Skip to main content

The current chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission has made it his mission to erase the work of his predecessor from the historical and regulatory record. But Jay Clayton’s name will live on in the most appropriate way imaginable: the survival of his bit of petty vengeance against the stock exchanges which gave him such trouble during his SEC tenure.

The judges…. refused to vacate a separate provision limiting the voting power of large exchange groups that own multiple marketplaces.

The judges also left in place another provision that had been contested by the exchanges, under which the firms that administer the SIPs must be independent of exchange groups that sell stock-market data products. Currently, the country’s two SIPs are administered by NYSE and Nasdaq, and the provision would dislodge them from that role.

Those kinds of restrictions are exactly the sort of thing that seem likely to remain after current SEC chief Gary Gensler’s complete restructuring of stock market operations (although whether they’ll withstand the Supreme Court’s opinion that federal agencies can’t do anything is less sure). Unfortunately, and not for the first time, Clayton’s carelessness about what the laws he was charged with implementing and enforcing actually say mean the new rules are slightly less onerous (and less costly) than he had hoped.

Judge Karen LeCraft Henderson vacated the provision of the SEC order giving seats on the SIP committees to representatives of non-exchange firms. She agreed with NYSE, Nasdaq and Cboe’s argument that federal law only allowed the data feeds to be run by the exchanges and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, which also has a seat on the committees. The provision is “unreasonable and therefore invalid,” Judge Henderson wrote.

Nasdaq, NYSE Win Court Battle With SEC Over Market Data [WSJ]

For more of the latest in litigation, regulation, deals and financial services trends, sign up for Finance Docket, a partnership between Breaking Media publications Above the Law and Dealbreaker.

Related

(Getty Images)

Literally No One Likes SEC Hedge Fund Secrecy Plan, Except The People Who Run The SEC

That’s a big, “Thanks, but no thanks” from the hedge funds on getting rid of most 13Fs.

(Getty Images)

SEC Making Sure Gary Gensler Will Feel Right At Home

You can authorize and investigation and you can authorize an investigation and you and you and you, too!

Uh, where is everybody? where did they go? this is a long caption. really long. does it wrap? By Kevin Hutchinson (Flickr) [CC BY 2.0], via Wikimedia Commons

Stock Exchanges Don’t Have To Do Thing They Very Much Don’t Want To At Their Own Expense

If the SEC wants to know how rebates impact stock trading, they’ll have to figure it out themselves.

robinhood

Robinhood Giving Shares To Its Poor Users, Sending The Rich (Those Companies) The Bill

As with everything else it does, regulators are getting ready to pull the plug.

(Getty Images)

Stale Hedge Fund Holdings Reports Saved From SEC’s Senseless Scalpel

Getting rid of most 13Fs proves too unpopular even for someone with nothing to lose like Jay Clayton.

(Getty Images)

Jay Clayton Wheeling-And-Dealing His Way Out The Door

Preet Bharara or Gary Gensler might not have much to do come Jan. 20.