HP Thinks That Autonomy Extracted A Bit Too Much Meaning From Its Enterprise Data

I don’t know much about this Autonomy thing – in brief, Hewlett-Packard acquired British software company Autonomy last year for $10.3 billion and today wrote that investment down by $8.8 billion, blaming $5 billion of that on “accounting improprieties, misrepresentations and disclosure failures” at Autonomy – but this sure sounds fake doesn’t it?

Today, Autonomy is firmly established as the leading provider of Pan-Enterprise Search and Meaning Based Computing (MBC) solutions. Autonomy’s unique Intelligent Data Operating Layer (IDOL) platform enables organisations to harness the full richness of human information by extracting meaning from the mass of unstructured information they handle every day, which analysts estimate to constitute over 80% of all enterprise data.

That’s from Autonomy’s last annual report as an autonomous company1 before HP bought it. Retrospective red flag perhaps? I would be wary of companies whose business involves “extracting meaning.” Meaning doesn’t come from software.2

Now of course HP is going to sue everyone and demand fraud investigations on two continents. Many people look bad here – HP first of all, whether or not its claims are true, then (if they’re true) Autonomy, Deloitte (Autonomy’s auditors), E&Y (HP’s auditors), HP’s bevy of bankers and others involved in due diligence who seem to have been unduly undiligent, and to some extent Autonomy’s bankers who marketed it to HP.3 I have plenty of sympathies with both sets of bankers, of course; their job is mainly to harness the full richness of human information by extracting meaning from the mass of stuff that companies make public, not to know whether that stuff is true.4 Bankers are an intelligent data operating layer; if you give them bad data then their operating layer is less intelligent. It’s possible that some of those words mean things.

That excuse sounds sort of lame – lots of people thought Autonomy was doing shady stuff! – but here we are. The bankers aren’t supposed to be able to spot well-concealed accounting problems; if they could, they’d be doing so. Like Jim Chanos noticed accounting imperfections at Autonomy but then he’s paid to do so. More than the bankers are I mean.

Let’s just assume, because it’s more fun than the alternative, that Autonomy was in fact a massive accounting fraud.5 The way that normally happens is, you’re an okay business, but you miss a few targets here and there and you don’t want to lose investor confidence so you fudge the numbers just a bit, booking revenue too early and so forth, planning to pay yourself back later, but then of course when you miss the next target things are even worse because you owe yourself for the prior quarter, and things snowball, and one day you wake up and your reality is $5 billion behind your accounting and it seems unlikely you’ll ever dig yourself out.

What do you do? Autonomy’s answer seems to have been “shop the hell out of yourself” – to HP, certainly, and maybe also to Oracle6 – so as to be acquired. In some ways, this is obvious: getting bought out for cash gets you, y’know, cash, at a significant premium in Autonomy’s case, which allows you to monetize your fraud and take off for non-extradition countries if that’s your thing. (Note that it wasn’t particularly at Autonomy; its CEO took his $800 million on the deal but stayed around to run the place until HP fired him.)

But it’s not entirely obvious. Being a public company subjects you to a certain amount of scrutiny, from auditors and investors and whatnot, but Autonomy seems to have managed fooling its auditors just fine. And putting yourself on the block exposes you to due diligence: a prospective buyer doesn’t need to be satisfied with public information, but can kick the tires more thoroughly, demanding nonpublic information and doing its own review of your accounts. There’s a chance they’ll discover any fraud. And if people are worrying about your aggressive accounting anyway, and a potential acquirer publicly walks away from a deal (as Oracle kind of did!), that’s not going to help your quest to avoid detection.

But Autonomy did it anyway. Maybe because there’s no fraud and HP is mistaken? Meh. Or maybe because it figured the consequences of being caught, as an HP subsidiary, would be less bad than the consequences of being caught as a public-company fraud? After all, no Autonomy shareholders were directly harmed by management’s fraud: they all got bought out at a premium! (HP’s shareholders, on the other hand, are losing out, but they have a bevy of other failures to shield them from the consequences of the Autonomy failure. Who knows what part of Autonomy’s performance decline, post-acquisition, was due to HP’s management and what part was due to the fact that pre-acquisition performance was fictional?) And when HP goes and sues everyone at Autonomy for fraud, Autonomy can – semi-reasonably! – say “well, HP had every opportunity to do due diligence, why were they relying on what we told them?” Public shareholders just seem more sympathetic, more able to prove reasonable reliance on Autonomy’s accounts, more clearly damaged by that reliance, and more likely to interest the sorts of people who put executives in jail, than HP does. HP garners much less sympathy.

Also, of course, shopping yourself is only dangerous if due diligence is likely to actually discover fraud. That didn’t happen and I guess there’s no reason why it would – again, the M&A process is about extracting meaning from information, not checking its accuracy. Perhaps Autonomy decided that being a public company exposed them to motivated short sellers who would figure out their accounting problems much faster than HP and its bankers and auditors would.

HP says discovered accounting “failures” at Autonomy unit [Reuters]
HP Issues Statement Regarding Autonomy Impairment Charge [HP]

1. Ugh, I know, sorry.

2. That’s why I didn’t buy the Facebook IPO.

3. I guess I look bad too; I did my own forensic accounting last year to guess that Autonomy’s version of its silly spat with Oracle sounded more plausible than Oracle’s. I have updated my priors.

4. The internet today is full of people defending their professions. I think if you asked the average

  • person, they’d say “why didn’t the bankers and lawyers doing due diligence catch this?”;
  • banker or lawyer they’d say “we rely on audited financials – why didn’t the auditors catch this?”;
  • auditor they’d say “we just audit the work of internal accountants – why did they lie to us?”

This is a problem of the M&A professions. M&A bankers have skills, but they are not the sort of skills that can tell you whether you should buy a company or how much you should pay for it. They just look like they are.

Also! Remember this story, where the shareholders of Dragon, the speech-recognition software, are suing Goldman because Goldman let them sell themselves to a massive fraud in an all-stock deal without catching that problem in diligence, and it turned out that the Goldman deal team was led by some VP who was perpetually on vacation? I bet he feels better, anyway.

5. Let’s also assume that it came from the top; HP’s press release blames “some former members of Autonomy’s management team [who] used accounting improprieties, misrepresentations and disclosure failures to inflate the underlying financial metrics of the company” but it’s not clear if that means the CEO or others who had a say in shopping the company. Maybe it was some sales manager whose fake reports were just reported up the chain in good faith.

6. See footnote 3, supra.

(hidden for your protection)
Show all comments

113 Responses to “HP Thinks That Autonomy Extracted A Bit Too Much Meaning From Its Enterprise Data”

  1. ST*R says:

    Skynet > Autonomy

  2. Inigo says:

    You keep using that word. I don't think it means what you think it means.

  3. connect says:

    Mattel? The Learning Company? Bain Capital?

    HP–Autonomy–Meg Whitman

    Who was rumored to be a cabinet member in a Romney administration?

    All Big 4 accounting firms involved at some point. It is not only the SEC who has trouble spotting fraud. But then again, that would require some creative thinking and the Big 4 doesn't encourage creative thinking–blandness is the required trait.

  4. F9_Calculate says:

    HP, E&Y, Deloitte and Autonomy,

    lol. Glad that I '"am not you'".

    -Oracle Abstract Meaning Department

  5. Lynch Mike says:

    I'm sure they can use Bayesian theory to explain *everything*.

  6. asdf1234 says:

    >> Bankers are an intelligent data operating layer; if you give them bad data then their operating layer is less intelligent.

    You mean if its not in the annual report its detail too hard to find?

  7. RBS M&A says:

    Chin up guys, it's overrated anyway, we did due diligence-lite and ABN still fucked us.

    – F. Goodwin

  8. Quant me maybe says:

    HP has a long history doing bad acquisitions. Why would this one be any different? It's just bigger than most of the turds they purchased in the past.

  9. Guest says:

    I'll be on holidays unti further notice.

    -F. Quattrone

  10. Edmund says:

    Autonomy Board Meeting:

    CEO: How can "extracting meaning" really be worth anything? How are we going to monetize this?

    Technical Director: Well our latest Bayesian statistical analysis of HP indicates there's a 73.4% chance they're dumb enough to pay $10 billion for us.

    CEO: I'll be on my yacht if anyone needs me.

  11. Oliver says:

    Oh honestly, i don't know anything about it on the first place and this would be a great meaning of it too. Thanks much for what you've done.. it's really awesome and one of the best.
    dress up kitchen cabinets

  12. pmp pdus says:

    well i get the headlines for today but i dont have any idea about the autonomy thing in brief.

  13. This is a wonderful article, Given so much info in it, These type of articles keeps the users interest in the website, and keep on sharing more.

  14. Very good article. I'm experiencing some of these issues as well…

  15. hank you posting relative information and its now becoming easier to complete this assignment.

  16. well i get the headlines for today but i dont have any idea about the autonomy thing in brief.

  17. When some one searches for his required thing, so he/she wants to be available that in detail, thus that thing is maintained over here…

  18. hunger games says:

    This is a wonderful article, give me so much useful information. Katniss Everdeen jacket

  19. strobin111 says:

    Possibly Autonomy made the decision that will being a open public organization shown the crooks to inspired short sellers would you figure out their accounting problems faster than HP as well as bankers and auditors would. rats pest control east london

  20. I really like this, your this post completely change my perspective. I was searching the topic for my article which is relevant to your post.. Thanks for sharing this with us..

  21. Very good information and article. Keep up the good work.

  22. I really love the content you have here, it's very educational and useful. I'll definitely come back frequently to learn more.

  23. Dyson DC41 says:

    Hey you got some nice content here. Thanks for showing these great tips!!!

  24. I really liked your content. Thank you

  25. Mold Removal says:

    Thanks – glad I found this as I have been looking for similar info for quite a while. i have bookmarked it for future use.

  26. I really love your content! Thanks

  27. Very useful article. Thank you.

  28. This is some awesome content. Thanks for the share!

  29. Nice Post, it was a good read, thanks!

  30. Großartig sehr interessant.

  31. ACN Scam says:

    Very helpful post. Thank you very much for this.

  32. I really love your content. Thank you :-)

  33. Love you blog, Thanks for the great information

  34. This stuff sure gives me food for thought.

  35. Very good and informative reading. I like this kind of input. I will be back for more later.

  36. This is a wonderful article. thanks for posting it!

  37. excellent and informative

  38. Good stuff here. I appreciate it.

  39. Awesome site! Thanks for sharing the great content![youtube A_fwtmqVc-I youtube]

  40. Great content – Thanks so much!

  41. Awesome site! Thanks for sharing the great content![youtube eU3crFw3fpY youtube]

  42. nail fungus says:

    Thanks for the post – read, enjoyed and bookmarked. Will also be passing it alongto some friends.

  43. Thanks for the information. It was very helpful.

  44. Rollovabeats says:

    Nice Content

    Do you need original music for your next project,
    show, youtube video, website, CD, or any other media
    projects? then visit where we have a
    selection of Hip hop, R&B ,Pop, Trap, and other genres
    for your next commercial project.
    Sign up and receive a FREE Beat Instantly!

  45. Seagull S6 says:

    I really love your content. It's easy to understand and great to share. Thank You!

  46. Nice site and good content. Glad to be here. Think of sharing Your content. Thank You

  47. Eat Well With A Paleo Diet Meal

  48. Great site. Very useful information. Keep up the good work!

  49. carlos says:

    Interesting points but I will have to take a liitle time to assimilate and get back to you.

  50. Hi, I love read your content. Congratulations!

  51. Hi, Great Content, Great Ideas. I Love your Content. Congratulations!

  52. Aaron says:

    Skin tags are usually harmless, but they can be annoying and sometimes are a source of embarrassment. Learn what is a skin tag and how to remove a skin tag safely and effectively.

  53. I really like your content. Thank you.

  54. Alan beswick says:

    I also think they did.

  55. Great Information, Thanks for sharing with us!

  56. Great article, made me think about certain things again. Thanks for the input, serious issue your adressing here! Let them go im thinking.. Check them

  57. Hey great content my friend… I just love your writing style

  58. I really love your content.. Thank you!

  59. Sounds like skulldugery to me. Thank you for sharing.

  60. Great Keep up the good work

  61. Thank you for providing such great content.

  62. Hiya, I'm really glad I have found this information. Nowadays bloggers publish just about gossip and net stuff and this is really annoying. A good web site with exciting content, that is what I need. Thank you for making this site, and I'll be visiting again

  63. Great content. Thanks for the information

  64. Great content! I can tell you did your research.

  65. I love your content, thank you

  66. If you looking for a Fargo Realtor or a Fargo Real Estate agent. You might want to check out this video because it will save you time and money instead of finding a Fargo Realtor.

  67. Wake Up Now says:

    Wake Up Now this is good information from a good site. I hope to be able to have a site like this one day

  68. Interesting and informative blog, thanks for sharing!

  69. Great content! Thanks for sharing!

  70. Everytime great content.Congratulation.

  71. It is true but there is still a big problems with it.

  72. I look up to more of your superb articles. Thanks a lot

  73. Writing ideas and thinking is good for readers.Readers attract towatds the blog.

  74. This is a great inspiring post.I am pretty much happy with your nice Work.You put really very special information ..

  75. I just read this post. and feel good to read valuable information abut all aspects .

  76. It cool and nice idea on this nice blog. i want to appriciate your writing effort.

  77. Chrissie Mac says:

    Great content. Thanks, will be back.

  78. thyromine says:

    The information is great I enjoyed this article alot.

  79. Hey, you used to write nice topic, but the last few articles have been kinda bull shit… ohh.

  80. Your effort for good writing is nice. I appricate your writing style.

  81. I found some awsom things ont his post. its helpfull for me in some of my research areas.

  82. I think i have right to share honest comment. honestly writer have not the art of writing.

  83. I found some awsom things ont his post. its helpfull for me in some of my research areas.

  84. Hey, you used to write nice topic, but the last few articles have been kinda bull shit… ohh.

  85. For a writer most important thing is to attract the readers and writer has clear ability to write good article.

  86. I was enjoying reading your well written post. It looks like you do a lot of effort and time on your blog.

  87. No dout the topic is not unique but the collection of word is nice.

  88. In this area of topic writer covered all aspects that is nice and good in article writng.

  89. Thats nice to see this topic on my PC. its good idea and different idea for writing.

  90. I found some awsom things ont his post. its helpfull for me in some of my research areas.

  91. Many of them are rife with spelling problems and I to find it very bothersome to inform the reality however I'll surely come again again.

  92. produced me in my view believe it from so many various angles.

  93. Many of them are rife with spelling problems and I to find it very bothersome to inform the reality however I'll surely come again again.

  94. Many of them are rife with spelling problems and I to find it very bothersome to inform the reality however I'll surely come again again.

  95. I'd like to peer more posts like this.

  96. IE still is the market chief and a big portion of other folks will miss your wonderful writing due to this problem.

  97. Hi my loved one! I want to say that this post is amazing, nice written and come with almost all important infos.

  98. I've read a few good stuff here. Certainly price bookmarking for revisiting.

  99. Your writing taste has been amazed me. Thank you, very nice post.

  100. excellent publish, very informative. I ponder why the other experts of this sector don't realize this.

  101. You're so intelligent. You recognize thus significantly when it comes to this subject,

  102. Chrissie says:

    Great Content, will be back. Thanks.

  103. Hey I really enjoyed reading your article. how do I find more information on this subject?

  104. Ryan says:

    Well thought through.

  105. Such a great software it could be much helpful for some big business works.

  106. omega 3 says:

    WHY ORDER OUR OMEGA 3 FISH OIL SOFTGELS: 100 softgels of our best Omega-3 Fish Oil Pills balanced formula are clinically proven to support your heart, joint, skin and cognitive health!

  107. Daniel says:

    This shows that accountancy is an art!