When a short-seller has something unkind to say about a company, there is something a script the target follows. The short seller is engaged in “blatant market manipulation.” The usually very long and detailed report he wrote is “replete with misleading information and salacious accusations” and “inaccurate and unfounded.” “Full of ignorance, errors” and “false allegations leveled by outside detractors.” “Haters gonna hate.” All lies. Fake news. Nothing to see here. And then move on and hope things blow over.

But how do you know if any of them are telling the truth? Hell, Lordstown Motors CEO Steve Burns said one of those things, you know, right before getting canned for “issues regarding the accuracy of certain statements regarding the company’s pre-orders,” the very statements that short-seller Hindenburg Research called “largely fictitious”? How do you know whether they will, in fact, blow over? (In most of the above-linked cases, they very much did not.)

Well, here’s one (very slow and expensive) way to show you mean what you say.

Quinton Mathews, who published his research on companies online under the pseudonym Rota Fortunae, will pay Farmland Partners "a multiple" of the profits on his short bet in 2018, according to the terms of the legal settlement announced late on Sunday. His research had helped wipe as much as US$115 million (S$154 million) off Farmland's market value…. Mr Mathews conceded that "many of the key statements" in a report he published on website Seeking Alpha targeting Farmland - including allegations of dubious related-party transactions and the risk of insolvency - were wrong….

"It's highly unusual and refreshing to see a company take on this fight, because most will take the short-term blow of the attack without pursuing legal vindication," [attorney Jacob] Frenkel said…. Farmland's litigation against a hedge fund firm that paid Mr Mathews for research, Sabrepoint Capital Management, continues.

'I regret any harm:' Short seller compensates target in rare move [Reuters]

For more of the latest in litigation, regulation, deals and financial services trends, sign up for Finance Docket, a partnership between Breaking Media publications Above the Law and Dealbreaker.

Related

By Chris Potter (Flickr: 3D Judges Gavel) [CC BY 2.0], via Wikimedia Commons

Hedge Fund Sues Target Company For Being Mean To It

Also lying and trying to manipulate a proxy contest, but are those even still illegal in Donald Trump’s America?

nikola truck

Nikola Statements That Short Seller Report Was Full Of Inaccuracies Appear Themselves To Be Full Of Inaccuracies

That whole bit about the “so-called ‘report’ replete with misleading information”? Yea, we might have spoken too soon about that.

By Chris Potter (Flickr: 3D Judges Gavel) [CC BY 2.0], via Wikimedia Commons

Ex-Hedge Fund Manager Better Hope The Next Judge He Sees Doesn’t Think He’s A Thief And A Liar

Because that judge will be the one fulfilling his prophecy about going to jail.

teslacrash

Hedge Fund Finds Two Ways To Lose Money On Tesla

Non-recourse legal loans to those seemingly intent on undermining their legal claims are an even worse bet than a Tesla short.

citi-frown

Hedge Fund Very Eager To Do Business With Very Incompetent Bank

We suppose it’s the really the least they could do.