Skip to main content

We here at Dealbreaker are skeptical about the mortality of the carried interest loophole. Understandably so, we’d argue: For more than a dozen years, we’ve been listening to confident pronouncements that the wildly unpopular and even more wildly unjust bit of the tax code allowing hedge and private equity fund managers to pay a lower rate on the vast majority of their income than basically anyone else is about to finally go, in one way or another, but one party or the other. And then it just, well, doesn’t, for, you know, reasons.

Now, however, we’re promised that one miracle shall beget another. Nay, not merely beget but be an integral part of the miracle, specifically that after a year-and-a-half of bickering and infighting almost certain to consign them to minority status come November, Chuck Schumer has finally convinced Sen. Joe Manchin that doing something is better than nothing. And Manchin says he’ll go back to doing nothing unless he gets to do in the carried-interest loophole.

Mr. Manchin told reporters Thursday that he was adamant about the carried-interest language and wasn’t prepared to lose it.

“People that have benefited from carried interest for years and years and years knew that they had a good run,” he said. “It was long overdue to get rid of and you couldn’t justify it any more.”

Cue the celebrations! After 15 years, a thing that could never really be justified in the first place is finally going down for the dirt nap.

“Sometimes it actually is impossible to permanently defend the indefensible,” said Jason Furman, who has argued for changing the law as a think-tank expert, Obama campaign adviser, White House aide and economics professor over the past 15 years…. “We have been pursuing its demise for years and there is no excuse to allow it to continue,” [Rep. Bill Pascrell (D-N.J.)] said.

Except, well, it’s sort of going to continue.

[The Schumer-Manchin deal] would not eliminate the loophole entirely and could still allow rich business executives to have smaller tax bills than their secretaries…. It would extend that holding period to five years from three, while changing the way the period is calculated in hopes of reducing taxpayers’ ability to game the system and pay the lower 20 percent tax rate…. The longer holding period would only apply to those who make $400,000 per year or more….

But even that sort-of closing of the loophole is a done deal, right?

It was dropped out of the House tax bill last year after [Sen. Kyrsten] Sinema indicated she opposed ending the tax break…. Sinema’s office has so far declined to comment on the legislation. She did not attend a Senate Democratic Caucus meeting Thursday to discuss the deal, according to a senator in attendance.

Democrats Ready Carried-Interest Tax Hike After 15-Year Lobbying Campaign [WSJ]
Carried Interest Is Back in the Headlines. What Would a New Tax Proposal Do? [NYT]
Manchin says he is firm on closing tax loophole; Sinema absent from caucus meeting [The Hill]
In a major boost to Democrats, Manchin and Schumer announce deal for energy and health care bill [CNN]

For more of the latest in litigation, regulation, deals and financial services trends, sign up for Finance Docket, a partnership between Breaking Media publications Above the Law and Dealbreaker.



Thing That Was Never Going To Happen Is Not Going To Happen

The carried-interest loophole lives! The Democrats’ climate-tax compromise maybe not so much.


Instead Of Closing Carried-Interest Loophole, Democrats Would Just Make It A Real Pain In The Ass

Of course, neither that plan nor the larger bill of which it is a part is going anywhere, but it’s nice to know all the same.

Getty Images

Oh, Look, Another Doomed Proposal To Kill The Carried-Interest Loophole

A tale as old as time. Or, at least, as old as this website.

Bill ackman beach

Bill Ackman Takes Bold Position That He Should Pay More In Taxes

The people’s hedge-fund manager has had it with the carried-interest loophole.

Mnuchin Lampert

Hedge Fund Managers Forced To Find Creative New Way To Avoid Paying Taxes

The loophole in the carried-interest loophole is closed, for now.

Tax on Carried Interest Moving Closer to Reality

A new proposal to tax carried interest as ordinary income was just attached to a larger tax and spending bill that could be voted on by the House as early as tomorrow.

Screen Shot 2019-07-08 at 12.11.30 PM

Leon Black Did Nothing Wrong, Will Stop Being Apollo CEO Anyway

He did do twice as much not wrong as previously reported, and is almost 70, so…