Calling Something A Ponzi Scheme May Or May Not Enjoy First Amendment Protection In Texas

Much to his chagrin, Kyle Bass is going to find out the hard way.
Author:
Updated:
Original:

A couple of years ago, an anonymous report hit the interwebs stating that a frequently-sued Texas REIT, United Development Funding, was perhaps being sued because it was running a Ponzi scheme. In the months after, UDF got raided by the FBI and received a Wells notice, the broker-dealers that sold its REITs were sued themselves, and the anonymous writer was revealed to be none other than Kyle Bass. This did not make UDF happy, so—in spite of the raiding and the getting sued and all the rest of it—it decided to do some suing of its own, specifically of Kyle Bass, for wrongly accusing the firm of misappropriating funds and claiming phony real-estate developments and running worthless funds and, of course, being a Ponzi scheme. Bass and his hedge fund, Hayman Capital, shot back that it was all just, like, their opinion, man, and opinions count as free speech, so back the hell off. The Texas courts are not so sure.

billofrights

The Defendants… argued that the Defendants were exercising rights of free speech in publishing negative material concerning UDF’s business—first anonymously and then on a proprietary website—and that the speech was made without actual malice…. After an extended evidentiary hearing, the Court ruled in favor of UDF, and has allowed the lawsuit to proceed to trial….

“The limited discovery granted by the Court allowed us to see this coordinated plan documented in the emails and texts of Bass and Hayman. We intend to pursue the lawsuit to trial as expeditiously as possible, and we look forward to our day in court.”

Ellen Cirangle, counsel for UDF, stated, “In all the cases that I have done, I have never seen such extensive dissemination of negative information about a company, including through anonymous postings.”

UDF Lawsuit Against Kyle Bass and Hayman Capital Will Proceed [press release]

Related

By SteeleatHaymanCapitalManagementLP (Own work) [CC BY-SA 4.0], via Wikimedia Commons

Kyle Bass Barred From Making Stuff Up About Lawyers For REIT He Accuses Of Making Stuff Up

Is it a good idea to piss off the judge presiding over your case this much? It seems like it might not be a good idea.

By SteeleatHaymanCapitalManagementLP (Own work) [CC BY-SA 4.0], via Wikimedia Commons

Frequently-Sued Texas REIT Sues Kyle Bass

There are enough bad things to say about United Development Funding available without making others up, according to United Development Funding.

By SteeleatHaymanCapitalManagementLP (Own work) [CC BY-SA 4.0], via Wikimedia Commons

Did Kyle Bass Go A Little Too Far In Trashing Fraudulent REIT?

I mean, the SEC is grateful for his help, but did he have to use the words “Ponzi scheme”?

Kyle Bass Crusader

Kyle Bass Certain His Sinophobic Dreams Are About To Come True

For real this time, you guys. He’s staking his fortune and reputation on it.

Greeks

Kyle Bass Plans Celebratory Toga Party For Sometime Next Year

These Greek banks are gonna blow up once voters throw these red bums out.

By Chris Potter (Flickr: 3D Judges Gavel) [CC BY 2.0], via Wikimedia Commons

Hedge Fund Manager In Jail For Ponzi Scheming Won’t Get Out For Lawyer’s Horndogging

Keenan Hauke’s attorney may have been blinded by desire for his client’s wife, but Hauke should have said something about that earlier.