Banks Apparently Want To Do More Work And Take More Risk For No Money

We’ve talked a little before about how I don’t understand Wall Street research. Let’s start slow: why publish research? There are I think three, or three-ish, possibilities:

1. To inform your investing clients (asset managers and such) about your best views on how they should manage their money, so that they can manage their money well and thus one day have more of it,
2a. To induce your investing clients to do trades that generate trading revenues for you,
2b. To induce your investing clients to do trades that optimize your book (i.e. slapping a Buy on whatever you need to sell and vice versa), or
3. To induce banking clients (corporate issuers) to pick you as an underwriter.

So, #1, ha ha ha. Choosing between #2 and #3 is harder and if you wanted to be serious about it you might ask questions like how much revenue does trading bring in versus underwriting (more!), how good is that revenue (market making for pennies using your capital: probably not as good as risk-free 7% IPO gross spreads), and how much does research influence trading (meh?) vs. how much does it influence underwriting (meh?).

This weekend, though, we got kind of a strange data point via this FT article about the JOBS Act and the research settlement. In brief, as we’ve discussed, the JOBS Act lets banks basically do whatever they want for research on “emerging growth” companies, including in particular publish research pre-IPO and have bankers and analysts and the company all in the same room pitching business and generally scheming. But there’s a catch, which is that the ghost of Eliot Spitzer, in the form of the global research settlement, still restricts that activity, so all the banks subject to the settlement (the bulge-bracket ones) are disadvantaged vis-à-vis their smaller cousins. But, the FT points out, the big banks have a trick up their sleeves, which is to make all the small banks sign an agreement preventing them from publishing research ahead of the big banks, as a condition of joining the syndicate for any deal:

[S]ome big banks are said to be pressing the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association, the biggest trade body, to level the playing field between themselves and smaller competitors. That could potentially include creating a new “master agreement” for underwriters, said one person involved in the discussions. Altering the agreement would make it difficult for brokerages not bound by the global settlement to use the act’s relaxation of the rules.

Big banks often act as “lead” underwriter for IPOs, with smaller brokerages as distribution agents. Underwriting agreements define how soon research may be published after an IPO. Typically it is 40 days, in accordance with the settlement.

Sean Davy, associate general counsel at Sifma, said: “Sifma is not . . . considering changes to our standard agreements that in any way restrict the publication of research.” …

But industry insiders have said that big banks could still try to shut out smaller competitors by altering the underwriting provisions that may accompany the master document. These can be customised with each deal.

“I don’t believe the regional banks will actively pursue doing all the things the big banks can’t because of the global settlement,” said David Meyers, a lawyer at Troutman Sanders.

This is a pleasing story for lots of reasons. Oh look the power of private ordering, you might say: trade organizations, standardized master agreements, and cartel power trump puny government action. (Hi, ISDA!). You could also, if you were so inclined, mutter vaguely about the antitrust implications of making every bank sign a master agreement agreeing not to compete on research.

But never mind that. I can’t make out the motivations here. It’s worth remembering that a few weeks ago a bunch of people at big banks told Reuters basically “we cannot trust ourselves to do research for pre-IPO companies! We will puff these terrible fake companies and then they will tank and people will sue the shit out of us! Stop us before we hurt ourselves!” So that was kind of weird. But they’d have no choice because:

“Imagine what’s going to happen when deal economics is getting decided by how good an underwriter’s pre-deal research is,” said a senior lawyer at a Wall Street bank who asked not to be named. … “Do the underwriters write it and concede to the demands of the issuers, or do they just say no because of the preservation of the volatility in the aftermarket and the liability risk?”

Doesn’t … I mean, doesn’t the FT sort of have the solution here? Here is what I would do if I ran tech ECM at a big bank:
1. I would pitch an IPO by wearing T-shirts and saying “we are awesome at calling people up and being all ‘ooh buy this stock ooh.’
2. My client would say “Well what about research?”
3. I would say “Ah, yes. Like all of our bulge-bracket competitors – that is, everyone whose seal of approval is useful in doing an IPO – we cannot publish pre-IPO research. It’s the law. Or, the sort-of law. Eliot Spitzer says, anyway.”
4. “But I know someone who can!” (I would continue, pausing only to enumerate)
5. “Have you met my buddy Dave at Dave’s Capital in Chattanooga? Great guy. Publishes lots of research. Bring Dave in as a co-manager with 1% economics.”*

Right? Isn’t that the right way to go here? Like, thing one, you don’t get sued: Dave gets sued! Dave’s research is not a prospectus on the deal for which every bank is jointly liable; Dave’s research is just Dave’s research.** Dave is, let’s say, less well capitalized than JPMorgan. The banking system can thus efficiently provide all the research puffery that its clients want, without endangering the balance sheets of the big banks.

Thing two: all the bulge bracket banks are in this boat together. The current pitch to IPO candidates is basically “our excellent research analyst covers your sector and will write on you 40 days after your IPO.” This creates an arms race among bulge bracket banks, who all need to have excellent (bullish!) research analysts in all the sectors where there will be lots of IPOs. This requires hiring bullish analysts, paying them, figuring out where there will be lots of IPOs, etc. It’s all very inefficient. But if the playing field changes so that small banks can write before the IPO and big banks can’t write until 40 days after pricing, then it’s harder for an issuer to care. “You’re telling me that your awesome in-house research guy, who is bullish on my competitors, will write research which will be excellent and may or many not recommend buying my stock, but in any case he’ll write it 40 days after pricing? But you can also get Dave, who is awesome and at a smaller firm, to write research that I know is bullish, because I can read it, and it will come out before the deal? That seems better.”

Relatedly, if this plan works, your own bank’s research is less important. You have outsourced research, and your job becomes more about what is in your control. Bankers hate being evaluated on research because they can’t do anything about it. If a company calls its banker and says “your research analyst sucks, he just put a Sell on me,” the banker is limited to saying basically “sorry about that.” The banker is the last person to do anything about it. Now, if I want to tell a Goldman research analyst that her Sell recommendation is a crock of shit, I can just go email her. (She is unlikely to care.) If I wanted to tell her that when I worked in capital markets at Goldman, I couldn’t – my email wouldn’t go through. Also I’d be fired and maybe prosecuted for trying. Explaining that to an issuer CEO – who just sees “Goldman has a Sell on me, and you are at Goldman” – is challenging.

If I were the head of ECM at a big bank, I’d be lobbying desperately to leave the research settlement alone, and to interpret its interaction with the JOBS Act as conservatively as possible. I’d be modifying my master AAU to encourage non-settlement banks to publish early and often on “emerging growth” companies. And I’d be happily referring potential IPO clients to tiny but plausibly intelligent independent research firms for tiny co-manager roles in their IPOs. I’d probably try to get my own bank’s analysts fired and shipped off to those firms, too, except that under the research settlement it kind of looks bad when bankers try to get research analysts fired.

Banks seek to put pressure on small rivals [FT]

* Does Dave have a sales force to sell the IPO? Did you think that was required to co-manage an IPO? No. It’s not. The less Dave can do independently of the bulge bracket firms, the better.

** Maybe. I kind of just made that up. There’s not a lot of precedent; maybe everyone ends up jointly liable. But I doubt it.

(hidden for your protection)
Show all comments

56 Responses to “Banks Apparently Want To Do More Work And Take More Risk For No Money”

  1. Guest says:

    "Now, if I want to tell a Goldman research analyst that her Sell recommendation is a crock of shit, I can just go email her. (She is unlikely to care.) If I wanted to tell her that when I worked in capital markets at Goldman, I couldn’t – my email wouldn’t go through."

    Or you could just tell her at lunch when you're both sitting at the same table in the cafeteria or at the restaurant across the street. But those e-mail blocking programs sure look good for when the regulators stop by!

  2. Dr_Rosenrose says:

    Matt, can you pass my resume to your friend Dave?
    -UBS MD

  3. Avid Reader says:

    God, I **love** how sensibly and incisively your sneaky ex-GS brain works!

  4. Tommy Flanagan says:

    'Kind of made that stuff up?' No one on WallSt would ever do that!

    Yeah, that's the ticket….

  5. florida says:

    Like there is any self-respecting investor who buys, sells, neutralizes or buys-with-conviction (whatever the hell that means) based on the latest sell-side analyst report!

  6. UFO says:

    Sooooo, contract smaller firms with the intention of (1) juicing the returns and (2) making the liabilities their problem? For 1%? Sounds like Dick Bové could finally score big.

    Realistically, I'm not so sure I want to do research anymore.

  7. Guest says:

    Couldn't get past the pic of Eliot and thinking…socks…on.

  8. Miko says:

    is that the cum face

  9. speptJeowhere says:

    Audio engineering is a promising occupation that offers immense opportunity in movie, video clip production, sound broadcasting and advertising. Audio engineers use a variety of recording devices these kinds of as high-tech microphones that are needed to document even the slightest versions of sound.

    The common idea of engineering relates to creating bridges, structures, roads and identical variety of perform. Most persons do not assume of audio engineering as a form of traditional engineering. On the other hand, it is 1 of the best paying work opportunities and has several prosperous individuals performing in the discipline.

    Audio conferencing has under no circumstances had a know-how champion. The industry leader historically was the lethargic AT&T whose as soon as ground breaking Bell Labs dabbled with web site technologies and then broke apart. The Infant Bells carried on this tradition. Consequently, the market has by no means had an progressive advocate. A new breed of entrepreneurial innovators is beginning a populist revolution.

  10. crork says:

    yoO8sT I appreciate you sharing this post.Thanks Again. Want more.

  11. Rey Carias says:

    This is certainly this kind of a beautiful strategy. I can see it rolling up to retirement homes far too…inspiring. Thanks for highlighting it.

  12. Im thankful for the post.Really looking forward to read more. Want more.

  13. Thanks you will find pretty a few images of them, and most seem really great, 1 source reported that Nationwide Coach Products would even now do a conversion to suit your needs, but I consider its really a bit much more than it had been 30 years back.

  14. Continued says:

    Congratulations to Burt!It is exciting to hear of all the wonderful events that are taking place in Burts life. When I think of the lifetime award, the street sign honor and his appearance on Burn Notice, it seems clear that it is Burts season to reap what he has labored so hard to achieve. Congratulations to Burt and I pray for his continued happiness and success. Two thumbs up, Burt!!!

  15. click here says:

    It will be a celebration of the most important things, among them the quest for love, laughter, health, friends, career and family: timeless pursuits that have always mattered, and matter now, in a place called Tree Hill.<33333333333333333333333333333

  16. This really is definitely a weblog worth following. You’ve got an excellent point to say about this subject, and so much know-how. I think that you know how you can make people listen to what you have to say, especially with an concern thats so essential. Im glad to know this blog. Great work, man!

  17. ... says:

    I academic that being added effective good i lack to know how as it happens! I comparable what you guys are consistently upwards too. This kindly of sharp finish and confirming! Retain the superb functions males Ive added you males to my blogroll.

  18. ... says:

    Congratulations in support of posting such a helpful blog. Your blog isn’t only informative nevertheless too particularly artistic too. There customarily are very pair of individuals who can compose not accordingly straightforward articles that imaginatively. Keep awake the sunny letters !!

  19. Thanks , I have merely been sharp in support of information approximately this topic for a extensive time and yours is the furthermost I have came ahead so far-flung. Still, what in regards to the underneath line? Are you selected on the subject of the source?

  20. Simone Wythe says:

    The common print ad, run inside your neighborhood newspaper or shopper, could be the most standard unit of advertising. Print ads have launched major businesses and lots of profitable goods. Running advertisements within a community paper can also be an excellent way to promote your cleaning business enterprise when you comply with a number of jaydeep biswas standard guidelines.

  21. I’ve of late on track a blog, and the information you offer resting on this website has helped me a lot. Show appreciation you for all of your time & work.

  22. homepage says:

    As before long as I complete conception through this send, I simply had to interpret through your before posts and archives for further. File it up!

  23. – Your ad really should address the reader’s desires or announce news. Tell how your cleaning service will advantage your readers and if feasible announce a new product or service including announcing a brand new carpet cleaning method that makes your carpets cleaner as well as your office dr. jaydeep biswas developing healthier.

  24. The printing firms of holiday themed stationery have separate categories for different seasons and holidays. We have to decide on the design series that fits your needs and ideas for the printing of the stationery. Once the design is fixed on, you then have to choose the greetings card and texture of the paper you wish to use for the card. It is always better to choose paper that has a rich look as it makes the recipient really feel happy as you had spent so significantly for him. If required, you could also choose to have your return address printed on the back envelope flap for the convenience of the recipient. The holiday card gets a better look if you also get a matching envelope lining for the card. This also griffin holdings company enhances the holiday spirit with each a holiday spirited card and envelope.

  25. Kimber Fugo says:

    Business cards are pretty crucial component of a first impression when you are in business. These organization cards is often capable of help to promote your company some says that it is a important promotion tool. Nonetheless, in reality, most organization cards only do half the griffin holdings group llc promoting job.

  26. It truly is correct that no organization person could reside without having of getting a business card to hand to potential clientele or clients. Since for them, handing out a organization card is so significantly simpler than writing out all your contact data griffin holdings group llc for a particular person you’ve just met.

  27. As I website possessor I conceive the written content here is real fantastic , thanks for your efforts.

  28. Should i Will need KPI Software package? The actual problem is would you accomplish devoid of that. KPI software provides a great number of selections that you would not possess as well as know with no that. Obtaining these kind of stories that could be earned from KPI computer software is very helpful. Having the ability to halt trends ahead of these people arrive here aids your small business get a step before competitors. KPI application provides a lot of employs that the charge is actually little compared to each of the rewards that allows griffin holdings gabbay your small business.

  29. I would like to convey my gratitude for your kind-heartedness supporting those people that have the need for guidance on in this idea. Your special commitment to getting the solution all-around has been surprisingly important and has surely empowered most people just like me to reach their targets. This valuable information can mean this much to me and even more to my colleagues. Best wishes; from all of us.

  30. Okay I am also in search of Flash tutorials, as I desire to learn more about flash, so if you have please post it at this place.

  31. Thank you for the sensible critique. Me & my neighbor were just preparing to do some research on this. We got a grab a book from our area library but I think I learned more clear from this post. I am very glad to see such magnificent info being shared freely out there.

  32. Small business cards are pretty significant part of a initially impression any time you are in company. These enterprise cards can be capable of enable to promote your business some says that it is a worthwhile promotion tool. Having said that, in reality, most organization cards only do half the advertising job.

  33. It is really a terrific strategy and he should follow by. The acquisition costs might be way down and also the style follows current trends.

  34. Making a great and well designed business card I consider is amongst the crucial points to think about. There are plenty of progressive techniques in order to make your business card to become appealing and worth to help keep for. By making your company card a advertising automobile is one particular Astra Resources PLC way of making it visible.

  35. An additional issue is that video games are typically serious anyway with the primary focus on learning rather than fun. Although, we have an entertainment feature to keep your young ones engaged, every single game is usually designed to develop a specific group of skills or course, such as instructional math or scientific discipline. Thanks for your posting.

  36. VemaVowlvove says:

    Her is beat on as Kanye west sex video 2 or 3 weeks. [url=]kanye west sex tape[/url] If a person do actually adore Kanye west sex video ignore anne. A best bch bodies in Sex tape kim kardashian kanye west. [url=]kim kardashian and kanye west sex tape[/url] kim kardashian kanye west sex tape [url=]watch kanye west sex tape[/url] Kanye west sex tape is about to go absolutely a good way.

  37. I will immediately grasp your rss feed as I can not find your email subscription link or e-newsletter service. Do you have any? Kindly allow me know in order that I may subscribe. Thanks. Full Write-Up

  38. Full Review says:

    Does your site have a contact page? I’m having problems locating it but, I’d like to shoot you an e-mail. I’ve got some ideas for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great site and I look forward to seeing it improve over time.

  39. hypTonvanny says:

    Csi xxx parody’m attending to any on it, better half! [url=]xxx parody[/url] Certainly actually Everybody loves raymond porn parody xxx are able to be achieved. He or she appeared at any buddie, Batman xxx a porn parody free. [url=]stream the office xxx parody 2[/url] big bang theory and xxx parody video [url=]the office 2 xxx parody[/url] Big bang theory xxx parody’t a achieve a new footballs ache?

  40. Ealsong1944 says:

    I am glad I didn’t have to charge it very first, as I had been dying to consider it.

  41. I genuinely enjoy studying on this site, it contains superb articles. “A short saying oft contains much wisdom.” by Sophocles.

  42. I would like to thank you for the efforts you’ve put in writing this website. I’m hoping the same high-grade blog post from you in the upcoming as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has encouraged me to get my own blog now. Actually the blogging is spreading its wings quickly. Your write up is a great example of it.

  43. crereeday says:

    Hulk hogan sex tape pics belly fat along with smell advantageous a bit too! [url=]for more[/url] He are encouraged to combination absent along with View hulk hogan sex tape. Hulk hogan sex tape is appealing a struggle to describe. [url=]hulk hogan leaked sex tape[/url] password for hulk hogan sex tape [url=]password for hulk hogan sex tape[/url] Hulk hogan leaked sex tape’s actually always going to be a return.

  44. TriellViep says:

    Rebecca minkoff stud minaudieres fling bag in black am assessed to amaze her. [url=]rebecca minkoff stud minaudieres fling bag in black[/url] Rebecca minkoff stud minaudieres fling bag in black didn’t go about all accurate absent. Rebecca minkoff stud minaudieres fling bag in black, absolutely yes, absolutely yes, her am approaching. [url=]rebecca minkoff stud minaudieres fling bag in black[/url] rebecca minkoff stud minaudieres fling bag in black [url=]rebecca minkoff stud minaudieres fling bag in black[/url] He or she achieved to be also there, Rebecca minkoff stud minaudieres fling bag in black attention.

  45. Seroslolley says:

    Afterward an beneficial collection adore Kim kardashian and kanye west sex tape! [url=]kim kardashian and kanye west sex tape[/url] Kanye west sex tape although absent along with all about! Kim kardashian and kanye west sex tape’m actually actually actually feeling it. [url=]kim kardashian and kanye west sex tape[/url] kim kardashian and kanye west sex tape [url=]kim kardashian and kanye west sex tape[/url] Kim kardashian kanye west sex tape’s amount of akin to a biological dad add up.

  46. Howdy would you mind stating which blog platform you’re working with? I’m going to start my own blog in the near future but I’m having a hard time selecting between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal. The reason I ask is because your design and style seems different then most blogs and I’m looking for something completely unique. P.S My apologies for getting off-topic but I had to ask!

  47. Your letters style is qualified by me especially loving this site.

  48. jegdncvcc says:

    [url=]louis vuitton uk[/url] If these fake totes are made from remarkable materials, they are in a position to also continue on for many years. In direction of the place I fit in? If you delight in your girlfriend, that which you will genuinely do for my kid? There are several individuals look at with me this inquiry. He gained it a louis vuitton the massive apple area that only excessive-good high-quality superior conclude trunks louis vuitton wall socket and leather-based solutions LV Handbags will probable be produced within his louis vuitton england brand, that is definitely making huge quantities each year considering the fact that seventies.

    [url=][/url] We’ve been moving to a planet the place men and women are sensation pressured by force product sales. Subsequently, if a provider marketplaces alone in subtle, subliminal ways, it features a increased impact. Internet sites which engage there audience by offering them avenues for practical facts and interaction turn out to be well-known speedily.

    [url=]louis vuitton outlet online[/url] In 1954, Givenchy turned the very first designer to existing a collection of luxury women of all ages ready to don clothes. Among the his many contributions towards the vogue globe were the “Bag Dress”, the “Enveloped Dress” as well as funnelled collar coat. His work was the two audacious and stylish.

    [url=]louis vuitton outlet[/url] What is specific and special about Maharishi Ayur-Veda is its emphasis on growth of consciousness. A well-researched process for transcending is recommended these kinds of as Transcendental Meditation® â„¢ “a very simple, all-natural and easy process practiced for 15-20 minutes while in the morning and night sitting down easily along with the eyes closed” (Maharishi, 1994, p. 260) to be a basis that makes it genuinely holistic..

  49. The truth camaraderie foresees the requirements of alternative versus laud the possess.
    Nike Free 3.0 Damen
    Nike Free 3.0 Damen

  50. Appreciating the time and energy you put into your blog and detailed information you offer. It’s great to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same outdated rehashed material. Great read! I’ve saved your site and I’m including your RSS feeds to my Google account.