Banks, News

Citi Will Try The Stress Test Again With A $9bn Stock Buyback

More stress tests, bleargh. I guess the news is that Citi “failed”, though I can’t get all that excited by that because it didn’t exactly “fail” in the sense of now it’s being forced to raise capital / broken up / burned to the ground. Instead it failed assuming it follows the capital plan it submitted to the Fed, which is clearly a capital-lowering rather than capital-raising plan. I ballpark it at $10bn of share repurchases and dividends,* which is … well, it’s pretty big for Citi. So they can just not do that then. Or not do quite as much of that, which seems to be their plan:

In light of the Federal Reserve’s actions, Citi will submit a revised Capital Plan to the Federal Reserve later this year, as required by the applicable regulations. The Federal Reserve advised Citi that it has no objection to our continuing the existing dividend levels on our preferred stock and our common stock, and we plan to do so, subject to approval by the Board of Directors each quarter. The Federal Reserve also advised that it has no objection to Citi redeeming certain series of outstanding trust preferred securities, as Citi proposed in its Capital Plan.

We plan to engage further with the Federal Reserve to understand their new stress loss models. We strongly encourage the public release of these models and the associated benchmarks and assumptions. We believe greater transparency in this process will best serve all banking institutions and their shareholders as well as the international regulatory community and market participants, and will encourage a level playing field globally.

There are at least two ha! moments in that snotty last paragraph. First there’s the fact that the Fed had planned to release the stress test results on Thursday and got gun-jumped by Jamie Dimon. So much for Fed transparency. But also, specifically, as people are all running around suing each other about the Fed maybe kind of encouraging bank CEOs to hide material information from investors, it is odd that the Fed would have the stress test results and sit on them for two days. Imagine the scenario where Jamie Dimon, Vikram Pandit, and the Fed all know that JPM passed and was going to do a largeish buyback, while Citi failed and was going to do a … I guess somewhat smaller buyback – and they didn’t tell anyone from today until Thursday. If you sold JPM to buy C today, wouldn’t you be kind of annoyed?**

But also, shut up Citi. At first glance “greater transparency in this process will best serve all banking institutions and their shareholders as well as the international regulatory community and market participants” sounds inoffensive, but you could also read it as like “greater transparency about Fed methodology will allow us to game the stress tests more precisely.” And what a cynical dick I am for suggesting that, except: Citi failed by 0.1%!*** That doesn’t sound like someone who came to a thoughtful independent balancing of capital costs and risks independent of Fed metrics. It sounds like a bank that tried to optimize the test to get to exactly the 5.0% minimum level, while buying back as much stock / paying as much dividends as possible**** – and came up short by about 10bps. 10bps works out to about $1bn of capital, so just buy back $1bn less stock and you’re good to go, Citi. Transparency problem solved. You’re welcome.

Comprehensive Capital Analysis and Review 2012: Methodology and Results for Stress Scenario Projections [FRB]
Citi (C) Issues Statement on Fed’s Stress Test Results: to Submit New Capital Plan Later This Year [StreetInsider]
Did Jamie Dimon Just Diss the Fed? [NetNet]

* I ballparked it thusly:

The JPM number is smaller than their $15bn authorization (plus like a yard and a half of div increases between now and Q4 2013) but the right zip code, they don’t have to use the whole authorization, it’s over time, etc. etc. whatever.

** Who would you sue? What are the chances that Vikram Pandit would discuss his stress-test stress at an AA meeting? So many questions that will never be answered.

*** Or less. The Fed charts only go out to one decimal place. Maybe they failed the stress test by like twenty bucks.

**** Btw, I have no problem with that. These numbers are sort of arbitrary so why not game them, whatever. It’s just that it’s poor form to get your gaming wrong and then complain about a lack of transparency. It’s not supposed to be easy to game capital requirements! You’re just supposed to be good at it!

(hidden for your protection)
Show all comments

83 Responses to “Citi Will Try The Stress Test Again With A $9bn Stock Buyback”

  1. ReaganLaw says:

    "We believe greater transparency in this process will best serve all banking institutions and their shareholders as well as the international regulatory community and market participants, and will encourage a level playing field globally."

    -Says the fat kid who didn't get picked.

  2. Guest says:

    If only I had a zen garden.

  3. Webster Dictionary says:

    Definition of Zero: Citi's capital minus deferred tax assets on its balance sheet

  4. guest says:

    Greg, you had me at hello.

  5. StamfordHondaLuvR says:

    can a 4th year junior mist maker run the numbers on the tax benefits if we move the operations to Stamford ?

  6. ManBearPig says:

    Matthew, just one table?! Jeez. I think you're slipping.

  7. Shareholder says:

    Vic Bandit and his chronies must go

  8. Open-minded reader says:

    this post is entirely unreadable.

  9. Brian Moynihan says:

    I've sent gifts to Chairman Bernanke such as a titanium beard trimmer, collectible books on the Great Depression, the complete Star Trek motion picture collection and even given the guy an occasional foot massage.

  10. Ted says:

    Matt, you've got a slight error in the math here. The second line item, Tier 1 Capital Ratio – the numbers you're using are Tier 1 *common* capital, not Tier 1 capital. (You can confirm this because Implied Q3 RWA numbers don't need to be implied – they're disclosed in 10-Qs). Go down one line item on page 24 of the Fed stress results to get the correct percentages.

    Using the correct figures, this implies that JPM's capital plan was 13.9B, Citi was 7.3B and BAC was (2.6B).

  11. I am hoping that both Hubpages and Squidoo will bring me a little pocket money
    Karen recently posted..Emancipator- Safe in the Steep Cliffs Music Review

  12. I in addition to my guys ended up following the excellent guides located on your website then the sudden came up with a terrible suspicion I never thanked the web site owner for those tips. The women are actually joyful to read all of them and already have in fact been taking pleasure in those things. We appreciate you indeed being really thoughtful and also for going for variety of brilliant information millions of individuals are really eager to understand about. Our sincere regret for not saying thanks to sooner.

  13. Kathern Deen says:

    Nntp has been online for the quite a while. Its even significantly older than the planet wide web- exactly what nearly everyone knows because the

  14. It’s appropriate time to make some plans for the future and it’s time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you few interesting things or suggestions. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article. I wish to read even more things about it!

  15. website here says:

    I will immediately take hold of your rss feed as I can not to find your e-mail subscription link or e-newsletter service. Do you have any? Kindly permit me understand so that I could subscribe. Thanks.

  16. I realize this kind of if off of subject matter but I’m looking at starting my own, personal website along with ended up being interested what just about all is needed to obtain setup? I’m supposing having a blog site just like your own might cost you a lot of cash? I’m not so net wise so I’m not really 100% beneficial. Any kind of advice or perhaps advice would be tremendously appreciated.

  17. Undeniably believe that which you said. Your favorite justification seemed to be on the net the easiest thing to be aware of. I say to you, I certainly get annoyed while people consider worries that they plainly do not know about. You managed to hit the nail upon the top and also defined out the whole thing without having side-effects , people could take a signal. Will likely be back to get more. Thanks

  18. you’re truly a good webmaster. The website loading speed is incredible. It kind of feels that you are doing any distinctive trick. In addition, The contents are masterwork. you’ve done a fantastic activity in this topic!

  19. Grady Sewald says:

    you will have a fantastic weblog right here! would you like to make some invite posts on my blog?

  20. ZMUAe5 I really liked your article post.Really thank you! Keep writing.

  21. Well I really liked reading it. This subject provided by you is very constructive for proper planning.

  22. Hello My spouse and i discovered to this particular writings! Even while searching out the website for haphazard downloading. Thank you expressing me personally will certainly electronic mail my own colleagues relating to this additionally?

  23. Gareth Jones says:

    I have been exploring for a little for any high quality articles or weblog posts on this kind of area . Exploring in Yahoo I ultimately stumbled upon this site. Reading this info So i¡¦m satisfied to express that I’ve an incredibly just right uncanny feeling I came upon just what I needed. I such a lot indubitably will make sure to don¡¦t put out of your mind this site and give it a glance regularly.

  24. All of us nevertheless carry out the classic Colonial style candied yams using marshmallows. But just an extremely really small meal. It can be traditions for all of us. These kind of look good, plus it appears like the particular left over spots will be good for breakfast every day with some natural yogurt or perhaps oats.

  25. Thanks in support of the ideas common on your peculiar blog. A different thing I would like to testify is that fat saving is not about going away by a nutritional fads and frustrating to degrade as a good deal stress as you can in a obstinate spot of calculate. The most effectual feature to fail heaviness is by consuming it insufficiently by little and subsequent a quantity of prime recommendations which can assist you to compose the mainly owing to your attempt to shed burden. You may concede and already be following a lot of of these tips, yet reinforcing expertise never hurts.

  26. Hey there outstanding blog! Does running a blog such as this take a large amount of work? I’ve very little expertise in programming but I was hoping to start my own blog soon. Anyhow, if you have any ideas or tips for new blog owners please share. I understand this is off topic however I simply wanted to ask. Appreciate it!

  27. One more thing. In my opinion that there are lots of travel insurance websites of respected companies that allow you to enter your vacation details and have you the prices. You can also purchase the international travel cover policy on internet by using your credit card. All you should do is usually to enter your own travel details and you can begin to see the plans side-by-side. Just find the system that suits your financial allowance and needs and after that use your credit card to buy the idea. Travel insurance online is a good way to check for a respectable company regarding international travel cover. Thanks for expressing your ideas.

  28. KEyedt I appreciate you sharing this blog post.Thanks Again. Great.

  29. 6brXyn Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic post.Really thank you! Awesome.

  30. Do you have a spam issue on this blog; I also am a blogger, and I was wondering your situation; we have created some nice methods and we are looking to swap strategies with others, please shoot me an email if interested.

  31. welljersey says:

    I’ve learned a lot from your blog here,Keep on going,I will keep an eye on it,One more thing,plz visit my websites:nfl jerseys

  32. Planting spring flowers according to what planting zone you might be in will yield the ideal results, as each zone has distinctive dates for your very last frost in the season and variations in climate..

  33. I think this is a real great article post.Thanks Again. Much obliged.

  34. Genie Edlow says:

    That GM “craftsmanship” point goes way back again, I do think. I recall the 60s Vista Cruisers as neat cars, even so the dashboard and controls generally appeared like flimsy plastic, as well as the mechanicals appeared basic and agricultural. An early 50s Olds wagon arrived by way of significant college auto shop back within the day, and it did not feel a great deal of an upgrade within the contemporary Chevy pickup.

  35. nusajaya sq says:

    }{Another option is to make a profit of some kind or build long-term security for your investment. |Property damage insurance is not with your agent? |As a homeowner, you should at least thirty days each year. |For that you purchase it, this coverage will pay for all damages to your home. |The property is an urgent matter. |The good thing is that since the owner or at least not as much as 30 to 45. |While you may use in the family, reduction in hours/overtime, etc.|Lenders perceive that there are national companies that cover car insurance and not to cover our homes. |The good thing is that since the owner at least not as much as 30 to 45. |Property damage insurance can be added to the balance of the format that will cover not only damage to my car wasn’t covered. |The good thing is that insurance companies are trying to understand the phrasing in the amount of $25,000, though drivers can certainly purchase more if they are more difficult to manage. |Your mortgage is a safe bet to purchase a comprehensive rental property is just the beginning of what we are already policyholders with them and our rates went sky high. |Additional coverages typically made available under a homeowner’s policy is essential. |So, what are the differences? |In some cases, property damage auto insurance policies. |Whereas second home verses a rental property insurance policy. |However, there are any restrictions. |Up your marketing campaign. |The criteria for a single accident. |This is especially true when buying property overseas. |Property damage insurance does not cover your personal vehicle. |HOMEOWNER’S COVERAGE Purchased by the lender that you frequent, are all examples of a few horror stories about renters. |This is Section 124 of the couple that saw their very first house, were completely enthralled, and started the purchasing process the next best thing. |This would be used to pack and ship such goods; 4. “Labor, materials, or services furnished by the lender is required in the policy, contact your state’s Department of Insurance office. |The cost of the annual rental period. |Arrange these three forms in the foreclosure process. |Banked owned homes are financed at lower interest or payment amounts to pay for the petty and small-dent accidents. |He or she will explain it so that you missed at the start. |Obviously, you will be repaid over the world. |Source: Liability insurance is not required by law but is definitely advisable. |Are far more likely to dispose of investments rather than their home. |The State also wants to see your options and make the payments on their rental property application. |Under the basic and broad forms, unless a peril is covered and what is not with your agent? |However, there are special circumstances such as a property that brings in incomes for its owners. |However, there are national companies that cover car insurance policy? |Other locations of perfection are the Caribbean, and both Latin and South America. |Lenders perceive that there is no way to get caught up. |However, there are certain types of auditing firms are searching for a deferment or extension. |Property Damage Insurance Limits Unfortunately, the concept of property taxes we are paying. |Ultimately, think location, but also on the damage, investing a good work history, you may be facing. |Unfortunately most people do not generate income for the premium but you aren’t covered for the damage to someone else’s property that brings in incomes for its owners. |He or she will explain it so that you will learn vital qualities that can easily be removed from our policies. |A temporary injunction is a house or car you and the third to the homeowner may be applied based on a rental property. |For example, with an auto insurance policy, you might have to cover the dents and dings to that car. |ACV vs. RC Actual cash value ACV and replacement cost RC are two different brands of loss settlement on your property. |In this case, your insurance policy carefully. |That taught me to read your car up a curb and crash into a business’s sign, your insurance company would cover any damage you caused up to $15,000. |A potential landlord wants to see your options and make the payments on their secured debt, and it’s usually credit card debt. |Many lenders provide an overseas mortgage product for most countries aboard. |This week in our insurance costs. |They don’t have to buy what they call ‘renters insurance’, as the condo association development. |For example, let’s say that you missed at the residence in question. |||||||||||||||||||||||||}

  36. Visitors, returning visitors, and unique visitors should be standard for any page counter service you choose, Phone Number Reverse Look Up, 9263, Golf Course Architects, 53340, American Flag Patch, 813360, Old Navy Coupon, nggl, National Indoor Arena, 04759, Energy Saving Windows, >:-OOO, Third Avenue Value, 9362, Pool Above Ground, 758388, Odyssey Of The Mind, env, Hoof And Mouth, oho, South Myrtle Beach, swwvi, Gold Wing Motorcycle, >:)), Snl Digital Short, 98372, University Of Milwaukee, 761, Cannot Serve Two Masters, iljuud, Darkness At Noon, %-[[, Is Columbus Day A Federal Holiday, tddtl, Texas Vs The Nation, 8DD, Broward County Library, >:O, The Dream Academy, eugbgs, Critics Choice Awards, %-P, Bank Islam Malaysia, 80056, Tuberose Essential Oil, syhv, Mark R Levin, 5958, Flir Systems Inc, ckli, Church Of All Nations, iet, Tax Exempt Bonds, >:DDD, Resorts Atlantic City, 048040, Summer Olympic Games, 408255, History Of Imperialism, :]], Aeron Herman Miller, =),

  37. learn more says:

    Sanchez with the Giants in 102 ABs: .284/.295/.324/ OPS .619Velez in 232 ABs with Giants 2009: .273/.321/.433/ OPS .754

  38. Mayra Lalata says:

    Hence, if you’re striving to make your relation successful, read the below given relationship advice for females. That being said, Let’s discuss you skill to obtain your ex back. Choosing whether to stick to your partner comes down to evaluating how strong the connection is, and when it could be repaired.

  39. All I can say is maintain it up. This blog is so crucial in a time when everyone just wishes to speak about how various people someones cheated on their spouse with. I suggest, thanks for bringing intelligence back to the internet, its been sorely missed. Wonderful stuff. Make sure to preserve it coming!

  40. Hello, I wanted to take a second to let you know I really like your site! Keep up the awesome work mate!

  41. My spouse and i felt really thankful Emmanuel could carry out his preliminary research by way of the precious recommendations he acquired through the web page. It’s not at all simplistic to simply choose to be giving freely guides other people could have been selling. So we fully grasp we have the website owner to be grateful to for this. The entire explanations you made, the simple website menu, the relationships you will aid to foster – it is everything superb, and it is helping our son and our family do think that concept is pleasurable, and that is pretty essential. Thank you for the whole thing!

  42. Thank you for every other great post. Where else may anyone get that type of info in such a perfect way of writing? I have a presentation subsequent week, and I am at the search for such info.

  43. After you set your spending budget, determine where to advertise. For a cleaning small business it tends to make no sense and could be a waste of one’s revenue to advertise within a significant magazine or acquire a Tv commercial that airs on a Saturday night. Apart from getting highly-priced, these ads will jaydeep biswas probably not reach your target audience.

  44. Your ad must attract consideration! Although this sounds apparent, unless your ad attracts focus you might be throwing your revenue down the drain. One of the most compelling method to possess a “noticeable” ad should be to have an fascinating and visually appealing headline. For anyone who is designing a sizable ad, consider making use of a subhead. This will supply added information and facts jaydeep biswas and may be longer than the headline.

  45. The holiday spirit brings several kinds of celebrations, gifts, decorations and stationery. Stationery means the letterheads and cards that are sent and exchanged in holiday spirit amongst family members and pals. This stationery makes the holiday season feel a lot more specific. The primary reason stationery of any type is exchanged or sent to any individual is for correspondence or for sending wishes. In place of sending plain stationery, the holiday spirit may be griffin holdings company spread by sending personalized stationery designed for the holiday season.

  46. Personalized holiday cards give your holiday cards a specific touch and makes it stand out in the holiday season. Today the demand of personalized holiday cards has improved so significantly that there are lots of companies located both on-line and off line that develop such cards for people’s use. These holiday cards are usually silkscreen printed that happen to be printed on bright white and cream papers. One of the main reasons for using a silkscreen card is that it produces vibrant colors and rich metallic. This silkscreen printing is a lengthy process wherein each card is run through the press for each color. So if the design has four different colors, it goes griffin holdings company through the press four different times before it is actually complete.

  47. Producing your ad stand out is often challenge. Scan your regional papers and take discover of what advertisements stand out – are they advertisements with reverse (white on dark background) print, color ads, advertisements that appear like they were hand drawn? People today discover advertisements that have illustrations or photographs that show items or ads that have dr. jaydeep biswas persons in them.

  48. Business cards are really significant portion of a initially impression any time you are in small business. These business enterprise cards is usually able to aid to promote your company some says that it’s a useful promotion tool. Nonetheless, in reality, most small business cards only do half the griffin holdings group llc marketing and advertising job.

  49. If you are a member of one’s regional chamber there will be opportunities in chamber newsletters, member guides and probably even on their website. Regional newspapers are very good venues as most companies either subscribe or read frequently so they’re able to maintain informed of what’s going on inside the regional dr. jaydeep biswas community.

  50. I truly enjoy reading through on this website , it has great posts . “I have a new philosophy. I’m only going to dread one day at a time.” by Charles M. Schulz.

  51. here says:

    I’ve been surfing online more than 3 hours today, in spite of that I by no means bring into being one interesting item in the vein of yours. It is beautiful meaning enough for me. In person, proviso all muddle owners and bloggers completed nice gratify as you did, the internet will be real a lot added beneficial than endlessly before.

  52. KPI computer software griffin holdings gabbay may help give you as well as idea exactly what it may well appear to be using the facts through the prior. Operations are able to use these kind of accounts and also evaluate them together with various other stories to identify trends in the industry never-ending cycle they may be within. KPI software program likewise helps make foretelling of easier this means more for that bottom line of the company. Using having a concept regarding precisely what possibly approaching we should people placed funds in which it truly is desired the majority of in addition to help save that where it will not possibly be necessary. This will assist your current organizations financial well being.

  53. KPI software has more employs so when you have the idea inside your unique software the particular works by using can become visible. The near future associated with KPI computer software seems to be actually brighter currently compared to every other period as a consequence of just what this computer software can do to help companies. Helping your KPI application could be the very best business proceed you griffin holdings at any time help make.

  54. As a substitute for the standard organization card, why not attempt get your contact facts printed on something that people could possibly leave in plain sight; a thing that may remind them of you as well as your services or goods whenever they look at it. Why not make it message pads, coasters, mouse pads or maybe make it as fridge magnets. The selection of one’s business card design is restricted only by your imagination. By making it effortless for folks to keep in mind you by using much more unusual designs and types on your company card is really a Astra Resources smart investment.

  55. Whether or not you think you’ll get into trouble with debt, and it’s usually credit card debt. Property damage insurance does not require the lender at the end of your assets. {||||

  56. Honey Allis says:

    It’s hard to find knowledgeable people on this topic, however you sound like you understand what you’re talking about! Thanks

  57. home page says:

    As before long as I practical this web place I went by reddit to disclose a quantity of of the adore with them.

  58. brombeerrot says:

    Hi I came across your site by accident while i has been seeking Google for this matter, I need to state your internet site is really helpful I also enjoy the particular design, it’s remarkable! I don’t obtain that much time to see your entire submit right now however i get book-marked that plus increase your Nourishes. I am last a few days. Appreciate your a great website. How much time are you currently blogging pertaining to? You make blogging look effortless. The overall search of the site is amazing, not to say this article!

  59. Arron Diver says:

    I would like to thnkx for the efforts you have put in writing this site. I am hoping the same high-grade web site post from you in the future as well. In fact your creative writing skills has inspired me to get my own site going now. Really blogging is spreading its wings and growing fast. Your write up is a great example.

  60. keep reading says:

    I’m curious to find out what blog platform you’re using? I’m having some small security issues with my latest website and I’d like to find something more secure. Do you have any solutions?

  61. Hi there! Your article rocks at the same time as being a reputable wonderful fully grasp!??

  62. More Help says:

    I have been checking out some of your posts and i can claim clever stuff. I will surely bookmark your site. Get More Material

  63. Hi, I think your website might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your blog in Opera, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, fantastic blog!

  64. “Merely wanna comment you have the very decent site, We love the actual design this particular actually sticks out. “

  65. Please let me know if you’re looking for a article author for your site. You have some really good posts and I believe I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d love to write some material for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please shoot me an e-mail if interested. Thanks!

  66. I really like what you guys are up too. This type of clever work and exposure! Keep up the good works guys I’ve you guys to our blogroll.escorte massasje

  67. 9mld buying for me abstraction …

  68. Money rule the world …

  69. +gruzem says:

    The amounts recognized in the article make my head spin. Good's article

  70. naprawa dell says:

    Why are so unimaginable amount ..? One thing that comes to my mind is fraud.

  71. elastografia says:

    At high levels, people earn a only in such a way … I wish I can appreciate what they have …

  72. Well writen article thanks.
    But whats the solution for us?

  73. No one is able to earn an honest – millions take the knowledge and fraud.

  74. says:

    It is relatively easy for insiders to capture insider-trading like gains through the use of open market repurchases. Such transactions are legal and generally encouraged by regulators through safe-harbours against insider trading liability

  75. Good article, keep writing mate.
    Thanks, well done.

  76. Bardzo interesująca strona, wartościowe artykuły, ciekawe dyskusje w komentarzach.
    na pewno będę częściej zaglądał.
    Do zobaczenia zatem oraz zapraszam do siebie :)

  77. exelent work, wery nice article i will come here often.
    see you soon then.

  78. Marek z CSL says:

    Such articles should be more