Skip to main content

What Does Mathew Martoma's Conviction Really Mean?

  • Author:
  • Updated:

So, the insider trader formerly known as Ajai Mathew Thomas has been convicted of said insider trading, just like everyone else who's been charged with it in the last five years. But forget this nobody grain of sand. How does it impact his former boss and conversation partner?

Answer: Probably not at all.

From a public relations standpoint, his conviction signifies another blow for Cohen, who had already been forced to drop all of his clients in converting SAC Capital into an investment vehicle for his $9 billion fortune.

Unless prosecutors leverage yesterday’s verdict to convince Martoma to turn against his former boss, however, his conviction is likely to have little bearing in their on-going pursuit of Cohen.

On the other hand, maybe?

There’s nothing like the prospect of prison time to make one reconsider one’s choices.

In the wake of the guilty verdict Thursday in the insider trading case against former hedge fund manager Mathew Martoma, prosecutors will certainly make another attempt to “flip” him–he is the most likely source of evidence, if any exists, of wrongdoing by Steven Cohen, the founder of the beleaguered SAC Capital Advisors. But for Martoma, who has never claimed to have any evidence against Cohen, it may be too late to make a deal to stay out of jail….

Still, at 39-years-old, Martoma may be eager to do what he can to pare down the potential 45-year maximum sentence that comes with his conviction on the three counts.

Either way, it gave us a newly-expanded infographic with Steve Cohen's face in the middle.

What it means for Mr. Martoma is a good deal clearer: Up to a decade in prison, the need for a really good appellate lawyer and the end of a American Dream realized.

Mathew Martoma had been on his way to being another American success story. Today, he is the eighth person who once worked for the hedge fund titan Steven A. Cohen to be convicted of insider trading….

The son of immigrant parents from India, Mr. Martoma, 39, graduated from Duke, attended Harvard Law School and earned an M.B.A. from Stanford Business School before he landed a job as portfolio manager at SAC, one of the most successful hedge funds in the world….

Until his arrest in November 2012, Mr. Martoma had seemingly checked off all the boxes on the path to success. At SAC, he earned a $9.3 million bonus in 2008, which enabled him and his wife to buy a $1.9 million home in Boca Raton, Fla., for themselves and their three young children.

But much of Mr. Martoma’s adult life was checkered with cheating.

About that….

Former Harvard Law student and SAC Capital Advisors portfolio manager Mathew Martoma was found guilty of two counts of securities fraud and one count of conspiracy to commit securities fraud Thursday afternoon. The 39-year-old Martoma faces a maximum sentence of 45 years….

During the court proceedings, it was also discovered that Martoma was expelled from Harvard Law School in 1999 for creating a false transcript and using it to apply for clerkships with federal judges….

Expulsions of such a nature are incredibly rare at Harvard Law School, according to Law School professor Alan M. Dershowitz. Dershowitz said that the Martoma case was a once-in-a-decade event in an interview with Bloomberg News last month.

Martoma's downfall made the pages of his alma mater's student newspaper (even if they spelled his name wrong), as well as that of the university that counts Steve Cohen as a trustee. As for the graduate school that didn't throw Martoma out? Well, it seems they've never heard of him.

And before we close the book on Martoma (for this week, anyway), let's give it up for the immortal Preet Bharara on his 79-peat.

Former SAC Capital Advisor portfolio manager Mathew Martoma was found guilty of insider trading on Thursday — bringing US Attorney Preet Bharara’s record in his five-year-old Wall Street probe to 79-0….

“In the short run, cheating may have been profitable for Martoma, but in the end, it made him a convicted felon, and likely will result in the forfeiture of his illegal windfall and the loss of his liberty,” Bharara said in a statement after the verdict….

Bharara’s probe has shaken the hedge-fund world and its relationship with so-called expert networks, where much of the inside tips originated. Six hedge funds — including SAC Capital — were shuttered by the probe.

Martoma is one of 11 inside traders ensnared in Bharara’s dragnet who’ve gone to trial — and the second from SAC.

Of the 78 prior convictions, seven were present or former SAC employees. Six pled guilty, as did the firm.

Martoma Prosecutors Bask in Victory Over a Grain of Sand [Bloomberg/Matt]
What Does Martoma's Conviction Mean For SAC Capital's Steven Cohen? [Forbes]
New Guilty Verdict Could Be Bad News For SAC Capital's Steven Cohen [Time]
The Cohen Connections [DealBook]
Now, the Sentencing for Martoma [DealBook, w/ bonus pic of Raj Rajaratnam]
Martoma faces loss of home, millions in forfeiture [USA Today via LoHud]
Dershowitz: Martoma Needs a Good Appellate Lawyer [Bloomberg TV]
Ex-SAC Trader Convicted of Securities Fraud [DealBook]
Former Law Student Martoma Convicted of Insider trading in SAC Case [Harvard Crimson]
Trustee's former employee convicted [Brown Daily Herald]
New notch for Preet as Martoma is convicted of insider trading [NYPost]


Mathew Martoma Got a Lot of E-Mails

So his lawyer gets 90 more days to read them.

By Federal Bureau of Prisons ( [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons

Mathew Martoma Isn’t Getting Out Of Jail

In trying, though, he did get the definition of insider-trading broadened again. So there’s that.