Well this isn’t great:
The story behind that – more fully described here – is that Chesapeake issued $1.3 billion of seven-year bonds in February 2012, and those bonds were freely callable from November 2012 to March 2013, and thereafter not callable (except with a T+50 makewhole) until maturity. And in March Chesapeake tried to call them, and their trustee – BoNY Mellon – said, well, no, you needed to give notice of a call a month in advance, everyone knows that, so you’re outta luck and can’t call them except at the makewhole price (~129). And Chesapeake disagreed and so they sued. The dispute turned on some ambiguous language – some places the bond documents said you need to provide notice a month before you call, other places they say that the early call works as long as you provide notice before March 2013 – but I wasn’t particularly sympathetic to Chesapeake, based mostly on market-practice-y reasons, and gave them about 25% odds of winning.
I was wrong!1 Today Chesapeake won its lawsuit and so will be redeeming those bonds at par. To be fair The Market was wrong too, as the bonds were trading at 108ish (5.25%-ish), wider than Chesapeake’s non-callable bonds but still well north of the 100 that you’re now going to get for them. Read more »







