Supreme Court To Consider Whether Financial Fraudsters Should Be Allowed To Just, You Know, Get Away With It - Dealbreaker

There is much hyperventilating at the moment about the Supreme Court’s plan to once again consider whether or not toss the Affordable Care Act into the dustbin of history. But before John Roberts & co. do that, they first have to decide whether a substantial chunk of the financial regulatory structure of the United States should precede it.

The case turns on the claim that courts for decades have ordered defendants in SEC cases to give back money earned illegally despite lacking authority from Congress to order such measures….

Critics say the SEC has used disgorgement too expansively. In cases such as Ponzi schemes, for instance, the SEC has asked defendants to turn over all proceeds, even if some money was paid to other actors, such as brokers, who might not have known about the fraud.

Some justices showed unease with how the SEC uses disgorgement in the Kokesh case.

The court will hear oral arguments Tuesday on whether a Democratic-led Congress exceeded constitutional boundaries in 2010 when it created the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau….

“I will be surprised if there aren’t five votes to invalidate the CFPB’s current structure,” said University of Illinois law-school dean Vikram Amar. The question, he said, may boil down to how far conservatives want to go in embracing the theory that almost everyone who exercises authority in the executive branch is answerable to the president.

Well, we certainly don’t have to wait to see what the consequences of that would be.

Supreme Court to Consider SEC’s Power to Win Funds for Cheated Investors [WSJ]
CFPB Case Heads to Supreme Court This Week [WSJ]
Supreme Court to Hear Obamacare Appeal [NYT]

Related

Quit hiding behind the bench. By Phil Roeder (Flickr: Supreme Court of the United States) [CC BY 2.0], via Wikimedia Commons

Supreme Court: Disgorgement Still A Thing, But Not As Much Of A Thing As SEC Would Like

The real winner here is John Roberts, who made everyone happy. Except Clarence Thomas.

biden

Supreme Court Orders Joe Biden To Fire CFPB Director On Jan. 20

The CFPB is alive if unwell, and may be ready to get back to business early next year.

Quit hiding behind the bench. By Phil Roeder (Flickr: Supreme Court of the United States) [CC BY 2.0], via Wikimedia Commons

True To Form, Deutsche Bank Loses For Winning In Trump Supreme Court Rulings

Someone at the Frankfurt mailroom might want to keep an eye out for envelopes postmarked Albany and Manhattan.

By Elisa.rolle (Own work) [CC BY-SA 3.0], via Wikimedia Commons

Hillary Clinton’s Supreme Court Shortlist To Decide If MetLife Is Too Big To Fail

MetLife might want to consider writing a few more checks to a Hillary SuperPAC or twelve.

(Getty Images)

Supreme Court Will Probably Let Some People See Trump’s Tax Returns, As If It Matters

Get ready for the most eagerly-sought grand jury duty in history.

Supremes Set To Smack SEC on Statutes of Limitations

Things aren't going well for you when you find yourself at the receiving end of sharp words from both Supreme Court Justices Antonin Scalia and Ruth Bader Ginsberg. Well, that's where the SEC finds itself in its effort to read a five-year statute of limitations creatively.