Deutsche Bank Is Not Above Shuffling a Few Pieces of Paper To Keep Nosy Regulators From Demanding $20bn in New Capital

Two things always worth talking about are bank regulation and path dependency so here’s this Journal story about Deutsche Bank that is like ooh-evil-Germans but also kind of meh:

Deutsche Bank AG changed the legal structure of its huge U.S. subsidiary to shield it from new regulations that would have required the German bank to pump new capital into the U.S. arm. … Taunus [the sub] — which at the end of last year had about $354 billion of assets and 8,652 employees, making it one of the largest U.S. banking companies — won’t have to comply with a provision of the U.S.’s Dodd-Frank regulatory-overhaul law that essentially forces the local arms of non-U.S. banks to meet the same capital requirements that American banks face.

Deutsche Bank has two main U.S. units. One is a trust company that has a banking license and must adhere to stringent U.S. bank-safety rules. The other is an investment-banking arm that isn’t technically a bank. Until recently, both units were housed under Taunus, which didn’t need to meet U.S. capital requirements, thanks to a waiver provided by the Fed a decade ago.

A provision of the Dodd-Frank Act, designed to prevent a repeat of the financial crisis, repealed the law under which that waiver and others were granted. That change was going to require Deutsche Bank to infuse Taunus, which for years operated with thin capital cushions, with what executives feared could be as much as $20 billion, according to people familiar with the matter.

Deutsche Bank responded last month by moving the trust company out of Taunus, named for a mountain range near Frankfurt. That means Taunus is no longer a bank-holding company and won’t have to comply with the new, tougher capital rules, even though Taunus still houses Deutsche Bank’s U.S. investment bank.

Instead it will be SEC regulated, like … well, every other US holding company that houses only an investment bank and not a bank bank. Bank. The bank bank subsidiary, on the other hand, will be owned directly by Deutsche Bank, which as the Journal previously explained gets to follow German but not US capital regulation. The bank sub will be a US trust company, so not quite true that it won’t have to meet the same capital requirements that American banks face. It will have to meet the same capital requirements that American banks face. Its just that its holding company will not be a US bank holding company, but will rather be a German thing regulated by Germans.

It’s hard to feel too many feelings about this, and any feelings you do have are probably attributable mostly to path dependency. Like: if Bank of Jupiter opened a US bank subsidiary tomorrow; the sub would be subject to US bank regulation (like Deutsche’s is) and the holding company would not be subject to US BHC regulation, but only to Jovian capital rules. Similarly if BoJu opened an investment bank it would be SEC, not Fed, regulated, because that’s how investment banks roll. The reason to get angry about Deutsche is that it is not some German bank opening a US subsidiary; rather, it is a big German bank with an existing US investment banking presence (though no real commercial banking presence) that is shuffling its US subsidiaries to optimize its US capital treatment and avoid some rules that apply to US banks.

Should anyone care? Well, Deutsche – and its predecessor in this variety of very slight shadiness, the artist formerly known as BarCap – will still be subject to capital rules administered by nice sensible Western European governments and would probably even pass US-grade stress tests. Of course adding another layer of juicy well-capitalized goodness above Deutsche’s risky risky i-bank couldn’t hurt, could it?

Funny you should ask. John Carney has a very smart piece today arguing that the extension of Basel II capital requirements to investment bank holding companies in 2004 helped cause the financial crisis by encouraging them to put all their money into products that got preferential capital treatment, meaning basically mortgage-backed structured credit: “The amendments contributed to the financial crisis not by permitting too much leverage, but by cajoling the investment banks into adopting the view of risk held by international regulators and subsequently, loading up on mortgage-related securities.” I like this a lot and find it plausible that spending all your time focusing on Basel-y risk-weighting leads you into error, though I’m not sure that the advantage of capping holding company leverage is outweighed by the disadvantage of defining it sub-optimally. In any case, though, if you do believe it too literally, then yay, getting rid of capital requirements at Taunus will make things safer.

There’s one maybe interesting implication of this. First of all, realize that though DB is getting a little bad press for the Taunus-shuffling, it also got to do it without much of a squeak from the Fed, which probably had at least some ability to step in and cause trouble if it wanted. Second, realize that though DB is getting out of some of Dodd-Frank, it’s not avoiding the most annoying item, which is the Volcker Rule: the current draft Volcker restrictions “cover the activities of any bank with a connection to the U.S., even a single branch in one state, according to lawyers and bank executives.” So the Taunus malarkey probably won’t get DB out of that.

But it does set the precedent that a thing that is a US bank holding company can stop being a US bank holding company with no hard feelings, Fed-wise. Other things that are kind of awkwardly US bank holding companies, what with their not really being US commercial banks in any meaningful way, include Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs. Unlike Deutsche Bank, for those domestic firms, de-BHC-ifying would, maybe, in theory, save them from the clutches of the Volcker Rule. Path-dependency, and also too-big-to-fail-ification, being what they are, that would get them some pretty bad press. But the Deutsche precedent suggests that it might fly with regulators.

Deutsche Bank Shields U.S. Unit From Dodd-Frank [WSJ]
The SEC Rule That Broke Wall Street [NetNet]

(hidden for your protection)
Show all comments

52 Responses to “Deutsche Bank Is Not Above Shuffling a Few Pieces of Paper To Keep Nosy Regulators From Demanding $20bn in New Capital”

  1. Edmond Dantes says:

    Deutsche is a London based hedge fund, headed by a rajestani, masquerading as a German bank, skirting US capital requirements, and brutally dependent on short term funding…

    I am sure this will all end well…

  2. Wall St. Dude says:

    right….. They're also a massive retail bank in europe, and didn't require a bailout during the last crisis.

    Let me guess – you're white.

  3. Mark Nuccio says:

    De-banking does not set everyone free from regulation. Dodd Frank includes a “Hotel California" provision which classifies as a "Significant Nonbank Financial Company" any company having total consolidated assets of $50 billion or more as of January 1, 2010 and that participated in the Troubled Asset Relief Program." If such a company ceases to remain a Bank Holding Company by engaging in a “de-banking” transaction, it will still be subject to regulation as a SNFC and will no escape the enhanced prudential supervision requirements of the Dodd Frank, including capital and quantitative limitations to be set forth in the regulations implementing the Volcker Rule.

  4. Finance Addict says:

    This story is much more significant than portrayed here, given Taunus' history.

  5. pTmKvD I loved your article post.Thanks Again. Fantastic.

  6. iq4lQt Im obliged for the blog post.Thanks Again. Awesome.

  7. xp4slX Im grateful for the article post.Really looking forward to read more. Fantastic.

  8. Jung Fearing says:

    Sciortino’s in South Amboy, New Jersey (formerly in Perth Amboy). I’m a NJ thin crust lover, but their Sicilian is other-worldly and basically the top pizza I have at any time had.

  9. Really appreciate you sharing this blog article.Thanks Again. Great.

  10. Malik Minger says:

    Hi, I’ve paid for two months of letters and also have not received any however. How do I get that set?br /thanks

  11. Howdy would you mind letting me know which hosting company you’re utilizing? I’ve loaded your blog in 3 different internet browsers and I must say this blog loads a lot faster then most. Can you recommend a good web hosting provider at a fair price? Thanks a lot, I appreciate it!

  12. Raiders win the AFCW this yearthis is my early sleeper pick.

  13. My now husband has always done that for me. I think that’s part of the reason I love him. He always checked even though my backseat was always so packed a person could never have gotten in there. It is the little things that make you see who a person is.

  14. kliknij says:

    I was wondering if you endlessly measured altering the explain of your blog? Its fantastically fine printed; I fondness what youve got to utter. On the contrary possibly you could a insufficiently further in the way of satisfy accordingly nation could connect with it outshine. Youve got an dire slice of text for only having one or two metaphors. Possibly you could space it absent better?

  15. Coralee Garg says:

    Which means other folks are going to be accomplishing a number of 97 % of all of the function, leaving behind you simply 5 pct along with sufficient time to do this in through a person evening or even morning or whenever work… through anywhere you want — in your house or maybe coming from a motel while you’re traveling along with enjoying yourself along with your jaydeep biswas loved ones.

  16. Education and also Assist – Coaching in addition to benefit support may also be main essentials with regard to work from home business folks. And Resort Vacations provides lots of teaching plus a call up middle to aid you having potential customers jaydeep biswas

  17. ebikes says:

    Most states and communities don’t require them to be in shape to ride to work on clear days if you want to do your bit for the next 2 to 3 years. Researchers at the University of Tennessee are taking a look at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology’s Smart Cities program, they are looking for.

  18. Bonuses says:

    Hello, Neat place of duty. In attendance is an issue down with your web place in internet explorer, power test this… That is immobile is the market leader and a bulky portion of people will pass on your fantastic inscription because of this problem.

  19. Your ad need to inform why your cleaning business could be the ideal in the area. By far the most convincing technique to do that is by way of dr. jaydeep biswas testimonials, statistics and awards.

  20. Cristi Johal says:

    Organization cards are pretty vital component of a initially impression whenever you are in small business. These company cards might be in a position to aid to promote your business some says that it’s a beneficial promotion tool. Having said that, in reality, most small business cards only do half the griffin holdings group llc marketing and advertising job.

  21. It really is accurate that no organization person could live with no of having a organization card to hand to potential clients or clients. Due to the fact for them, handing out a business card is so a lot less difficult than writing out all of your make contact with details griffin holdings group llc for a individual you’ve just met.

  22. Full File says:

    Greetings from Los angeles! I’m bored to death at work so I decided to check out your site on my iphone during lunch break. I really like the knowledge you present here and can’t wait to take a look when I get home. I’m shocked at how fast your blog loaded on my mobile .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyhow, fantastic blog!

  23. For anyone who is a member of the regional chamber there will be possibilities in chamber newsletters, member guides and possibly even on their web site. Local newspapers are fantastic venues as most corporations either subscribe or read on a regular basis so they’re able to hold informed of what’s going on within the regional dr. jaydeep biswas community.

  24. says:

    I really feel that she has strategy to considerably class to receive involved being a VP and solution to significant of the IQ to obtain involved with Washington gang. Could you think about a debate concerning Condi and Biden. It might be called Einstein and also the pea bain

  25. Continued says:

    There is a remedy used for all it is called death.

  26. Micheal Rys says:

    To produce small business cards in Microsoft Word is easy as 1, 2, three. Initially step, within a blank document open in Word, choose Tools|Letters and Mailings|Envelopes and Labels. Click the Labels tab and after that click Choices. Second step, in the Label Selections dialog, be certain the drop-down says Avery Regular and after that scroll the Item Quantity down to 5371. Click OK. Third step, back inside the Envelopes and Labels dialog box, ensure below Print, it says complete web page from the Very same Label. Then click New Document. A table seems with a bunch of 2 inch x 3.5 inch cells. Now you are able to commence setting up your first enterprise card. There you’ve it! Speedy and effortless organization cards griffin holdings group llc appropriate from Microsoft Word.

  27. KPI software offers much more employs so when you use the idea inside your different apps the particular utilizes might be obvious. The longer term connected with KPI software seems to be even happier today compared to every other time period as a result of what exactly this kind of software program is able to do to help you business people. Getting your KPI software program would be the finest organization shift anyone griffin holdings ever before help to make.

  28. So let me get this straight….you have to have an ID to see King Hussein, but u don’t need a ID to vote….as long as u vote for him…lol It amazes me just how dumb liberals/Democrats are….lol

  29. Nowadays, there are lots of printing organizations offered which have a organization card printing service. They can guide you on your creation of one’s small business card. They’ve a group of designers that may assist you to conceptualize the style of your card. Even so, having them do your company card entails funds, in case you can not afford their service fee there is another way. Printing your personal organization cards working with Microsoft Word could be a very inexpensive Astra Resources choice.

  30. Opening new studios is always a terrific news. But high quality matters. As a Yoga instructor I hope these two new studios will guarantee excellent and provide peace, happiness and wellbeing for the practitioners.

  31. I grew up during the area behind the seat in a very TD, and owned a couple TFs but my father (and myself) normally preferred the appears in the TC. Someday I really hope to personal one.

  32. Entertaining your clientele should really involve over just shouting a few rounds at the local pub. Intelligent firms recognize that outstanding corporate entertainment raises their profile, consolidates existing organization arrangements and delivers a concentrate for future bargains. So the careful option of corporate occasions needs to be aspect of one’s all round hospitality approach and not a spur with the moment decision, and also the budget for this must be component of one’s all round marketing plan. And remember, you don’t have to go overboard expense-wise to impress, because a number of the most Astra Resources PLC memorable occasions expense the least to stage.

  33. I am extremely impressed along using your producing expertise as smartly as together with the format in your weblog. Is always that this a paid subject or did you customize it yourself? Anyhow preserve up the superb high excellent producing, it can be rare to peer a great website like this 1 these days..

  34. I really enjoy the article post.Much thanks again. Keep writing.

  35. lubie to says:

    Very nice article! We are linking to this chiefly enormous clause taking place our situate. Keep positive the sunny writing.

  36. G’day to men and women. My Organization Is from the Greece and i use a fresh new website page. Please Visit my website and tell me your personal opinion. You’ll Discover many ideas and knowledge for my job role. It Really Is free 100% and without registrator. Gives Thanks To absolutely everyone that may check my completely new page. This Helps my job. | μετακομίσεις |

  37. Fantastic beat ! I wish to apprentice while you amend your site, how could i subscribe for a blog site? The account aided me a acceptable deal. I had been a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast offered bright clear concept

  38. I simply needed to thank you very much once more. I am not sure the things I would’ve carried out in the absence of the type of opinions provided by you about such concern. It absolutely was a frightening matter in my circumstances, but spending time with the very well-written form you dealt with the issue made me to cry over delight. I will be grateful for this help and in addition have high hopes you realize what a great job your are carrying out teaching people today by way of your webblog. Probably you haven’t met any of us. Read Far More

  39. Hi, i read your blog occasionally and i own a similar one and i was just curious if you get a lot of spam responses? If so how do you prevent it, any plugin or anything you can suggest? I get so much lately it’s driving me crazy so any support is very much appreciated.

  40. HEY!br /How in regards to the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Museum in Cleveland?

  41. I precisely had to thank you very much again. I do not know what I could possibly have followed without the actual tips and hints revealed by you over such area. It truly was an absolute traumatic concern in my opinion, however , seeing the skilled style you solved it took me to jump for joy. I am just happier for the guidance as well as expect you really know what a powerful job you have been getting into educating other individuals through the use of your web blog. I am certain you have never encountered all of us.

  42. I was just searching for this info for a while. After 6 hours of continuous Googleing, finally I got it in your website. I wonder what’s the lack of Google strategy that don’t rank this kind of informative sites in top of the list. Generally the top sites are full of garbage. Click On This Site

  43. kasyno says:

    Lets hope that someday I will hold the expertise to post this sort of fine articles including you. Sam is currently writing your own weblog, but more right drawer. In case you where to drive previous several classes on paper, allow understand!

  44. The other day, while I was at work, my sister stole my iPad and tested to see if it can survive a forty foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My apple ipad is now destroyed and she has 83 views. I know this is completely off topic but I had to share it with someone!

  45. I’ve learn a few just right stuff here. Certainly price bookmarking for revisiting. I wonder how a lot effort you put to create any such magnificent informative website.

  46. These days of austerity along with relative stress and anxiety about having debt, many individuals balk about the idea of having a credit card to make acquisition of merchandise as well as pay for a vacation, preferring, instead to rely on the tried as well as trusted technique of making repayment – hard cash. However, if you possess cash on hand to make the purchase completely, then, paradoxically, this is the best time for them to use the credit card for several motives.

  47. I exposed this send before now little in the office. Vastly beneficial. Sent the website link to myself and will possibly bookmark it when I bring in it home.

  48. Fresh lower flowers can be on the costly aspect. If you are obtaining an function and need to have a number of shows try out and do them oneself. richard walker gebo isn’t as tough as you would feel if you adhere to a couple of quick suggestions. The container is crucial. With a broad mouth container, make certain you have some thing to preserve the flowers in place at the bottom. Marbles or a piece of Styrofoam will do. The container issues but can be something unique to the event. It doesn’t need to have to be fancy but it does need to be good. Ahead of you begin lay out the blossoms you have bought: greens, spray, flowers 1,two,three. As every piece goes in cut it to the preferred height you want it to be, but don’t forget that if any person else takes it home they could reduce a small off the end to to hold them new so depart a tiny for them. Put every piece in brief to tall as you like and be certain to be simple adequate so that you can do each and every exactly the same. Also keep in mind that tall is not constantly better so make certain you have parameters below manage. If they are for a table show, folks usually like to see the individuals on the other side of the table.

  49. The new Zune browser is surprisingly good, but not as good as the iPod’s. It works well, but isn’t as fast as Safari, and has a clunkier interface. If you occasionally plan on using the web browser that’s not an issue, but if you’re planning to browse the web alot from your PMP then the iPod’s larger screen and better browser may be important.

  50. Thanks for sharing those tit bits of information.. surely made my day. =)

  51. Bennie Zank says:

    cheers for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and enjoy learning more on this subject. If possible, as you gain expertise, could you mind updating your weblog with far more details? as it really is extremely valuable for me.