Skip to main content

Back in October, the creators of Showtime’s “Billions” dodged a bullet: A federal judge watched their terrible show, and found no similarity between its character Wendy Rhoades and the real-life Denise Shull beyond their gender and jobs, neither of which are, apparently, copyrightable. But then, according to Shull, Andrew Ross Sorkin & co. got cocky and started having Maggie Siff, who plays the allegedly-not-fictitious-enough hedge fund performance coach and dominatrix, dress suspiciously like Shull, just to stick it to her, as Shull saw it.

Now it was Shull’s turn to get cocky. After all, she’d filed an amended complaint against the Billionsaires, and was delighted to see them “playing chicken with the court.”

Well, U.S. District Judge George Daniels is either no fashionista or the contents of one’s closet are no more open to copyright than one’s job description, because he remains distinctly unimpressed, and Shull remains distinctly uncompensated for all of those questions about whether she, too, employs a riding crop.

"Plaintiffs do not offer any specific information that this Court apparently overlooked that would cause this Court to reach an alternative conclusion," he writes in the order, which is posted below. "Instead, Plaintiffs simply reassert the same or similar arguments they previously made, and this Court previously rejected, despite the Court's thorough review at the motion to dismiss phase."

‘Billions’ Battle Won’t Be Reconsidered by Judge [The Hollywood Reporter]



‘Billions’ Now Accused Of Closet Infringement

The real-life Wendy Rhoades is only a dominatrix in the courtroom.


Inspiration For ‘Billions’ Dominatrix Wins In Court Of Public Opinion

Which is to say she lost in the actual court of the Second Circuit. Soundly.


‘Billions’-Based Courtroom Costume Drama To Return Long Before ‘Billions’

Shull v. Sorkin is coming back to a courtroom near you (if you live in Manhattan), and to a livestream for everyone else.


There's One Thing 'Billions' Gets Right

While her case proved unsuccessful, she has graciously offered to discuss her experiences and frustrations with the litigation process.


It Doesn’t Look Like There Will Be A Second Season Of ‘Billions’ Wardrobe Drama

It’s never good when a federal judge cuts your lawyer off with, “That’s enough.”


If 'Billions' Hadn't Made The Character She Inspired A Dominatrix, Maybe Denise Shull Wouldn't Have Sued Them

Denise Shull sued 'Billions' on a variety of claims arising in IP. Here are her thoughts.


‘Billions’ Gets A Dozen More Chances To Mess With Local Hedge Fund Performance Coach

Denise Shull can’t shake her fictionalized self next year—or the year after.