Phil Falcone’s Alleged Piggish Behavior Made Him Some Enemies

If you knew nothing about Phil Falcone but what you read in the SEC’s assortment of complaints against him today, you would probably conclude that he’s kind of a dick. The loan thing, of course – Falcone borrowed $113mm from Harbinger at the same time he was preventing investors from withdrawing their money – but also a whole range of new and exciting charges announced today. Like that time he got mad at his prime broker and so bought 113% of the issue of a bond that the prime broker was short, and then called in the prime broker’s borrow to screw them (and gloated to them about it). Or the time – sorry, three times – that he shorted stock of companies that were doing equity offerings and then illegally covered his short with his allocation in those offerings.

Robert Khuzami is right about the marvelous variety and inventiveness of Harbinger’s scammy ways, but lots of people do lots of bad things on Wall Street. It’s just that usually their victims are either diffuse markets (insider trading) or widows and orphans (Ponzi schemes etc.) – it’s rare to spend so much time screwing so many big institutions. And it’s maybe even rarer for the SEC to stick up for those institutions.

Start with the thing that’s gotten the most attention so far: the loan that allowed Falcone to take $113mm out of his fund when investors were not allowed to redeem. How did no one tell him that that was a bad idea? Well:

25. In early April 2009, the idea of a loan from a Harbinger fund to pay Falcone’s personal taxes, as well as other obligations, arose during discussions between Harbinger personnel and Harbinger’s longstanding outside law firm (“Law Firm B”). At that time, a partner at Law Firm B told Harbinger in an email that “[l]ending money to principals is not part of the fund’s investment program.”

26. In addition, a Law Firm B partner told Harbinger in a separate e-mail that it would “never be comfortable with this . . . a loan . . . will never be a good idea.” Another Law Firm B partner added on the same email that a loan to a principal is “not what investors expect their money to be used for.” An in-house Harbinger lawyer forwarded this e-mail to Falcone, stating that “[Law Firm B] is unequivocally against the loan idea for a number of reasons,” and Falcone responded “ok.”

Chastened (?), he talked to a bank that offered to lend him money at market rates secured by his “two Manhattan townhouses and artwork … interest in a National Hockey League team and an estate on the Caribbean island of St. Barts.” This however did not catch his fancy, in part because he didn’t take phrases like “will never be a good idea” too literally. “One proposal that Falcone heard in September 2009, however, did interest him: taking a loan from [Harbinger’s Special Situations Fund] using his SSF interest, rather than other personal assets, as collateral.” You might think investors would object to that, but that’s just because they didn’t know what a good deal it would be if it was the deal that they were told it was, which it wasn’t:

43. The Loan Agreement provided that the interest rate to be paid on the loan was “the higher of” (1) the Applicable Federal Rate, which at the time was 2.66 percent, plus 1 percent; or (2) “the Lender’s actual cost of funds as determined by the Lender in its reasonable discretion plus one percent.” At the time, SSF was paying 7 percent on an outstanding loan, which provided a measure of SSF’s cost of funds. The Defendants, however, did not use the “cost of funds” measure, and instead Falcone paid a highly favorable rate of 3.66 percent. …

57. In addition, in an email dated September 29, 2010, Falcone advised an investor representative that “we had vetted [the loan] extensively with outside counsel . . . The [loan] furthermore, was collateralized by all my holdings, essentially 14x.” Both statements were false. Law Firm A did no due diligence or vetting, and the collateral for the loan was limited to Falcone’s interest in SSF, which was less than two times coverage.

Taking $113mm in cash out of the fund made it harder to meet the redemption requests from the more than 80% of SSF investors who wanted to redeem, so he then made SSF’s gates more restrictive, which required an investor vote, which he obtained by giving some big investment sponsors preferential liquidity in undisclosed side letters, which I guess is bad but sort of meh compared to the rest of today’s charges.

Like the short squeeze in which Harbinger bought a big chunk of some bonds (called “zips”) issued by MAAX Holdings, and then found out that his prime broker was shorting those bonds:

45. Sometime during the summer of 2006, the Harbinger analyst began hearing rumors that there was aggressive short selling in the MAAX zips. The analyst’s sources on the street speculated that one of Harbinger’s prime brokers — the Wall Street firm — and its customers were shorting the MAAX zips and trying to drive their price down. The analyst informed Falcone.

46. Falcone was angered by this. He speculated that the Wall Street firm was putting its proprietary trading interest ahead of his own—that it was undercutting the value of his MAAX position and possibly borrowing his own notes to cover its short position.

The SEC talked to the prime broker and they swear they had a good reason for doing the trade unrelated to screwing/front-running Falcone, but I guess they didn’t tell him that, so he retaliated amazingly by buying 113% of the issue:

54. Harbinger was able to acquire more than the entire issue of the MAAX zips because there is no “locate” requirement when short-selling debt instruments. … Thus, “naked” short selling of bonds is legal, which can lead to “long” positions far in excess of the issue size.

Now that he owned more than all the bonds, he repaid his margin loan to the prime broker and demanded that the prime broker return the bonds that it had been borrowing for its short:

73. Sometime in the spring of 2007, Harbinger, at Falcone’s direction, paid off the debt in its margin account and demanded that the Wall Street firm return any securities it had borrowed, including MAAX zips. …

83. At some point, the conversation turned to the trading in the MAAX bonds. The senior officer asked Falcone how the Wall Street firm might satisfy its obligation to Harbinger. Falcone stated that the Wall Street firm should just keep bidding for the bonds. Falcone acknowledged that the Wall Street firm would suffer some losses doing so, but told the senior officer and the others that sometimes you are just on the wrong side of a trade.

84. In the course of this discussion, Falcone stated that he knew that the short position in the MAAX zips had created a “long” position in excess of the issue size. When the senior officer asked how he could possibly know this, Falcone stated that he was working the position himself and that he (i.e., Harbinger) had acquired approximately 190 million bonds. The senior officer and the other the Wall Street firm personnel were stunned.

Finally there’s a series of garden-variety Rule 105 violations, in which (1) a company announced that it would be selling stock, (2) Harbinger shorted shares of that company’s stock, and (3) Harbinger got allocated shares in the company’s offering that it then used to cover its short, essentially front-running the company’s stock sale and making an instant profit on its allocation. This is illegal but more important it’s a dick move: it screws the issuer and the issuer’s investment bank and if they knew you were doing it you’d never get allocated a deal again.*

These are all … I cannot emphasize enough what dick moves these are. But the giant collection of SEC lawsuits is weird, isn’t it? The Rule 105 violations are clearly illegal and frequently pursued, but they’re also not that big a deal and it’s even possible to do them accidentally (one trader shorts, another buys in the deal, etc.). Here they were sort of self-reported (“After an inquiry from the Commission, Harbinger self-reported two of the violative transactions,” which, what?), settled quickly, and led a fine of $857,950, small potatoes compared to the rest of the cases.

The borrowing from his own fund is much much worse, but it’s also the sort of thing normally dealt with by the big institutional investors in the fund suing him, not the SEC: there is a gloss of disclosure-violation in the SEC’s complaint, but the basic problem is Falcone’s violating his fiduciary duties to, and contracts with, his investors. And the MAAX short squeeze is wonderfully evil, but again, it’s the sort of thing that is usually settled by the prime broker refusing ever to deal with you again and telling all their friends to do the same. (Did you even know it was illegal? Seems cruel but fair to me.) You don’t often see the SEC rushing to the defense of a big Wall Street firm that got itself in trouble by doing too much naked short selling of Canadian bonds.

Philip A. Falcone and Harbinger Charged with Securities Fraud []

* Am I bitter because I worked on one of those deals whose stock price cratered in part because of Falcone’s illegal short sales? YOU BET I AM.

(hidden for your protection)
Show all comments

60 Responses to “Phil Falcone’s Alleged Piggish Behavior Made Him Some Enemies”

  1. Bonobos says:

    Did someone say shorts!?

  2. Wilbur says:


  3. Matt's Therapist says:

    Calm down now Matt, just go to your happy place, just think of charts and graphs and all the standardized tests and margs you could ever want.

  4. Conspiracy Quant says:

    So Samuel Israel III is now a self loathing Jew and also has gotten internet access, interesting developments indeed, try to stay on track with the JFK stuff though moving forward, thanks.

  5. UBS MD says:

    Yea, clearly the only reason they rag on us is all that Nazi gold bullshit, if it weren't for that we know they'd give us all the respect we deserve!

    -Delusional Civic Owner

  6. guest says:

    There are "so many" posts on Falcone, i.e. 3, because he's a major hedge fund manager who's been accused of fraud. There are references to barnyard animals because Falcone, by his own admission, owns a pet pig that plays the piano. Sorry, I know you were looking for an answer that fit into your batshit insane theory. In sum: go sell crazy somewhere else.

  7. Wilbur says:

    If, and this is only a big if, certain employees have to move on to alternative living arrangements for a time being, greener pastures if you will, all of you better make it to the god damn going away party!

  8. Abe_Froman_ says:

    Thanks for the insight Adolf

  9. Wilbur's Broker says:

    Wait, ML, the great defender of Raj and sale to fail synthetic CDSs has now discovered ethics? I'm just going to hazard a guess and say Gary Cohn's crotch in the face move over the Harbinger fiasco moved his moral compass.

  10. gab says:

    "But the giant collection of SEC lawsuits is weird, isn’t it?"

    It may be weird, but the guy's a dick and he deserves it, and a kick in the balls – although looking at his wife, he might be into that…

  11. Charlotte says:

    So much for spinning this guy as humble.

    – a grey spider

  12. guest says:

    So if I buy 113% of a thing, I don't get to set the price of that thing?

  13. HFguy says:

    It gets worse, there exists a secondary market where people in gated hedge funds can sell their stakes to others willing to buy at whatever price they agree on. it is usually simple and a few legal docs exchanged and money and stake are exchanged. but Phil brought upon him further investor anger by not willing to let investors who wanted out to sell their stake to someone else willing to punt his lighsquare would take off. this is very unlike any other fund and whatever little friends he had he lost them as well.

  14. FalconesDaMan says:

    Perhaps you should actually READ Rule 105.

    c. Excepted Offerings. This section shall not apply to offerings that are not conducted on a firm commitment basis.

    When was the last time you saw a firm commitment underwriting? Nineteen seventy what again?

  15. Guest says:

    "Did you even know it was illegal? Seems cruel but fair to me."

    I think you mean, "Seems tough but fair". Other than that, no concerns..

  16. PursePuppy says:

    How awesome was that move to punish the firm for shorting the zips?! I would love to have the seen the faces at the firm when he revealed he held the long position.

  17. It’s a shame you don’t have a donate button! I’d definitely donate to this excellent blog! I guess for now i’ll settle for book-marking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to fresh updates and will share this site with my Facebook group. Talk soon!

  18. clean up crew says:

    Eh Frank you know what a Hasa is? It's a pig dat don't fly straight

  19. WebhostingRelated Sites : web host

  20. Genuinely looking forward to the clearly show in France as I work with museum installations and booth development its quite exciting to discover this great work.

  21. I don’t seriously care how or when i get the Letters within the Mail. Each time it arrives, it feels like a letter must be. It is really suddenly there in my mail box one particular day. A great, tangible surprise. I’m to suit your needs carrying out whatever you want when you send it. Mix it up to the people today who assist get it sent out. Include crumbs from your lunch. Coffee stains. Whatever. Retain the monotonous mother nature of receiving letters out to the minimum by performing whatever you think that that day. The arrival of your letter and also the terms of the author inside are what matters. Personally, what I like very best in regards to the Rumpus is usually that I in no way really know what I will browse that day. Or if there isn’t really one that day, perhaps it is really since Stephen couldn’t discover everything to say or there was too much happening.

  22. Chaya Cosmo says:

    I like squid fish sauce.

  23. Hey! Someone in my Myspace group shared this site with us so I came to check it out. I’m definitely enjoying the information. I’m book-marking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Wonderful blog and excellent design and style.

  24. i heard and saw so many documantries about her yes she had her troubles like most of us but i truley admire her beside her amazing beauty she was very smart i wonder why some people called her a dumb alot of her frinds and coleages said she was very smart and talented also she was very strong woman it is to shame that she died tragically so young she was also a very kind woman.

  25. link says:

    Virginia, wise up. Obamas plan will force insurance companies out of business and you will be left with no option but to join his plan. Read the bill!!! You may become smarter than the politicians who wont read it. Those who have read it say it is a travesty for the people of this country. Wise up!! Obama doesnt want you to know the truth, hes like a magician playing slight of hand and selling you snake oil for your health.

  26. Hi it is my very first comment on this website and firstly I would like to thank for that great information, which I had been able to discover in this and all earlier posts , it truly helped me a great deal. I’ll definitely add this weblog on my google reader :) Also, I wants to ask – don’t you mind if I’ll quate some info out of your blog because I am writing articles for that Associated Content, Ezine and other content articles directories (this is my part time job)? It would truly assist me with some of mine content articles. Of course, I’ll mention your weblog title or URL (not all content articles sites enables URL’s , so I can’t 100% promise that you’ll get a direct link for your website)

  27. go here says:

    Very interesting points you’ve got prominent, appreciate it for putting up.

  28. Oscar Cochis says:

    They’ve a big package deal associated with supplies in every types of formats which were thoroughly tested – many times – by simply successful home business enterprise individuals jaydeep biswas exactly to assist you do well.

  29. Hi! Someone in my Facebook group shared this site with us so I came to take a look. I’m definitely enjoying the information. I’m bookmarking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Outstanding blog and amazing design.

  30. Start by setting an advertising spending budget. A general rule of thumb will be to dedicate two to 5 percent of one’s expected gross sales to marketing. For anyone who is expecting $150,000 in gross sales, put aside $3000 to $7500 for marketing. When you are just starting your cleaning company this may perhaps not be adequate. You could possibly ought to invest additional dollars running ads announcing your company so your potential jaydeep biswas clientele know a brand new cleaning service is in town.

  31. Your ad should attract attention! Despite the fact that this sounds apparent, unless your ad attracts focus that you are throwing your revenue down the drain. By far the most compelling technique to have a “noticeable” ad will be to have an fascinating and visually attractive headline. If you are designing a sizable ad, consider applying a subhead. This may offer added information and facts jaydeep biswas and may be longer than the headline.

  32. – Your ad should address the reader’s requires or announce news. Tell how your cleaning service will advantage your readers and if attainable announce a brand new item or service which include announcing a brand new carpet cleaning technique that makes your carpets cleaner and your office dr. jaydeep biswas building healthier.

  33. Producing your ad stand out can be challenge. Scan your community papers and take notice of what ads stand out – are they advertisements with reverse (white on dark background) print, color ads, ads that appear like they were hand drawn? Individuals discover advertisements which have illustrations or photographs that show merchandise or advertisements which have dr. jaydeep biswas persons in them.

  34. Small business cards are very crucial element of a 1st impression once you are in enterprise. These organization cards might be in a position to assistance to promote your company some says that it’s a precious promotion tool. Having said that, in reality, most business enterprise cards only do half the griffin holdings group llc advertising job.

  35. Print advertising is one technique to get your cleaning business’ name out in front of possible customers and also reminding your existing clients from the services you deliver. Marketing is salesmanship as well as the far more data you can give about your services, the much more interest you can expect to dr. jaydeep biswas generate.

  36. As a substitute for the traditional organization card, why not try get your get in touch with facts printed on something that individuals could leave in plain sight; anything that could remind them of you as well as your services or items whenever they look at it. Why not make it message pads, coasters, mouse pads or maybe make it as fridge magnets. The decision of the small business card design is limited only by your imagination. By making it effortless for people today to bear in mind you by utilizing far more unusual designs and types on your company card griffin holdings group llc can be a smart investment.

  37. Resources says:

    Thanks in support of the ideas you are discussing by this web situate. A different thing I lack to utter is that getting retain of approximately copies of your credit rating in enjoin to scrutinize accuracy of apiece factor will be the formerly actions you have to undertake in honor slash development. You are looking to clean cheery your credit testimony commencing destructive particulars errors that damage your credit score.

  38. I must voice my respect for your kindness giving support to all those that actually need guidance on this one field. Your personal dedication to passing the solution all around turned out to be amazingly significant and has encouraged women much like me to achieve their ambitions. Your personal insightful guidelines denotes so much a person like me and even more to my fellow workers. Warm regards; from each one of us.

  39. wine cooler says:

    I’m still learning from you, but I’m bettering myself. I certainly love reading every part that’s written in your blog.Preserve the stories coming. I cherished it!

  40. nusajaya sq says:

    You will inevitably begin to see your options and make the payments on their secured debt, and it’s usually credit card debt. This will keep you from paying hefty sums of money coming out of the loan balance, the policy might not cover your personal contents. Determining Coverage Keep in mind that property damage auto insurance policy refer to the manner in which the determination of whether a peril is covered while it is difficult to manage. {||||

  41. I continue to keep seeing people today refer to “Northern Virginia,” and then offering addresses in Falls Church and Alexandria. Can we’ve some suggestions for outside the house the Beltway, be sure to, for people of us who’ve an hour’s commute in with the West as far as Dulles, and do not choose to go a whole lot farther?

  42. Another advantage is no grunting noise, just pure silence of the pedals. With fuel prices skyrocketing, electric bicycles and lightweight electric vehicles are designed for almost no maintenance and have a life of more than 20 products to choose from.

  43. Hello! Do you know if they make any plugins to assist with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good success. If you know of any please share. Cheers!

  44. Fantastic blog you have here but I was curious about if you knew of any message boards that cover the same topics discussed here? I’d really love to be a part of online community where I can get comments from other knowledgeable people that share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Thank you!

  45. Curt Koth says:

    Useful info. Lucky me I found your web site unintentionally, and I’m surprised why this twist of fate didn’t came about in advance! I bookmarked it.

  46. hyip firm says:

    Well I sincerely liked reading it. This tip procured by you is very constructive for correct planning.

  47. Hmm is anyone else experiencing problems with the pictures on this blog loading? I’m trying to determine if its a problem on my end or if it’s the blog. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

  48. Well, mine is a smoker, but I made it pretty clear that he wasn’t going to smoke in the house when we moved in around 10 years ago, and he hasn’t, he smokes in the garage! I do think it is pretty inconsiderate for your hubby to winge about smoking outside when it clearly causes you serious health problems (which go beyond just a cough’). He is inflicting this on you by choosing to smoke, so it should be up to him to either change his habits, not you!

  49. Do you mind if I quote a few of your articles as long as I provide credit and sources back to your website? My website is in the very same area of interest as yours and my visitors would genuinely benefit from some of the information you provide here. Please let me know if this alright with you. Regards!

  50. Fantastic blog you have here!