Andrew Ross Sorkin Smells Something Fishy

Author:
Updated:
Original:

Late last week, Botox-maker Allergan Inc sued Valeant Pharmaceuticals and Pershing Square, alleging the latter two had engaged in insider trading when Pershing bought $1 billion worth of Allergan shares ahead of a takeover offer by the hedge fund and Valeant. On the suggestion of wrongdoing, Valeant called with charges "baseless," while Ackman stated in a press release that "This is a shameless attempt by Allergan to delay the shareholders' fundamental right to call a special meeting and vote their shares. Allergan is threatened by our progress toward calling the special meeting. This scorched-earth approach is further evidence of the board's and management's further entrenchment."

Not entirely convinced? Dealbook's Andrew Ross Sorkin, who in his column today says WAIT JUST A SECOND, PEOPLE.

There was no secret phone call or briefcase full of money. Instead, Valeant’s chief executive, J. Michael Pearson, called Mr. Ackman directly and told him about his company’s intent, seeking a partnership of sorts in which Mr. Ackman would build a large position in Allergan stock and help Valeant press Allergan’s board to acquiesce to a deal...Still, something hasn’t smelled right about these clever machinations. An analyst at Sanford C. Bernstein quite rightly titled a report “How Can It Be Legal?” [...] Whatever the case, Valeant and Mr. Ackman’s actions, at least from a public policy perspective, may have been too clever by half. When Sanford C. Bernstein wrote a note to clients at the time the offer was first announced, it described Pershing Square as having found an opportunity for “regulatory arbitrage.” Now a judge will decide whether it was truly regulatory arbitrage or something more sinister.

Ackman and Valeant’s Bid for Botox Maker May Be Too Clever to Be Legal [Dealbook]

Related

Valeant Pharmaceuticals Finds A Weird Way To Kick Bill Ackman When He's Down

Well, maybe not "weird," but certainly painful and right to the jugular.

Bill Ackman Doesn't Think Valeant's Awesomeness Has Been Adequately Conveyed

There's simply no other way to explain what's happening there.

Hold Bill Ackman's Calls

The hedge fund manager is having A DAY.