SEC Is Going To Take Your High Frequency Trading Algorithm, Run It On A Commodore 64, See If It Crashes The Market

After decades of responding to tips about fraud by writing notes on napkins and then throwing them away, the Securities and Exchange Commission finally got itself some computers and is excited to put them to use. Legitimate use. First up: figure out if maybe the computers are in fact the problem.

U.S. securities regulators have taken the unprecedented step of asking high-frequency trading firms to hand over the details of their trading strategies, and in some cases, their secret computer codes.

The requests for proprietary code and algorithm parameters by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), a Wall Street brokerage regulator, are part of investigations into suspicious market activity, said Tom Gira, executive vice president of FINRA’s market regulation unit….

SEC examiners want the information to ensure that hedge funds are actually using the strategies they market to investors. They also review it to make sure that algos are not being used to manipulate the market.

If you were considering just submitting a confusing fake algorithm to cover up the fact that your algorithm does in fact operate by manipulating the market and/or that you’re running a Ponzi scheme and your “algorithm” involves mainly blowing investor money on personal expenses, and you were thinking that the SEC isn’t computer savvy enough to notice – well, you’re not alone:

Even though the SEC believes it needs this algorithm information to help it police the market, many on Wall Street are still not convinced the agency will know what to do with the data.

“Let’s just say the good developers in the industry are being hired by the industry — not by an SEC salary,” a trader said.

But you might be wrong. Reuters reports that the SEC has acquired a couple of Ph.D. and ex-industry quants, headed by Rick Bookstaber, formerly of Bridgewater and other hedge funds. So they may well understand the finer nuances of your trading algorithms. Though that too might be objectionable:

It has alarmed some traders who are afraid their “secret sauce” — intellectual property sometimes developed over years and at great cost — could get into the wrong hands, especially when SEC and FINRA examiners leave for the private sector.

“I’d be disappointed and upset” if they asked for code, said a high-frequency trading firm executive who declined to be named. “I mean, are these people all going to work at the SEC forever?”

Regulators seek trading secrets [Reuters]

(hidden for your protection)
Show all comments

43 Responses to “SEC Is Going To Take Your High Frequency Trading Algorithm, Run It On A Commodore 64, See If It Crashes The Market”

  1. Rahodeb says:

    Rick Bookstaber? I couldn't come up with a better fake name for an SEC auditor if I tried.

  2. Anal_ist says:

    Cut the SEC some slack. The only reason that Commodore 64s are being used is because capacity on newer computers is being used for a higher purpose – – Redtube.

  3. pazzo83 says:

    I don't think the Commodore can handle our top performing algorithm, a² + b² = c²

    – UBS Quant

  4. Guesticulator says:

    Matt, that is a really great headline. Well done.

  5. Biff says:

    Precious! I figure a bunch of guys will be leaving the SEC soon to start a HF trading outfit. There's a certain class of people in this world that let others do the leg work.

    Just Sayin'

  6. Backoffice Monkey says:

    The code? Sure… no problemo… Here you go:


  7. Backdoor_Bess says:

    Ahhh, bringing back memories of River Raid and Montezuma's Revenge…….pardon me, as I have just ruined my trousers.

  8. Mexi_Cant says:

    I wanna cuddle.

    -Jimmy Simons.

  9. merkin_capital says:

    You'll have to pry my ColecoVision from my cold, dead hand.

  10. Optimus Quant says:

    All of our algorithms run on refurbished Sega Genesis consoles, all of them have the "turbo" setting as on.

    –Every quant firm that isn't Rentech, D.E. Shaw or PDT.

  11. Biffy Bassness says:

    I loved that computer. Those fat buttons….those fat buttons…..

  12. Guest says:

    God bless this great country. God bless Ron Paul, and God bless Monsanto.

  13. STAR says:

    Bring it, motherfuckers!

  14. derp says:

    bleep blorp wokka wokka fizzzzzzz pffffth sizzzzzle

    – SEC_Commodore_64

  15. Nerd says:

    What? No chart? Not even psuedo-code? Process-flow chart?

  16. Secret C64 Algo says:

    10 INPUT "Are you a female SEC employee? Y/N";A$
    20 IF A$="Y" THEN GOTO 40
    30 END
    40 INPUT "please enter your age:";A
    50 IF A>18 THEN GOTO 70
    60 GOTO 40
    70 PRINT "Meet me at Minetta's at 6PM. I'll be the one in the corner playing Jumpman Junior."
    80 END

  17. MeVC says:

    Was that Rick Bookstaber or Rick Backstabber?

  18. Chunk says:

    All your algorithm are belong to us

    – Zero Wing enthusiast

  19. seaman bodine says:

    I thought our lawyers covered this…shit, they lost?

    Two Sigma Quant, Seaman Bodine

  20. UBS Head Trader says:

    I hope they won't take my Quotron away! How else will I get my stockquotes?

  21. FinneganKristiansen says:

    Letting your secret sauce get into other's hands is the NKI

  22. Useful information. Fortunate me I found your web
    site unintentionally, and I am surprised why this
    twist of fate did not happened earlier! I bookmarked it.

  23. 90rkhQ I cannot thank you enough for the blog.Really looking forward to read more.

  24. Marty Wig says:

    Time on your medication.? These are all strangers.!!!

  25. Wonderful collection. We have bookmarked these Photoshop actions. Many thanks :)

  26. uq8vun Very neat post. Want more.

  27. Sex webcam says:

    Wow, great post. Really Great.

  28. Agen SBOBET says:

    Thanks for a very interesting web site. Where else could I get that kind of info written in such an ideal approach? I have a undertaking that I'm just now working on, and I've been at the look out for such information.
    Jasa SEO