Today's Dealbreaker "Reader Challenge"

Author:
Equity Private
Updated:
Jan 14, 2019
Original:
Feb 9, 2009

Grade the following statement, made in 2000 by the Honorable Louis Stanton, the judge hearing the Bernie Madoff civil case:

Second, a stock split divides only the outstanding shares of a corporation. "Delaware law, which is controlling under the terms of the Agreement, defines `outstanding' stock as that which can be voted and therefore is `construed to mean stock in the hands of shareholders, not stock in the treasury.'"

(Satterfield v. Monsanto, 88 F.Supp.2d 288, March 27, 2000).
Is His Honor correct?
If not, why not?
Extra Credit: In light of this, is Judge Stanton competent to handle the complex Madoff civil case now before him?
88 F. Supp. 2d 288.pdf
Earlier: Ponz. Boy Settles

News

As Dealbreaker historians will recall, last March marked our first Dealbreaker NCAA Tournament Challenge. It was inspired by a financial services hack who made the public announcement that he planned to (anonymously) report any colleagues he caught filling out brackets and keeping tabs on their picks during business hours. At the time, we encouraged you all to enter as many pools as were available, making it impossible for him to keep up with the amount of people and their offenses he needed to rat out, and created one to do our part. Is this guy still on the loose? He very well might be but regardless: never forget. To that end, sign up for the Second Annual Dealbreaker NCAA Tournament Challenge today. If you need reason beyond being able to say you won the DBNCAATC, first place will receive dinner for him/herself plus some colleagues and/friends at Peter Luger's, an outing funded by us,* a Greenlight Capital messenger bag, a Pershing Square golf umbrella, a pair of Third Point-branded running sneakers, and an I Heart Dealbreaker button.** The pool will once again be managed by Dealbreaker Commenter and Friend NakedShort, who, along with myself, will answer any questions you might have, provide color if warranted (rip everyone’s brackets to shreds, call out the bottom 5 performers), etc. Sign up here now.*** So it is abundantly clear, if you do not want participants to know your real name, MAKE SURE TO FILL OUT SOMETHING ELSE IN THE NAME FIELDS. For example, if your ID is Godswork, rather than writing Lloyd B, enter first name: Gods, last name: work. To that end, if you don’t want people to see your email address, from the bracket page, click ‘options’ and then ‘hide email.’ If you feel it necessary, create an entirely new email account specifically for this challenge. Finally, don’t use HisHoliness as your ID because Alan Greenspan’s already called dibs. The pool password is: animalliar Dealbreaker NCAA Tournament Challenge [CBS Sports] *Last year we offered Wall Street North favorite Beamers Cafe, but the winner had "already seen all Beamers had to offer," and choose an alternative venue. This year, feel free to think outside the box. **If any other hedge funds, private equity firms, or banks would like to be represented via swag, feel free to get in touch! ***NakedShort says you have until Thursday morning to fill out a bracket but you should just get on this ASAP.

News

Today's Dealbreaker "Reader Challenge"

The Dealbreaker Chronicle of Vending Machine Challenges

Let's Talk B-School: A Dealbreaker Reader Poll

Moron Poker Challenge

Goldman's Memory Challenged

Congratulations, Dealbreaker Readers!

Enter The Fourth Annual Dealbreaker NCAA Tournament Challenge Today

Enter The Second Annual Dealbreaker NCAA Tournament Challenge Today

Enter The First Annual Dealbreaker NCAA Tournament Challenge Today (UPDATE)