Banks, News

Morgan Stanley Heeding Frenemies’ Advice About Trading Less, Better

Here’s an interesting set of slides that Morgan Stanley CFO Ruth Porat presented at the Barclays conference today. For some reason this one struck me:

Morgan Stanley: basically a mutual fund! Half a mutual fund. Really barely at all an investment bank, which I guess is the way of the world for investment banks, but still sort of stark to see it there in black and white, er, navy and yellow. And Morgan Stanley will be shifting even more toward wealth/asset managing after today’s hotly negotiated purchase of Morgan Stanley Smith Barney.1 As Reuters puts it:

For Morgan Stanley, buying more of the brokerage is part of a strategy to become less reliant on the volatile securities trading business and the investment banking business, which has been in a long rut.

I’ll leave investment banking in that rut – and that 11% of revenues – but let’s talk about that volatile securities trading business a bit. Yesterday brought a GS research note suggesting that Morgan Stanley could shrink the amount of balance sheet it devotes to FICC trading while still making almost as much money in FICC trading, because certain physical laws have been suspended and it no longer takes money to make money, at least not in FICC. That seems to be Morgan Stanley’s idea as well, with slide 17 detailing a plan involving:

  • Reduce capital in assets that are not accretive to future revenue growth
  • Act as rapidly as possible while acknowledging market limitations and client relationships
  • Consider returns in each sub-business in context of adjacencies, size and scale

I like the first one – “stop putting all our money in things that lose us money” – and it seems to have paid off; the next slide is “Case Study: Securitized Products Balance Sheet and Revenues.” I will non-expertly hypothesize that this is a cherry-picked case study of a product area where more balance sheet in recent years has meant more negative revenues but anyway go ahead Morgan Stanley:

Imagine a counterfactual universe where regulators, creditors, shareholders, etc. didn’t care about balance sheet or capital: would Morgan Stanley have made the choice to reduce securitization balance sheet and increase revenues? I feel like that would be an interesting question to answer.2

One thing that looks increasingly unlikely in a post-Dodd-Frank-Volcker-what-have-you world is a return to the old-school standalone investment-banking-and-trading businesses; the legacy bank-n-trade firms are slimming down bits of their banking-n-trading but also bulking up complementary businesses like retail banking or asset management or whatever. (Ex Goldman, which makes like 80% of its money on banking and trading, but everyone will assume Goldman is hiding a giant hedge fund somewhere even if it actually isn’t.) You could ponder a variety of unsavory explanations for that; one goes in cynical outline:

  • “investment banks”3 can’t cover their cost of capital and so need to be subsidized by the cheap funding of deposits and/or captive audiences of retail brokerage, while
  • “investment banks” provide value to bankers who sit on retail deposits and/or brokerage accounts by allowing them to (1) gamble those deposits and/or (2) cross-sell terrible investment banking products to the retail investors.

Is that right? Meh, probably not. Still, as a rule of thumb, it might be a good idea not to celebrate Morgan Stanley’s shrinking reliance on risking its own balance sheet to create revenues, until you figure out whose balance sheet MS is now risking to create (bigger!) revenues.

Ruth Porat presentation, 2012 Barclays Global Financial Services Conference [Morgan Stanley]
Morgan Stanley, Citigroup settle brokerage dispute [Reuters]
Morgan Stanley’s MSSB 8-K and joint press release [EDGAR]

1. Uhhh so let’s talk about that purchase price? MS (current 51% owner) is buying 14% from Citi (current 49% owner) today, with forwards/options to buy the remaining 35% between now and 2015, at a price equivalent to a $13.5bn valuation for the whole thing – vs. MS’s $9-ish billion and Citi’s $23-ish billion valuations. Random thoughts:

  • Perella Weinberg was brought in as a valuation agent in terrorem but ended up not doing any actual valuating. Do you think they still got paid?
  • I submit to you that even the $13.5 billion stated price of MSSB rather overstates matters, since Morgan Stanley basically gets an interest-free loan to buy most of it between now and 2015 at the same valuation, whenever it can get around to raising the cash. (Actually it’s part loan and part call option; MS has to try to get in 15% more at the $13.5bn valuation, but can dawdle on the rest, and if it doesn’t buy it by June 2015 Citi can put it to MS but at the [presumably lower, if MS hasn’t bought!] then-fair market value, not at the $13.5bn, so maybe Perella Weinberg will earn its keep.)
  • But I guess that makes sense? Consider that (1) Citi 5-year CDS is ~183, MS is ~260 and (2) Citi price/book is 0.52, MS is 0.56. So it’s more expensive for Morgan Stanley to raise a dollar than for Citi to do so, but a dollar in Morgan Stanley’s hands is worth 4 cents more than a dollar in Citi’s hands. (Neither is worth a dollar!) Ergo, Citi using its balance sheet to give Morgan Stanley free funding for MSSB is a brilliant arbitrage. Except for Citi. I dunno, thoughts?

2. Another good one is how broadly applicable is this lesson of “just drastically slash balance sheet in a product area and you’ll make more money trading it”; both are left as exercises for the reader.

3. Stupid quotes just for, like “investment bank” = “thing that does investment banking and sales & trading and not so much asset management or commercial banking or what have you.” As opposed to “investment banking” a ways above, which was just “investment banking.”

(hidden for your protection)
Show all comments

79 Responses to “Morgan Stanley Heeding Frenemies’ Advice About Trading Less, Better”

  1. Philip Purcell says:

    IF MS is the new Merril then how am I not fucking vindicated ?

  2. Sandy Weil says:

    Hear Hear…. er wait

  3. Clueless says:

    They get half their net revenues from Gay White Males (GWM)??!!

    -Geico Caveman

  4. Jon Edward Corzine says:

    These guys should have greater exposure to european debt with some of the excess funding client business generates.

  5. they laid me off! says:

    They laid my off in 2008 from the equity trading desk in nyc.. it feels so good to see those clowns relegated to looking like a mutual fund. this reality is more painful that losing a job to half the michael milken wannabees work there.

  6. E. Cartman says:

    Try to interview Steve D'Antonio about his Securitized Products model. It's actually pretty (deviously) brilliant.

  7. guest says:

    if ever there was a signal to keep your money far away from a full service brokerage account, this is it.

    "we haven't been doing so well with disastrously conceived structured products, mismanaged IPOs, bad merger advice and money losing prop trades, so we're [MS/UBS/ML] going to see what magic we can work with your life savings."

  8. Guest says:

    Pretty sure MS still has to pay citi 35% of the profits, that counts for something right?

  9. Guest says:

    Great, more MS PWM's out on the road. Stay off your bikes.

  10. DDK says:

    By the way, does anyone know why GS didn't attend the event?

  11. Real fantastic info are available on website. Time finds truth. by Lucius Annaeus Seneca.

  12. My wife and i ended up being now comfortable Louis could do his homework through the precious recommendations he grabbed out of your web site. It is now and again perplexing to simply find yourself making a gift of strategies that some other people have been making money from. And we do understand we’ve got you to appreciate for that. The explanations you made, the easy web site menu, the relationships you will make it easier to create – it’s got most remarkable, and it’s really making our son in addition to the family consider that this topic is entertaining, which is wonderfully important. Thank you for all the pieces!

  13. Wow, great weblog layout! How lengthy have you ever been running a blog for? you make running a weblog glance easy. The total appear of your internet site is magnificent, effectively the content material!

  14. Its great as your other content : D, thankyou for putting up.

  15. Max Goldberg says:

    See what I found !! Gold Price Chart – Live gold spot prices

  16. superb post.Never knew this, appreciate it for letting me know.

  17. Aw, this was an exceptionally good post. Spending some time and actual effort to
    generate a good article… but what can I say… I hesitate a lot and never
    seem to get nearly anything done.

  18. Some truly fantastic blog posts on this web site, appreciate it for contribution.

  19. The good intreguing articles keep me coming back here time and time once more. thank you so considerably.

  20. Hello there, I discovered your web site via Google while looking for a related matter, your site came up, it appears great. I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.

  21. Tanner says:

    I truly liked your site article. Truly looking forward to read more. Will keep reading.

  22. I went over this site and I think you have a lot of excellent info , saved to bookmarks (:.

  23. We are a gaggle of volunteers and opening a brand new scheme in our community. Your website offered us with useful information to paintings on. You have done a formidable job and our entire community will probably be grateful to you.

  24. diesel jeans says:

    Best diesel jeans sale online in discount price and free shipping! Buy any diesel jeans will get best service from us.Welcome to our store!

  25. I got what you intend, saved to my bookmarks , extremely decent web site .

  26. Established in Columbia, South Carolina in 1993 Burriss & Ridgeway Injury Lawyers have gained a reputation throughout South Carolina as a law firm that cares about its clients

  27. I am glad to be a visitant of this sodding site! , thanks for this rare info ! .

  28. Feather Fret says:

    Nice site. I’m jealous. Save the ferrets!!

  29. Ty Mossien says:

    Some really nice stuff on this site, I enjoy it.

  30. I am impressed with this site, really I am a fan.

  31. I am typically to running a weblog and i really recognize your content. The article has really peaks my interest. I’m going to bookmark your web site and maintain checking for new details.

  32. you use a fantastic blog here! do you wish to have the invite posts in my small blog?

  33. eliko carpet says:

    fantastic points altogether, you simply won a new reader. What would you recommend about your submit that you simply made a few days ago? Any certain?

  34. Great ¡V I need to certainly pronounce, impressed together with your website. I had no trouble navigating by way of all tabs as effectively as related info ended up being truly straightforward to do to access. I lately found what I hoped for before you know it at all. Quite unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those that add forums or anything, internet site theme . a tones way for your client to communicate. Outstanding task..

  35. You have mentioned very interesting points! ps nice internet site.

  36. Bakarat says:

    Sweet internet site, super design, real clean and utilize friendly.

  37. Hi there, You have performed an incredible job. I’ll surely digg it and for my part suggest to my friends. I’m positive they will likely be benefited from this website.

  38. Travel Station Staff vs. Food Nation Badge | Foursquare Atlanta I was suggested this web position by my cousin. I am not definite whether this post is written by him as rebuff one to boot identify such in depth on the subject of my difficulty. You are incredible! Thanks! your article about Travel Waterway Be in charge of vs. Foodstuff Nation Badge | Foursquare AtlantaBest Regards Craig

  39. After I initially commented I clicked the -Notify me when new feedback are added- checkbox and now each time a remark is added I get four emails with exactly the same comment. Is there any method you’ll be able to take away me from that service? Thanks!

  40. X Art says:

    Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I truly feel strongly about it and enjoy learning extra on this subject. If attainable, as you accomplish experience, would you thoughts updating your blog with additional data? It really is very beneficial for me.

  41. UGG Botas says:

    My brother recommended I may like this internet internet site. He was entirely proper. This publish truly created my day. You’ll be able to not consider just how so considerably time I had spent for this information! Thank you!

  42. duftlys says:

    Quickly and easily build your internet traffic and PR, which provides Web internet site visitors to add your page to any social bookmarking web site.

  43. Anonymous says:

    Apple now has Rhapsody as an app, which is a great start, but it is currently hampered by the inability to store locally on your iPod, and has a dismal 64kbps bit rate. If this changes, then it will somewhat negate this advantage for the Zune, but the 10 songs per month will still be a big plus in Zune Pass’ favor.

  44. hello!,I really like your writing extremely a lot! percentage we maintain up a correspondence extra about your post on AOL? I want an expert on this area to unravel my dilemma. Could be that is you! Taking a look forward to peer you.

  45. Some truly wonderful info , Gladiola I detected this.

  46. It is truly a great and helpful piece of information. I am glad that you just shared this helpful info with us. Please stay us informed like this. Thanks for sharing.

  47. buy wine says:

    So selfish. I can’t stand when posters make such rude remarks.

  48. Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your website and in accession capital to assert that I acquire in fact enjoyed account your blog posts. Anyway I’ll be subscribing to your augment and even I achievement you access consistently rapidly.

  49. Hollister says:

    Thankx so a lot for this! I havent been this thrilled by a post for a long period of time! Youve got it, whatever that indicates in blogging. Anyway, You are surely someone that has something to say that men and women require to hear. Maintain up the excellent job. Maintain on inspiring the individuals!

  50. Attractive section of content. I just stumbled upon your website and in accession capital to assert that I acquire in fact enjoyed account your blog posts. Anyway I’ll be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently fast.

  51. Excellent post at 302 Found. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Very helpful info particularly the last part :) I care for such info a lot. I was seeking this certain info for a very long time. Thank you and good luck.

  52. Cecile Shoat says:

    Simply wanna comment on few general things, The website style and design is perfect, the subject material is very excellent : D.

  53. Very interesting info !Perfect just what I was searching for!

  54. Tad Mathies says:

    I like this web blog very much, Its a rattling nice berth to read and incur info . “Young men think old men are fools but old men know young men are fools.” by George Chapman.

  55. exceltdeefs says:


  56. But along with its recognition arrived this rumors pertaining to their unwanted effects. The concept is that if one thing is that often beneficial, after that there must be anything inside the ingredient that will bring the opposite impulse. This may be one of the thoughts that the not-so-convinced customers intend.

  57. Wow, marvelous blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your web site is fantastic, as well as the content!. Thanks For Your article about 302 Found .

  58. Gomezzjr says:

    ugg coats

  59. sohbet says:

    Chair, I will bail out strippers. The rest of the argument becomes irrelevant because the world will be a kinder happier place with more strippers. And, hence, the U.S. shall maintain world leadership in porn by preserving the efficiencies of a an