Skip to main content

Jes Staley Is Having A Very John Cryan Day, As Is John Cryan

No one deserves to feel like Deutsche Bank, not even Deutsche Bank.
  • Author:
  • Updated:
Getty Images

Getty Images

It's fitting that the big European banks report well after all the big U.S. ones are done presenting earnings. Otherwise the contrast would elicit an inflated sense of accomplishment among traders stateside, whose performance in this maddeningly low-vol period isn't as poor as it could be (with some exceptions) but certainly isn't anything to write home about. But even so, the Jamies and Lloyds of the world must be feeling alright about this:

Revenue from trading bonds and stocks plunged 30 percent at Deutsche Bank and 31 percent at Barclays, the lenders reported Thursday. That’s twice the 15 percent average decline of their largest U.S. peers. For Barclays, its the worst performance since Staley took charge.

No one expected these two banks to blow it out of the water in the third quarter, but these results are pretty Deutsche Bank, even for Deutsche Bank. But while their trading revenues came out relatively similarly, the John Cryan and Jes Staley are coming from two opposite directions when it comes to their investment banking strategy.

The Barclays CEO has spent the last year “doubling down” on the investment bank that his predecessor had declared dead, hiring new traders and pumping in resources as the rest of the bank got whittled down. Thursday's news doesn't change that bet:

“We’re not going to change our strategy,” Staley said. “You cannot cut yourself to glory and those that have tried to do that will ultimately fail.”

Cryan has been doing the opposite, gently smothering units of the German bank's trading division in the night until just a few more affordable desks remain. That strategy – a reversal of a reversal – has conveniently helped bring costs down in line with persistently sinking revenue, but only at the cost of driving refugees to greener pastures and making everyone else a Deutsche feel like scheiße. Yet, as Cryan assures us, there is light at the end of this long, dark tunnel:

Mr. Cryan said Thursday in a statement that the bank has made “significant progress” in turnaround plans. “We are convinced that the benefits of our efforts will step-by-step become more apparent in the coming quarters and years,” he said.

Whatever the causes, the results raise the perennial question of how it is Cryan and Staley can hold onto their jobs (particularly the latter, given his recent naughtiness). Their positions aren't enviable, and much of the dysfunction they're up against preceded each of their arrivals, but eventually investors expect something other than “it's not so bad if you squint.”

Deutsche, Barclays Feel the Investment Bank Burn (WSJ)
Trading Drought at Deutsche Bank, Barclays Adds Pressure on CEOs (BBG)


(Getty Images for Yahoo Finance)

Jes Staley Really Showed Us

Barclays’ chief gets to keep his investment bank and his job.

(Getty Images for Yahoo Finance)

Jes Staley Is Very Sorry For Launching A Transatlantic Vigilante Crusade Against A Disloyal Whistleblower

Saying mean things about the boss is apparently one of the few things you can't get away with at Barclays.

(Getty Images for Yahoo Finance)

Jes Staley’s ‘I Told You So’ Tour Rolls On

Barclays had another quarter in which its I-bank wasn’t too embarrassing.

(Getty Images for Yahoo Finance)

Time For Jes Staley To Launch Another Renegade Witch Hunt

Add "duped by an obviously phony email" to the Barclays CEO's list of achievements.

(Getty Images for Yahoo Finance)

Today In Things That Do Not Augur Well For Jes Staley…

You launch one little transatlantic vigilante anti-whisteblower crusade and look what happens.


John Cryan Fully Committed To Flagellating Himself For The Next Two Years

No one else may want to be at Deutsche Bank, but the chief wants to go down with the ship.

(Getty Images for Yahoo Finance)

Jes Staley Enjoying Rare Moment Of Non-Outright Hostility

Throwing a few extra pence his shareholders’ has him moving up from John Cryan levels of popularity to the Brian Moynihan-esque.