What Scheme Liability Really Would Have Deterred

Author:
Publish date:

It bothers the legal scholars to see the court make decisions based on policy rather than legal doctrine but we couldn't help but smile when we read Justice Anthony Kennedy noticing that the "scheme liability" scam urged on the court by trial lawyers would likely deter companies from offering securities on U.S. exchanges.
"Overseas firms with no other exposure to our securities laws could be deterred from doing business here," Kennedy wrote in the majority opinion for Stoneridge. "This, in turn, may raise the cost of being a publicly traded company under our law and shift securities offerings away from domestic capital markets."
Maybe it's not properly the court's job to worry about that but it's nice to know that someone is.

Related

In Wake Of Exec "Accidentally" Stabbing A Cab Driver, Morgan Stanley Insists You Ask, "What Would The Post Say?"

A year ago this Friday, a Morgan Stanley banker named William Bryan Jennings attended a couple holiday parties, drank a few Coors Lights, and around 10:30PM hailed a cab and asked the driver, Helmy Ammar, to take him home to Connecticut. On the way, a hungry WBJ requested they stop at G&G Deli off 10th Avenue, where he bought "a 20 oz. bottle of Aquafina water, a sandwich and some Burger King cheesy fries." As the cab entered approached Jennings' hometown of Darien, a dispute reportedly broke out as to what the fare for the ride would be. Ammar claims that they'd agreed on $204 before leaving Manhattan, but once in Connecticut, Jennings said he'd only pay $50. Jennings claims that Ammar jacked the price up to $300 and was unhappy when the banker offered $160. Another matter of he said/he said is whether or not Jennings started shouting racial slurs at Ammar and told him, "I'm going to kill you. You should go back to your country!" (Jennings denies this happened and says that Ammar locked the doors and wouldn't let him out of the cab.) The one aspect of the story that is not in dispute is that as tensions flared, WBJ whipped out a pen knife he had in his pocket. For those of you reading from Morgan Stanley, this is where the teachable moments occurs: if you ever find yourself in a situation wherein you're winding up to stab a cab driver in the hand, stop and ask yourself, "Is this going to look bad in the Post tomorrow morning?" Jennings did not and now this is happening: