There is much to ponder about Nasdaq’s slow-moving plans to compensate the people it screwed by taking its time confirming trades on the day Facebook opened.* Here’s a fun thing I didn’t quite understand, from Reuters:

Nasdaq’s liabilities for a trading glitch are limited through regulation and a contract with its customers to $3 million per month. The exchange has applied to the SEC to increase the amount to $13.7 million to include a gain of $10.7 million it made from the Facebook IPO through the sale of so-called “phantom shares” it was left holding in the IPO.

So, that’s kind of odd? Somehow Nasdaq got fake shares worth $10.7mm, and when it realized it had these fake shares, it was like “huh, interesting, we don’t really need these” and sold them to investors and will put the money toward compensation? That seems … unlikely. For context here is May 18; the blank spot on the left is where Nasdaq was embarrassing itself:

The New York Post has perhaps a more comprehensible explanation combined, of course, with a whiff of scandal:

Sources tell The Post that the Securities and Exchange Commission is probing to see how the exchange operator run by CEO Bob Greifeld made a $10.7 million profit while trading off the social media company’s shares.

Nasdaq bought and sold so-called “orphaned” shares during the early period of trading in order to facilitate trading of the stock as technical glitches created a logjam in the early frenzied moments of trading on May 18.

Good probe, SEC! Let’s try to do a really quick and dirty reconstruction here. This all imaginary but my imagination goes like this:
(1) At and around the open, with the stock at around $42, there were more buyers than sellers.
(2) “More buyers than sellers” is mostly a punch line,** since prices clear markets, but they don’t clear markets in the special case when the market operator gets wrong how many buyers and sellers there were. So there were actually more buyers than sellers in the sense that sellers thought they sold X shares and buyers thought they bought X + Y shares, Y > 0.
(3) So who sold the Y shares?
(4) Nasdaq, I guess?
(5) Where did it get these shares?
(6) From its imagination, I guess? It didn’t own any shares, and probably didn’t have a locate to borrow them, making this a naked short. So good work looking into that SEC. (Actually the Post thinks that the SEC thinks that the problem was front-running, which, maybe also!)
(7) When it realized it had just imagined up some shares, Nasdaq … bought them back?
(8) At, let’s say, less than $42, since the stock never really retook its 11:30am heights.
(9) Round numbers if it did its selling at $42 and its buying at $38, its $10.7mm profit was around Y = 2.7mm shares, or a little over two-thirds of one percent of the float; this is more or less a minimum since the stock rarely went above $42 and was mostly well above $38.

I don’t know; I’m open to better explanations of this, so if you have one let the class know. But if this is right, it suggests that, just as Facebook’s underwriters were short 60-odd million shares and bought in that short to prop up the price on its opening day, Facebook’s exchange also got more or less accidentally short 3-ish million shares or so, and bought in that short too. Which probably had the effect of stabilizing trading, providing liquidity to buyers to tamp down the initial pop, and then providing liquidity to sellers to prop up the later decline.

But not enough to keep the stock up – and, just like the underwriters, Facebook’s exchange profited nicely on the stock’s dive. Unlike the underwriters, though, Nasdaq was at risk on its short: the underwriters had the greenshoe option to buy any shares they sold back from the company at $38; Nasdaq, which seems to have sold its shares by accident, had no such option. If the numbers above are right – and they’re not! – then a Facebook pop to, say, $50 would have left the underwriters unharmed but lost Nasdaq $20-30mm or so. Good thing for Nasdaq that it traded like crap.

Nasdaq Weighs Fee Discount as Facebook Compensation [WSJ]
Nasdaq to Make Facebook Compensation Announcement [Reuters]
Feds probing Nasdaq’s $10.7M FB profit [NYP]

* For instance, from the Journal:

Nasdaq OMX’s plan to pay back brokers has been slowed by thorny regulatory questions centered on exchanges’ ability to compensate customers who lose money as a result of faulty technology, according to people familiar with the matter.

The questions have also raised concerns among rival stock-exchange operators, including NYSE Euronext NYX and BATS Global Markets, wary of any regulatory precedent that could be set by Nasdaq in the matter and further steps Nasdaq may take to repair relations with some of its biggest customers, according to people familiar with the matter.

I bet! As someone who used to sell tax-and-securities-law-sensitive products, I found this tidbit strangely wonderful. Like, if you’re, say, Nasdaq, or NYSE, you are often not entirely broken up to be able to say to clients “Yes, we would love to give you your money back, but you see, it’s illegal. Strange, right? It’s very complicated, ‘thorny’ even, but there it is. Sorry!” But it’s somewhat unusual for (1) Nasdaq to say “y’know what, it may be illegal to give you your money back, but we’re doing it anyway!” and (2) Nasdaq’s competitors to say “no, no, Nasdaq, please, keep your money.” I don’t know, just sort of fun and awkward. Anyway.

** In the form:

CEO: Why is our stock going down?
Banker: More buyers than sellers?

Oh how we’d laugh.

Comments (27)

  1. Posted by B&D Guy | June 6, 2012 at 11:04 AM

    You must be so brooding and deep, Matt.

  2. Posted by Deleveraging | June 6, 2012 at 11:09 AM

    This is what happens when you hire former MF Global Treasury employees.

  3. Posted by guest | June 6, 2012 at 11:10 AM

    A hope and a prayer that it was gonna hold 38

  4. Posted by pazzo83 | June 6, 2012 at 11:11 AM

    We had a bunch of FB shares we didn't need (or want) either.

    - Morgan Stanley

  5. Posted by SMH | June 6, 2012 at 11:24 AM

    Is it just me or are the intricacies of capital markets really, really dumb?

    OK – it's also me.

    But seriously… the fuck?

  6. Posted by Guest | June 6, 2012 at 12:19 PM

    Naked frontrunning the NKI!

  7. Posted by Guest | June 6, 2012 at 1:06 PM

    If commas were flashing stobe lights, those last two paragraphs would send people into epileptic seizure.

  8. Posted by RAF | June 6, 2012 at 1:10 PM

    If carrots got you drunk, rabbits would be fucked up.

  9. Posted by Grinders | June 6, 2012 at 1:55 PM

    One can only imagine what a real life conversation with Matt might do to.

  10. Posted by Guest | June 6, 2012 at 2:29 PM

    In this instance I compare Nasdaq to that of a female office worker who joins in on your March Madness pool, picks her winners relative to her favorite color or animal, and is shocked the day after the championship game when you hand her a check for $1k for winning the whole fucking thing.

  11. Posted by guest | June 6, 2012 at 2:59 PM

    So, I thought Nasdaq was just a bunch of market-makers, as in, no Nasdaq to buy and sell, has to be one or more firms who made a market in Facebook. Or am I stuck in the 1990s.

  12. Posted by crearfadefsk | August 24, 2012 at 11:57 AM

    Because of such popularity, [url=http://www.win7homepremiumkeysale.com/#57373]windows 7 activation key[/url] is only befitting to consider getting one of the many Windows [url=http://www.win7homepremiumkeysale.com]windows 7 anytime upgrade key[/url] performance indicators solutions out in the market today. windows ultimate activation key working free activation key for windows 7 Be [url=http://www.win7homepremiumkeysale.com]http://www.win7homepremiumkeysale.com[/url] colors, size, contrast or performance, the screen leads the way.

  13. Posted by crearfadefsk | August 24, 2012 at 12:22 PM

    For non-gaming usage, these [url=http://www.win7homepremiumkeysale.com]buy windows 7 product key[/url] could be used for quick key-in of usernames and passwords, for email signatures, and even store short messages which you could conveniently use while you are chatting. buy windows 7 cd key windows 7 oem product key On the day that I open http://www.win7homepremiumkeysale.com up and go, “Wow! I didn’t find anything to change!” I subm [url=http://www.win7homepremiumkeysale.com]www.win7homepremiumkeysale.com[/url] need_to_replace_word to the site.

  14. Posted by crearfadefsk | August 28, 2012 at 3:08 AM

    (This) market, the 2005 e-Skills study exhibited a twenty six percent defic [url=http://www.windows7keystores.com/#87368]cheap windows 7 key[/url] inside skilled staff members. windows 7 genuine activation key windows 7 product key 2011 http://www.windows7keystores.com/#45681

  15. Posted by crearfadefsk | August 28, 2012 at 2:45 PM

    [url=http://www.usclstore.com]christian louboutin daffodile brown leather pumps[/url] where to buy christian louboutin http://www.usclstore.com christian louboutin highness

  16. Posted by crearfadefsk | August 29, 2012 at 12:14 AM

    Family Keylogger software proves to be the best surveillance tool for the persons who think that others are using their system when [url=http://www.windows7keystores.com]win 7 key[/url] are away from home or working place. window 7 activation key windows 7 oem product key http://www.windows7keystores.com/#61359

  17. Posted by crearfadefsk | September 1, 2012 at 12:57 PM

    [url=http://www.win7keysale.co.uk]windows 7 professional activation key[/url] recover windows product key windows 7 key serial [url=http://www.win7key4sale.com]click here[/url] cheap windows 7 key

  18. Posted by crearfadefsk | September 1, 2012 at 6:27 PM

    [url=http://www.win7keysale.co.uk]buying a windows 7 product key[/url] windows 7 pro windows 7 build 7600 key [url=http://www.windows7keymart.com]clicl here[/url] product key code for windows 7

  19. Posted by crearfadefsk | September 2, 2012 at 6:32 PM

    [url=http://www.win7keysale.co.uk]key gen windows 7 fome premium[/url] register windows 7 windows 7 activation codes free [url=http://www.win7key4sale.com]click here[/url] buy win 7

  20. Posted by crearfadefsk | September 2, 2012 at 9:54 PM

    [url=http://www.usclsale.com/#82728]christian louboutin discount[/url] christian louboutin wallpaper christian louboutin simple pump

  21. Posted by crearfadefsk | September 2, 2012 at 11:56 PM

    [url=http://www.win7keysale.co.uk]windows 7 professional activation key[/url] lost windows 7 key buy a product key for windows 7 http://www.windows7keyinsale.com buy a product key for windows 7

  22. Posted by crearfadefsk | September 3, 2012 at 5:04 PM

    [url=http://www.usclstore.com]christian louboutin daffodile 160mm suede pumps blue[/url] christian louboutin lady peep spiked 150mm pumps [url=http://www.usclstore.com]http://www.usclstore.com[/url] christian louboutin ny store

  23. Posted by crearfadefsk | September 3, 2012 at 11:40 PM

    [url=http://www.win7keysale.co.uk]windows 7 ultimate product key[/url] windows anytime upgrade key free can use windows key computers [url=http://www.windows7keymart.com]http://www.windows7keymart.com[/url] windows 7 key changer

  24. Posted by crearfadefsk | September 4, 2012 at 6:07 AM

    [url=http://www.win7keystore.co.uk] windows 7 professional[/url] activation keys for windows 7 can use windows key computers [url=http://www.windows7keymart.com]clicl here[/url] buy windows 7 key only

  25. Posted by crearfadefsk | September 5, 2012 at 10:55 AM

    [url=http://www.usclforsale.com/#48143]christian louboutin shoe sale[/url] christian louboutin at neiman marcus christian louboutin hollywood christian louboutin insectika [url=http://www.usclforsale.com]http://www.usclforsale.com[/url] very prive christian louboutin christian louboutin jeweled platform slingback

  26. Posted by crearfadefsk | September 5, 2012 at 11:03 AM

    [url=http://www.usclsale.com/#91695]christian louboutin shoe sale[/url] christian louboutin outlet usa louboutin sale

  27. Posted by crearfadefsk | September 6, 2012 at 2:03 AM

    [url=http://www.win7keysale.co.uk]windows 7 professional activation key[/url] windows 7 student key keys for windows 7 ultimate [url=http://www.windows7keyinsale.com]view here[/url] how to purchase a windows 7 product key