post.Really looking forward to read more. Really Great.

  35. Really enjoyed this post.Much thanks again.

  36. Appreciate you sharing, great post.Thanks Again.

  37. Im grateful for the post.Much thanks again. Really Great.

  38. zumba kurs says:

    Really enjoyed this article.Really thank you! Will read on…

  39. Great, thanks for sharing this post.Really thank you! Really Cool.

  40. A powerful share, I simply given this onto a colleague who was doing a little evaluation on this. And he the truth is purchased me breakfast because I discovered it for him.. smile. So let me reword that: Thnx for the deal with! But yeah Thnkx for spending the time to debate this, I really feel strongly about it and love reading more on this topic

  41. recipes says:

    I’m glad I found this very informative post. I appreciate recipes your blog a lot and always find it informative.

  42. chris papa says:

    GET NIKE NFL ONLINE SHOP INFORMATION PLEASE VISit http://nikenflonline.blogspot.com

  43. cd wallets says:

    You can definitely see your enthusiasm within the paintings you write. The arena hopes for even more passionate writers like you who aren’t afraid to mention how they believe. All the time go after your heart.

  44. Can I simply say what a aid to seek out someone who really knows what theyre speaking about on the internet. You definitely know find out how to carry a problem to gentle and make it important. Extra people must learn this and perceive this side of the story. I cant imagine youre no more well-liked since you definitely have the gift.

  45. SEO Basics says:

    I was just seeking this info for some time. After six hours of continuous Googleing, finally I got it in your web site. I wonder what is the lack of Google strategy that don’t rank this type of informative sites in top of the list. Normally the top sites are full of garbage.Please tell me that youre heading to keep this up! Its so superior and so important. I cant wait to read additional from you.

  46. Sweet blog! I found it while surfing around on Yahoo News. Do you have any suggestions on how to get listed in Yahoo News? I’ve been trying for a while but I never seem to get there! Appreciate it

  47. saldytuvai says:

    A powerful share, I simply given this onto a colleague who was doing a little evaluation on this. And he the truth is purchased me breakfast because I discovered it for him.. smile. So let me reword that: Thnx for the deal with! But yeah Thnkx for spending the time to debate this, I really feel strongly about it and love reading more on this topic

  48. A powerful share, I simply given this onto a colleague who was doing a little evaluation on this. And he the truth is purchased me breakfast because I discovered it for him.. smile. So let me reword that: Thnx for the deal with! But yeah Thnkx for spending the time to debate this, I really feel strongly about it and love reading more on this topic

  49. I am so grateful for your blog post. Much obliged.

  50. Thanks again for the article post.Really thank you! Keep writing.

  51. Moroccanoil says:

    I appreciate you sharing this article.Much thanks again. Fantastic.

  52. Car Cover says:

    Thanks a lot for the blog article.Thanks Again. Great.

  53. Hi Richard
    Welcome back
    No, neither have I.
    I just happened to read through something the other day, well, just one or 3 things in fact. I didn’t realise the impact it could have.
    It appears like it may be good for creating back links, I even thought of Squidoo Ezine blog. Will try it sometime amd see what happens.
    Dee

  54. you are really a good webmaster. The web site loading speed is amazing. It seems that you are doing any unique trick. Also, The contents are masterwork. you’ve done a fantastic job on this topic!

  55. I will immediately snatch your rss as I can not find your email subscription hyperlink or e-newsletter service. Do you’ve any? Please permit me understand so that I may just subscribe. Thanks.

  56. visitors says:

    One of the better to see anyone that I am many new for you to blogging as well as site-building and of course savored your blog. Most likely I’m about to bookmark your web site. You definitely include incredible content along with evaluations. Thank you for revealing your site internet site. http://www.phlebotomycertificationhq.com/

  57. Brilliant font collection and also thanks for your Facebook font

  58. SILKROAD says:

    We are happy to search out lots of tips the following within the offered, we want create more approaches to this consider, The idea mind-numbing to search out experienced individuals because of this make a difference, but you could be seen as you happen to be previously mindful what you might end up being talking about! We appreciate you expressing. http://www.silkroadgoldbuy.com

  59. Simply desire to say your article is as astonishing. The clearness in your post is simply great and i can assume you are an expert on this subject. Well with your permission allow me to grab your RSS feed to keep up to date with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please keep up the enjoyable work.

  60. Olen Agler says:

    I’m perpetually thought about this, appreciate it for posting .

  61. Whats Going down i am new to this, I stumbled upon this I’ve found It absolutely helpful and it has aided me out loads. I’m hoping to give a contribution & aid different users like its helped me. Great job.

  62. Click here says:

    I just could not leave your website before suggesting that I really loved the usual info a person provide on your visitors? Is going to be back incessantly to check up on new posts

  63. I just wanted to construct a brief comment in order to say thanks to you for the marvelous pointers you are sharing on this website. My time-consuming internet investigation has now been honored with useful strategies to share with my neighbours. I would suppose that many of us readers are truly endowed to live in a good community with so many brilliant people with beneficial tricks. I feel truly grateful to have discovered your webpages and look forward to so many more awesome minutes reading here. Thanks once more for a lot of things.

  64. I’d personally prefer to appreciate your discussing your own suggestions and positioning the time into the content articles an individual publish! I recently cannot go away your site ahead of indicating that we very appreciated the standard information someone offer you on your readers? Might be back on a regular basis in an effort to confirm up on brand-new content. http://www.silkroadgoldbuy.com/how-to-make-beaded-bracelets.html

  65. I do agree with all the concepts you have offered on your post. They are very convincing and can definitely work. Still, the posts are too brief for newbies. May just you please prolong them a little from next time? Thank you for the post.

  66. I merely couldn’t abandon your website in the past indicating which i tremendously seasoned the traditional data an individual produce with regards to your audience? I will go to return to their office again normally so that you can take a look at high on new posts. http://www.silkroadgoldbuy.com/mens-beaded-bracelets.html

  67. I merely discovered your blog post and desired to point out that I’ve genuinely enjoyed searching your website articles. A great site along with interesting content material, this is exactly what We need. In my opinion this article content here is rattling wonderful, appreciate it for the efforts. You must keep writing forever! http://www.autoglassrepairhq.info/

  68. Im attempting to be intelligent to enroll in the RSS feeds, except cannot figure it absent. Approximately assistance will ensue awesome Thanks

  69. Aw, this was a really nice post. In thought I want to put in writing like this moreover – taking time and actual effort to make an excellent article… but what can I say… I procrastinate alot and under no circumstances appear to get something done.

  70. Great blog! Do you have any tips for aspiring writers? I’m hoping to start my own website soon but I’m a little lost on everything. Would you advise starting with a free platform like WordPress or go for a paid option? There are so many choices out there that I’m totally overwhelmed .. Any ideas? Appreciate it!

  71. crork says:

    bVF68S I am so grateful for your blog post.Much thanks again. Keep writing.

  72. I value the article.Really looking forward to read more. Cool.

  73. Very good article.Much thanks again. Cool.

  74. click here says:

    I really enjoy the blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Fantastic.

  75. entrepreneur says:

    Thanks a lot for the blog post.Much thanks again. Really Cool.

  76. business says:

    Wow, great article.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.

  77. Really appreciate you sharing this blog post.Much thanks again. Fantastic.

  78. Great, thanks for sharing this article post. Will read on…

  79. erotismo says:

    I think this is a real great article post.Really thank you! Great.

  80. Spanish says:

    Really informative blog article.Thanks Again. Will read on…

  81. This is one awesome blog.Really looking forward to read more. Want more.

  82. massage says:

    Thanks a lot for the blog.Really thank you! Much obliged.

  83. tea tree oil says:

    Im grateful for the post.

  84. Very neat blog article.Much thanks again. Want more.

  85. Appreciate you sharing, great blog post. Great.

  86. Really enjoyed this blog.Thanks Again. Great.

  87. I appreciate you sharing this blog post.

  88. best vpn says:

    A big thank you for your blog post.Thanks Again. Keep writing.

  89. I loved your article post.Really looking forward to read more. Great.

  90. Online TV says:

    I really liked your blog article. Cool.

  91. Thanks-a-mundo for the blog article.

  92. Great article post.Really thank you! Really Cool.

  93. This is one awesome article.Really looking forward to read more. Great.

  94. Great blog post.Much thanks again.

  95. Thanks for the article.Really thank you! Keep writing.

  96. Say, you got a nice blog post.Much thanks again. Really Cool.

  97. Major thankies for the article.Much thanks again. Great.

  98. save water says:

    Thanks again for the article.Really thank you!

  99. TrapStep says:

    Major thanks for the blog article. Will read on…

  100. Very neat article post.Really thank you! Cool.

  101. Muchos Gracias for your article post.Thanks Again. Much obliged.

  102. bath mate says:

    I am so grateful for your blog post.Thanks Again. Fantastic.

  103. Really enjoyed this blog article.Thanks Again. Really Great.

  104. I really liked your blog.Thanks Again.

  105. Im grateful for the blog.Thanks Again. Much obliged.

  106. I appreciate you sharing this post.Thanks Again. Will read on…

  107. A big thank you for your blog post. Cool.

  108. Very good blog.Thanks Again. Great.

  109. Great, thanks for sharing this post.Really thank you! Really Cool.

  110. baby care says:

    I truly appreciate this article post.Much thanks again. Cool.

  111. chinese says:

    wow, awesome article post.Thanks Again. Will read on…

  112. PTFE SHEET says:

    HI, Thank for your blog. I love your blog. Hope more !! [url=http://www.PTFE-SHEET.com]PTFE SHEET[/url] [url=http://www.AUTAI.com]PTFE[/url]

  113. Really appreciate you sharing this post.Thanks Again. Really Cool.

  114. Major thankies for the article post.Thanks Again. Awesome.

  115. Really informative blog.Much thanks again. Fantastic.

  116. Thank you for your post.Really thank you! Really Cool.

  117. I loved your article post.Really thank you! Fantastic.

  118. więcej says:

    Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wished to say that I’ve truly enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again very soon!

Our Sites

  • Above the Law
  • How Appealing
  • ATL Redline
  • Breaking Defense
  • Breaking Energy
  • Breaking Gov
  • Dealbreaker
  • Fashonista
  •