KPMG Partner Assured Coconspirator Who Handed Him Bags Of Cash In Parking Lots That Insider Trading Wasn’t Really Illegal

I don’t want to give you legal advice, but on the other hand you could be getting it from a worse source. Scott London for instance:

[Insider trader Bryan] Shaw said that in approximately July 2012, he received a notice from Fidelity Brokerage Services that Fidelity was putting a hold on his investment account. Shaw said that he immediately called LONDON and expressed his concern that their insider trading had been discovered. Shaw said that LONDON reassured him that there was no reason for concern, and explained that insider trading was like counting cards at a casino in Las Vegas – if you were caught, they simply ask you to leave because they cannot prove it.

Oops! Six months later the FBI got to Shaw, inducing him to cooperate to save himself, and today they charged London with criminal insider trading.1 It’s tempting to conclude that the moral of this story is “never take legal advice from an accountant,” though realistically it’s more like “never take legal advice from your criminal co-conspirator.”

This case is very weird. I mean the actual case is pretty boring: London, as a KPMG audit partner on a bunch of West Coast accounts, got earnings information before it became public, and then he gave it to Shaw, and then Shaw bought stock and options and made money on it and then literally delivered literal bags filled with literal cash to London to thank him for the tips. After Shaw started cooperating he met with London, wearing a wire, and this happened:

In advance of the meeting, agents from the FBI provided Shaw with $5,000 in cash, which was placed into a manila envelope and then wrapped inside a black paper bag, which was consistent with how Shaw had described his concealing previous cash payments he had made to LONDON.

Oh you put the cash in an envelope inside a bag? They’ll never catch you!

I’ve never understood the psychology of insider trading: Shaw supposedly made about $1.2 million, and paid London $50,000 of it, which I can’t imagine being worth going to jail for. But reading this complaint you get the sense that they got psychic satisfaction out of the drama of it: “ooh, look at us, we’re big-shot insider traders! With our black paper2 bags!” London’s inside information was not exactly full of drama and insight:

Shaw asked LONDON whether he should buy [HLF], and LONDON said that typically the stock price would go up based on the earnings that were going to be released, but that the stock was very volatile so it was hard to know. LONDON again confirmed that the guidance was going to be raised, but said that he would “find out exactly.” …

LONDON and Shaw discussed how the stock price for Herbalife had jumped recently when Carl Icahn bought a large block of its stock. Shaw told LONDON, “I wish you would’ve known that he was going to release that and we could’ve made some money.” LONDON responded, “Yeah, that would’ve been nice.”

LONDON then referenced rumors that had been spread recently about Herbalife going private, which had been discussed in various news reports. LONDON stated, “That is where you make a ton of money … because, you know, we’ll know that.” LONDON then advised that if that were to take place, “What we oughta do is, when I know that it’s gonna start happening, what you do is you start just buying in small blocks, right, so it doesn’t draw attention and then, you know, then it doesn’t look unusual at all.”

Basically they got together and fantasized about finding a merger to insider trade on. As opposed to their insider trading on Deckers:

Shaw asked LONDON, regarding Deckers stock, if “it could go up a little bit?” LONDON responded, “It could go up a little bit.” LONDON said he was not sure how the stock would respond. Shaw then asked LONDON if he agreed they should “buy a little, if it goes up, then we made a little money.” LONDON responded, “Yeah … I think that’s fine.”

Zzzz. Incidentally: Deckers, huh? Deckers is a public company and a KPMG audit client. Shaw and London insider traded in five stocks, all KPMG audit clients. Two are no longer public – to be fair, they were both bought out and Shaw insider traded before each merger, so, yeah, good work big shots – and two are Herbalife and Skechers, which are now-former KPMG audit clients. That leaves Deckers. Why is KPMG still okay auditing them?

The answer appears to be that while London was the audit partner for Skechers and Herbalife, meaning that he signed their audit opinions with the full faith and credit of KPMG, he was only the “account executive” for Deckers, which means that he basically took Deckers executives out for drinks and was all “hey, so, accounting, huh?” Auditors need to be “independent in fact and appearance” of their audit clients; apparently having a current or former audit partner insider trading in your clients ruins that fact and/or appearance, while having a current or former “account executive” doing so doesn’t. I dunno. If you were Deckers would you be pissed? Would you fire KPMG? If you were Herbalife would you be pissed? Would you demand that KPMG come back? The decision about when KPMG has to resign – and leave Skechers and Herbalife without audited financials and in theoretical danger of delisting – and when it can just get by with an apology, seems pretty metaphysical.

Still the weirdest thing about the case might be that both Shaw and London have released teary public statements confessing to everything and saying how sorry they are. These are people with lawyers. Paid lawyers! Shaw has been cooperating with the FBI since February so I guess he’s got some upside in cooperating to the press, but what is London’s angle? Here’s his lawyer’s take:

“But he just can’t understand why he did it, and it’s hard to understand why he did it,” Mr. Braun said. “It makes no sense. He’s looking back on the years that he did it. It made no sense from a dollar-and-cents point of view; it made no sense in terms of his ethics. He’s not trying to justify it in the slightest.” …

“It’s pretty grim,” the lawyer told CNBC. “His life is ruined. He’s 50 years old, he’s lost his career, he’ll probably lose his license, he’s been disgraced, and he may have to do some jail time.3 That’s the best-case scenario. It’s a very grim reminder of the consequences for anyone who wants to leak any insider information.”

Well it’s a useful reminder, too. Some people seem to have been underestimating those consequences.

U.S. v. Scott London – criminal complaint [C.D. Cal.]
SEC Charges Former KPMG Partner and Friend with Insider Trading [SEC]
SEC v. Scott London & Bryan Shaw – civil complaint [SEC]

1. And the SEC brought civil insider trading charges against both of them. Shaw seems not to have been charged criminally, because he was cooperating I guess, but he still might be.

2. Are “black paper bags” really a thing?

3. Umm some? As Peter Henning points out, London is on the hook for all of Shaw’s $1.2mm in profits, even though he himself only got about $50k, even though he didn’t know how much Shaw was trading, and even though Shaw himself hasn’t yet been charged. I eyeball that at a little under 2 years.

(hidden for your protection)
Show all comments

12 Responses to “KPMG Partner Assured Coconspirator Who Handed Him Bags Of Cash In Parking Lots That Insider Trading Wasn’t Really Illegal”

  1. guest says:

    "London then proceeded to advise Shaw that masturbating on an airplane was not illegal; merely frowned upon."

  2. Feels a little lite says:

    I like too put things down in the toe of the shoe to conceal them.

  3. Fabulous Fab says:

    Sure you know why this happened. London wanted to be the "big playah". Here's a Cal State Northridge accountant, all of a sudden he's PRACTICALLY a Wall Street guy. Well, nearly practically. Well, closer than the guy making fries at Pink's.

    But who makes him feel like a hot shot Wall Street type? Yes, his friend Bryan the jeweler. Bryan thinks Scott is the next best thing to Lloyd. AND he's got cash. I mean, Scott can't do it directly – he could get fired! But if someone else does the trading, no biggie. Taking a small % is nothing compared to the guy who puts the buy orders in. And a jeweler – free Rolexes for life, amirite?

    But Scott forgets. Cal State Northridge not known for higher logical processing. His jeweler friend could rat him out to save his own neck. And does.

    So – $50K and a watch you won't see again until they hand you that manila envelope with your belongings at the end of your sentence. Enjoy!

  4. guest says:

    "Thanks for the moo-la"

  5. Guest says:

    Black paper bag = department store bag

    Perhaps a Samsonite briefcase could have been a more obvious red flag as far as objects to hand to another man are concerned, but that's about the only thing.

  6. Guest says:

    Did you consider "probably lose his license" as a tag?

  7. Fewdollarsmore says:

    Who hurt me most, I met as a friend!
    I expected the trust – a thing he didn't comprehend.
    I was betting on him, and he on a trend.
    His returns were my risks, his means – my end.
    For one to act, for other to recommend.
    It was illegal, but not so hard to defend.
    No money, no fame, no thrill did it lend.
    Only gain I wanted, was a gain of a friend!

  8. Posted 1300 days ago

    Tags: Fortis Healthcare Ltd, HCL Infosystems Fortis Healthcare Ltd Hospital Information Systems Enterprise Resource Planning

    HCL Infosystems will manage and oversee the IT processes of Fortis Healthcare Ltd for five years under an IT outsourcing deal forged between the two firms.
    Under the deal all the hospitals of Fortis will be standardised through the IT systems of HCL and this activity will be completed within 12 months.

    HCL will deploy Hospital Information Systems (HIS) and Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) solutions to standardise operations across Fortis hospitals. Solutions enabling automation of financial processes and business intelligence and analytics solutions will also be offered to the Healthcare major.

    Fortis will also be able to have an online sharing of patient records and data.

    Shivinder Mohan Singh, Managing Director, Fortis Healthcare said,’This tie up will create newer benchmarks in the quality of healthcare delivery and patient care and take it to the next level. IT forms the back bone for hospital operations and improved patient care.The system integration with high end IT infrastructure would result in enhanced performance and superior patient care. I am delighted that with this initiative we will not only have an integrated IT platform meeting the needs of our company today but also have a robust IT infrastructure capable of servicing the future needs of a large network of hospitals across national boundaries and geographies.’

    Mr. Ajai Chowdhry, Chairman and CEO, HCL Infosystems Ltd. said, ‘We are happy to be a part this ground breaking initiative of introducing total outsourcing of IT Application and Infrastructure Management for the Healthcare industry in India. This deal with Fortis Healthcare is a strategic and an effective move that will not only set new benchmarks for the Indian healthcare industry but also have a positive rub-off on the Fortis Healthcare objectives to provide quality treatment to its patients.’

    Related Posts:

    Fortis Healthcare buys its international unit
    Fortis to buy Hong Kong’s quality healthcare…
    Fortis Healthcare Plans to Open SGD 70 million Cancer…
    Fortis to Come Up with eICUs
    Fortis Healthcare signs agreement with Burundi

    You might also like
    Innovations Spurring in Indian Health IT
    Innovations Spurring in Indian Health IT
    Indian Healthcare Sector on Growth Track
    Indian Healthcare Sector on Growth Track
    WIPRO wins $ 200 mn contract from US healthcare chain
    WIPRO wins $ 200 mn contract from US healthcare chain
    EHR to pave the way
    EHR to pave the way
    LivLife Hospital to Raise Rs 50 Crore for Expansion
    LivLife Hospital to Raise Rs 50 Crore for Expansion
    Innovations Spurring in Indian Health IT
    Indian Healthcare Sector on Growth Track
    WIPRO wins $ 200 mn contract from US healthcare chain
    EHR to pave the way
    LivLife Hospital to Raise Rs 50 Crore for Expansion
    Recommended by

    Readers who viewed this page, also viewed:

    Wipro GE Healthcare to integrate GE Healthcare units in India and South Asia

    Get Updates

    Subscribe to our e-mail newsletter to receive updates.
    Share This Post
    Related Articles

    News:Money Matters
    Fortis Healthcare plans to raise Fresh Fund
    Fortis Healthcare organizes 2nd Annual Fortis Quality Conclave 2010
    “Today, corporate hospitals also recognise the utility of research” : Dr. Upendra Kaul, Fortis Escorts Heart Institute & Research Centre

    Upcoming Events

    Most Read

    Healthcare Leaders’ Forum,March 14, 2012, Assocham, New Delhi
    Nurse Strike Has Come to an End
    MEDICALL 2012 Chennai Witnessed an Overwhelmed Response
    Importance of CDSS in Clinical Practice : Dr. Vijayabhaskar Reddy Kandula Physician, St Mark’s Hospi…