Derivative Surprises Everyone By Accomplishing Purpose and Unwinding at Randomly Generated Market Value

Yay, Greek CDS worked. But, as we talked about a bit, it almost didn’t:

By happenstance, some of the new bonds Greece has issued in its restructuring have a market price close to the total value of the package creditors received — about 22 cents on the euro. Those bonds will help set the CDS payout, and trouble will be averted: CDS holders will receive about 78 cents, roughly equivalent to the loss bondholders suffered. …

If the new Greek bonds had different terms — higher or lower interest payments for instance — their prices could be substantially different, changing the amount the default swaps would pay. Ben Heller, a portfolio manager at New York hedge fund Hutchin Hill Capital, which owns both Greek bonds and CDS, said that means the swaps aren’t doing their job. He said that until the problem is fixed, he “will not use CDS as a hedge against credit exposures anymore.”

In fact Heller told Felix Salmon:

When you think about it, it’s a product that, on certain poorly defined credit events, offers a random payout. So if I want to do that, then I could play roulette at a casino.

So, first of all: yes! I think worry about the definition of credit events is a bit overblown, but the randomness of the payout is a real thing and bizarre and terrifying. It bears re-emphasizing that the method of calculating the Greek CDS payout bears no relation whatsoever to the default risk that it was supposedly hedging.

But, also: no! Greek CDS ultimately settled at 21.5. That randomly generated payout number is veeeeery close to the “right” number, i.e. the number that would have hedged that risk it was supposed to be hedging. (And, it’s maybe worth mentioning, the payoff was too big, not too small.) Which is maybe a coincidence except Felix also tells the story of how the new Greek bonds’ maturities got reshuffled so that the 2042 would lead to more or less the correct result in the CDS auction.

One thing to remember that CDS is just a contract between two parties, one or both of whom is generally a securities dealer. ISDA is just a third-party provider of infrastructure that those two parties often like to sign up to. If you don’t like the thing that CDS is, go find someone to sell you a thing that is the thing that you want to have. Heller plans to; he’s got his eye on bond futures.

Somehow this got me thinking of our friend Greg Smith. Here is some sensible stuff from one Jacki Zehner, who also left Goldman but not in a huff and in fact as a partner, a title she got at age 32, which she points out in passing, leaving it unmentioned that at that age Greg Smith was still a VP* so SUCK IT GREG, but anyway, where were we:

Though I left my trading position 12 years ago, I will tell you from personal experience that the vast majority of people I worked with cared deeply about our customers, and, if you were heard calling customers any of the things Mr. Smith mentioned, you would be in big trouble. BIG.

More relevant is that if you continuously ‘ripped your customers eyeballs out’, they would cease to be your customers. The behavior that Mr. Smith so graphically describes was, at the time, the exception and not the norm in my opinion. Were we supposed to make money? Yes. If you promoted that this came at the customer’s expense, that was a bad thing.

There was a period of time in the distant past where, by accident, my desk wrote contracts that allowed us to terminate them immediately.** This really was a pure accident – we’d been writing the contracts the same way for years, but market conditions had moved such that a trigger that you’d never expect to be hit was hit at inception of the trade. Terminating would be a good thing for us, since it would in theory let us take our entire profit on the trade without any more risk or balance-sheet usage. Our customers, who were sophisticated large companies advised by fancy law firms, had read the contracts and signed on for this, although of course they didn’t know that – to be fair, neither did we, and we read a lot more of these than they did. Then we discovered the glitch, and … well, we eventually fixed it in future documents. But for the contracts we’d already signed up, we had discovered a free termination right that was valuable to us. So we basked, briefly, in our newfound ability to terminate trades like assholes and generate millions of dollars in risk-free profits. Then we went back to work. Guess how many we terminated?

If your business is dealing CDS or equity derivatives or used cars or whatever, repeatedly ripping eyeballs out is … well, bad business. Customers often use their eyeballs for things, like seeing, so they tend to notice when they’ve been ripped out and have hard feelings about the operation. They go elsewhere. So even if you’ve got their eyeballs in your grasp and could, with one quick tug, acquire those eyeballs and also probably money because who wants eyeballs, you might well forebear and let them see the next deal you’ve got cooking for them.

But even if you’re the nicest guy in the world, it is nice to have optionality. If you’re a derivatives dealer, you’re particularly attuned to free options, even if all they’re realistically good for is some gentle basking. If you’re ISDA, or the dealer banks that make up the majority of its membership (and also maybe have some input into the Greek restructuring), a thing that you probably don’t want to do is blow up the CDS market for ever and aye by just picking a wildly wrong random number. But you probably like having the (partial, constrained, of-uncertain-legality) option to do so – constructed with, say, ambiguous documentation or determinations committees that decide whether there’s been a credit event and what obligations are eligible for auction. Because it turned out that banks’ Greek CDS exposure was pretty small – but if it had been, I dunno, Italy, ripping out some client eyeballs might have been necessary for the banks to save their own.

ISDA is doing some entertaining throat-clearing about fixing the screwy CDS settlement provisions that were invoked here, and the Ben Hellers of the world are pushing them to do that. Maybe they will, especially since the next default could go against dealers. Or maybe, by accidentally or accidentally-on-purpose alighting on an attractive – reasonable but slightly protection-buyer-favoring – random number for the Greek auction, they’ll avert calls for reform and get to keep a bit of optionality for the next, scarier default.

Greek Deal Highlights Flaws in Default Swaps [WSJ]
A top CDS trader quits the CDS market [Felix Salmon / Reuters]
[Greece CDS] Final auction results [FTAV]

* As was I! Ah, misspent youth.

** Look, I’m not really giving anything away here because these contracts are publicly filed. Go find them. If you can figure out the problem, then, well, good for you, go sell equity derivatives, I HEAR THEY’RE HIRING.

Also, like, this happens all the time everywhere. Who reads documents?

(hidden for your protection)
Show all comments

36 Responses to “Derivative Surprises Everyone By Accomplishing Purpose and Unwinding at Randomly Generated Market Value”

  1. E Jones Arb says:

    um……..uh….. eh……….too long, not enough charts, didn't read.

  2. dumb says:

    YES, my later afternoon Levine fix…

  3. AIG says:

    Our subtle variation on this strategy was; write up whatever terms you wish, but make sure you include the wire details/SWIFT number with the deal sheet. Compliance might read that BS, but we have no intention on paying out on it whatever the case.

  4. Beerio says:

    I like how we now get random footnotes which aren't referenced to any specific point in the text. This way I can insert them, like, anywhere I feel appropriate in the text/when I get bored. Win!

  5. AIG Circlejerk Quant says:

    Damn and we were just in the middle of unveiling a revolutionary new product which would provide a CDS on a CDS contract

  6. HeathenWonk says:

    This was actually excellent. Both you and Felix are honestly excited and intrested in this shit. Your super-nerd attempts to explain it to the heathens and wonks alike is appreciated.

  7. I usually do not like the timeline setup on fb and do not want it on my web page. It sounds like I wil not have a very choose since its not like I pay or fb but its a bunch of crap to force it on us it we have been happy together with the way it is now.

  8. Lakia Krenn says:

    Government inside the U.S. today is really a senior partner in every business in the united states.

  9. If your business is dealing CDS or equity derivatives or used cars or whatever, repeatedly ripping eyeballs out is … well, bad business. Customers often use their eyeballs for things, like seeing, so they tend to notice when they’ve been ripped out and have hard feelings about the operation. They go elsewhere. So even if you’ve got their eyeballs in your grasp and could, with one quick tug, acquire those eyeballs and also probably money because who wants eyeballs, you might well forebear and let them see the next deal you’ve got cooking for them.

  10. Great submit is going to be linking this particular on numerous internet sites regarding my very own maintain inside the great work. This is the great indicate raise up that lots of aren’t speaking about. A truly exciting examines, I might certainly not concur fully, but you will have the very appropriate points. I excavated some of an individual post while i cogitated we were holding beneficial handy.

  11. Thanks for revealing your ideas. I might also like to express that video games have been ever before evolving. Better technology and revolutions have helped create realistic and fun games. Most of these entertainment games were not actually sensible when the real concept was being experimented with. Just like other styles of technologies, video games as well have had to progress as a result of many generations. This is testimony to the fast growth and development of video games.

  12. I have noticed that credit repair activity needs to be conducted with tactics. If not, chances are you’ll find yourself causing harm to your rank. In order to be successful in fixing your credit score you have to confirm that from this time you pay your monthly fees promptly before their planned date. It is significant simply because by certainly not accomplishing that area, all other steps that you will choose to use to improve your credit rank will not be effective. Thanks for expressing your suggestions.

  13. Every now and then basically we decide on sites we read. Listed here are the most recent web sites that people decide on. Check out the sites we all stick to, including this one, as it symbolizes our own recommendations on the internet.

  14. Hey all, My partner and i came with that great weblog, and asked yourself if I might start off following your discussions. I am myselfvery considerably considering every thing concerning this subject , along with want to return shortly and initiate inputtingmy views.

  15. Read Here says:

    This kind of submit actually manufactured my own day time. You are unable to envision what amount period I needed invested because of this information! Nonetheless I am the following today and would likely like to say thanks a great deal for an outstanding submit and an all round interesting weblog. Are you able to offer you guests writers to write content available for you? My spouse and i wouldn’t head crafting an article or even elaborating with a amount of the niche.

  16. It’s an exclusive take care of for them and also makes the knowledge complete. We don’t know what to express. This web site is actually wonderful. This is much that you forced me to be want to learn more to do with it. Your website can be my personal stepping-stone, my buddy. Was looking for heads up on this subject.

  17. I am not certain the place you’re getting your information, however good topic. I needs to spend some time studying more or understanding more. Thank you for magnificent info I was searching for this information for my mission.

  18. Full Article says:

    whoah this blog is fantastic i love studying your articles. Stay up the good work! You know, lots of individuals are searching round for this information, you could help them greatly.

  19. Wow, wonderful weblog layout! How lengthy have you been running a blog for? you make blogging glance easy. The entire glance of your site is great, as smartly as the content!

  20. I do agree with all the ideas you have presented for your post. They are very convincing and can certainly work. Still, the posts are very short for newbies. May just you please extend them a bit from subsequent time? Thanks for the post.

  21. Thanks for every other great post. Where else could anyone get that kind of info in such a perfect means of writing? I’ve a presentation subsequent week, and I am on the search for such info.

  22. Thanks a lot for sharing this with all people you really recognize what you are speaking about! Bookmarked. Kindly additionally talk over with my website =). We will have a link change arrangement between us!

  23. I think this is among the most important info for me. And i’m glad reading your article. But want to remark on some general things, The website style is ideal, the articles is really nice : D. Good job, cheers

  24. Gareth Jones says:

    I’ve been browsing on-line more than 3 hours lately, yet I by no means discovered any fascinating article like yours. It is pretty worth sufficient for me. Personally, if all site owners and bloggers made excellent content material as you probably did, the internet will likely be a lot more helpful than ever before.

  25. I’ve been recently missing for a time, however From the precisely why I did previously really like this web site. Thank you, I will try and come back more often. I’ve just lately began an online site, the details you are offering here helps myself greatly. You should keep us all up to date such as this. Appreciate expressing.

  26. A lot of thanks for all of the labor on this blog. My mother really loves carrying out investigation and it is easy to see why. We hear all about the powerful way you provide precious suggestions by means of your website and even encourage response from others on this situation and our favorite daughter is actually studying a whole lot. Take advantage of the remaining portion of the year. You have been carrying out a powerful job.

  27. Thanks a lot, this is what I am looking for. Your information is very useful for me. So, thank you so much. Have a nice weekend.

  28. What’s Taking place i am new to this, I stumbled upon this I have found It absolutely helpful and it has helped me out loads. I am hoping to give a contribution & help different customers like its helped me. Good job.

  29. My programmer is trying to convince me to move to .net from PHP. I have always disliked the idea because of the expenses. But he’s tryiong none the less. I’ve been using Movable-type on a number of websites for about a year and am anxious about switching to another platform. I have heard great things about Is there a way I can import all my wordpress content into it? Any help would be really appreciated!

  30. Szwecja film says:

    This in truth helped my question, Cheers!

  31. Brombeerrot says:

    Hi there I came across your website in error once i was seeking Google because of this issue, I need to state your website is truly helpful I also adore your design, it’s wonderful! I don’t obtain that a lot of time to learn your post at the moment on the other hand have got book-marked that and in addition create your current For. I am back in a day or two. Appreciate your a great website. How long are you writing a blog for? You are making writing a blog appear effortless. The overall seem of your respective website is wonderful, aside from this content!

  32. WWW says:

    Hi, Neat post. There’s a problem with your site in internet explorer, would check this… IE still is the market leader and a huge portion of people will miss your great writing because of this problem.

  33. tri nam da says:

    wow!!!! amazing post … actually i was searching for some thing like this ….